Abstract:Under the influence of fiscal federalism and government decentralization theories, a significant part of health systems around the world confronted the COVID-19 pandemic after being shaped or re-shaped by processes of devolution from central to local governments. Procurement of key supplies is one of the components that operate in a decentralized manner, forcing local governments to compete against each other. This was the origin of what has been called the “bidding wars” between subnational governments at the beginning of the pandemic response. These wars led to centralization policies in the United States, the United Kingdom, and the European Union. Yet, less is known about cases from the Global South. By analyzing the procurement of Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) in the 320 Chilean municipalities in charge of primary health, this research provides evidence of the impacts of horizontal government competition on the ability to procure key supplies. In Chile, during the 2020 response to the pandemic, richer municipalities were able to procure more face masks per population, while economies of scale rewarded bigger purchases with lower prices. The authors support the theoretical notion of “concurrency” as a concept that adds nuances to the centralization-decentralization debate. In Chile, for instance, while testing and tracking required decentralization, PPE purchases could have probably benefited from centralization in order to avoid reproducing territorial inequalities. Sob a influência do federalismo fiscal e das teorias de descentralização governamental, uma parte significativa dos sistemas de saúde em todo o mundo enfrentou a pandemia da COVID-19 depois de terem sido moldados ou remodelados por processos de transferência dos governos centrais para os governos locais. A aquisição de suprimentos essenciais é um dos componentes que operam de forma descentralizada, forçando os governos locais a competir entre si. Esta foi a origem do que foi chamado de “guerras de licitações” entre governos subnacionais no início da resposta à pandemia. Essas guerras levaram a políticas de centralização nos Estados Unidos, no Reino Unido e na União Europeia. No entanto, sabe-se menos sobre os casos do Sul Global. Ao analisar a aquisição de Equipamentos de Proteção Individual (EPI) nos 320 municípios chilenos responsáveis pela saúde primária, esta pesquisa fornece evidências dos impactos da competição governamental horizontal na capacidade de adquirir suprimentos essenciais. No Chile, durante a resposta à pandemia de 2020, os municípios mais ricos conseguiram adquirir mais máscaras faciais por população, enquanto as economias de escala recompensaram compras maiores com preços mais baixos. Os autores apoiam a noção teórica de simultaneidade como um conceito que acrescenta nuances ao debate centralização-descentralização. No Chile, por exemplo, embora os testes e o acompanhamento exigissem a descentralização, as compras de EPI poderiam provavelmente ter beneficiado da centralização, a fim de evitar a reprodução de desigualdades territoriais.

Decentralization: A handicap in fighting the COVID‐19 pandemic? The response of the regional governments in Spain

Assessing the Multi-level Government Response to the COVID-19 Crisis: Italy and Spain Compared

The Return of Decentralization Greek Local Government Response to the COVID-19 Pandemic

Spanish Healthcare Sector Management in the COVID-19 Crisis Under the Perspective of Austrian Economics and New-Institutional Economics

On the association between COVID-19 vaccination levels and incidence and lethality rates at a regional scale in Spain

[Insight on how to assess and improve the response to the COVID-19 pandemic]

Hospitalization burden and epidemiology of the COVID-19 pandemic in Spain (2020-2021)

Variations in Governmental Responses to and the Diffusion of COVID-19: the Role of Political Decentralization

Austerity Measures and Underfunding of the Spanish Health System during the COVID-19 Pandemic-Perception of Healthcare Staff in Spain

Transforming health care systems towards high-performance organizations: qualitative study based on learning from COVID-19 pandemic in the Basque Country (Spain)

The Role of Functional Urban Areas in the Spread of COVID-19 Omicron (Northern Spain)

Exploring COVID-19 research credibility among Spanish scientists

Local health systems resilience in managing the COVID-19 pandemic: lessons from Mexico

Shutting Down to Save Lives: A Regression Discontinuity Analysis of Non-Essential Business Closure

Trust and accountability in times of crisis

Fiscal decentralization, intergovernmental mobility, and the innovativeness of local governments' policy response in COVID‐19: Evidence from China

COVID-19 and Public Health Spending; Effects on the Economic Sustainability of the Spanish Private Healthcare System

Social Determinants, Urban Planning, and Covid-19 Response: Evidence From Quito, Ecuador

Effectiveness of the contingency plan for social and health care during the COVID-19 pandemic in a health district in northwestern Spain

Exploring the roles of local mobility patterns, socioeconomic conditions, and lockdown policies in shaping the patterns of COVID-19 spread

Bidding against each other: local procurement of personal protective equipment in the context of decentralization and high socio-economic inequality