Abstract:There are numerous evidence showing that consumers usually experience emotional dissonance (e.g. purchase regret) and anticipate it in consideration set formation process. Our paper investigates how anticipated regret affects consumers' consideration set formation and the relevant implications on sellers' price and assortment competition. We adopt a parallel search paradigm to explore how consumers form their consideration sets and use search depth and search breadth to alleviate anticipated regret, and to check how sellers optimally choose their prices and assortment sizes accordingly. Intuitively, regret not only lowers consumer surplus but also intensifies sellers' competition as consumers have incentive to include more competitive alternatives in consideration set to alleviate regret. However, our findings show that these intuitions may not always hold when search depth (i.e., the number of attributes to evaluate) is a choice. Specifically, we show that sellers may benefit from anticipated regret as it encourages consumers 1) to evaluate more product attributes (i.e., a deeper search depth) to alleviate regret (which increases consumers' willingness to pay); 2) to include less sellers to save search costs (which soften sellers' competition). Surprisingly, our results also show that anticipated regret can achieve a ``win-win-win situation for consumers, sellers and social planner. We further explore sellers' assortment and price competition in reaction to anticipated regret, and demonstrate that sellers engage in assortment competition when regret intensity is low but price competition when it is high. Lastly, we show that both search cost and assortment may amplify the benefits of anticipated regret. Our analytic results provide potential interpretation to customers' search behavior under ecommerce environment and could guide sellers' assortment strategy and platform's search environment design.

Regret Is Born Where Choice Dies

Regret: A Model of Its Antecedents and Consequences in Consumer Decision Making

Regret and Behavior: Comment on Zeelenberg and Pieters

Cognitive Mechanism and Neural Substrate of Regret

Regret and the Consciousness of the Past

Price and Assortment Competition under Consideration Set Formation: the Role of Anticipated Regret

Ignorance is Bliss: A Game of Regret

“I Am Regretful but I Would Not Change My Decision”: the Dissociation Between Emotional Regret and Behavioural Regret in Children

Consumer Search with Anticipated Regret

A Research on Factors Influencing Decision Regret

Reining in regret: emotion regulation modulates regret in decision making

Is the Effect of Justifications on Regret Direct or Indirect?

On the Logical Structure of Regret

Review of Regret Theory

Regret and the Negative Evaluation of Decision Outcomes in Major Depression

A very public replication of the temporal pattern to people's regrets

Remembering and Regretting: The Zeigarnik Effect and the Cognitive Availability of Regrettable Actions and Inactions

Regret theory under fear of the unknown

Regret causes ego-depletion and finding benefits in the regrettable events alleviates ego-depletion.

The Effects of Superior Outcome of the Foregone Option on the Relationship Between Responsibility and Regret

The Influence of Psychological Distance on Regret