Abstract:Macphail's comparative approach to intelligence focused on associative processes, an orientation inconsistent with more multifaceted lay and scientific understandings of the term. His ultimate emphasis on associative processes indicated few differences in intelligence among vertebrates. We explore options more attuned to common definitions by considering intelligence in terms of richness of representations of the world, the interconnectivity of those representations, the ability to flexibly change those connections, and knowledge. We focus on marine mammals, represented by the amphibious pinnipeds and the aquatic cetaceans and sirenians, as animals that transitioned from a terrestrial existence to an aquatic one, experiencing major changes in ecological pressures. They adapted with morphological transformations related to streamlining the body, physiological changes in respiration and thermoregulation, and sensory/perceptual changes, including echolocation capabilities and diminished olfaction in many cetaceans, both in-air and underwater visual focus, and enhanced senses of touch in pinnipeds and sirenians. Having a terrestrial foundation on which aquatic capacities were overlaid likely affected their cognitive abilities, especially as a new reliance on sound and touch, and the need to surface to breath changed their interactions with the world. Vocal and behavioral observational learning capabilities in the wild and in laboratory experiments suggest versatility in group coordination. Empirical reports on aspects of intelligent behavior like problem-solving, spatial learning, and concept learning by various species of cetaceans and pinnipeds suggest rich cognitive abilities. The high energy demands of the brain suggest that brain-intelligence relationships might be fruitful areas for study when specific hypotheses are considered, e.g., brain mapping indicates hypertrophy of specific sensory areas in marine mammals. Modern neuroimaging techniques provide ways to study neural connectivity, and the patterns of connections between sensory, motor, and other cortical regions provide a biological framework for exploring how animals represent and flexibly use information in navigating and learning about their environment. At this stage of marine mammal research, it would still be prudent to follow Macphail's caution that it is premature to make strong comparative statements without more empirical evidence, but an approach that includes learning more about how animals flexibly link information across multiple representations could be a productive way of comparing species by allowing them to use their specific strengths within comparative tasks.

Understanding across the senses: cross-modal studies of cognition in cetaceans

Spontaneous establishing of cross-modal stimulus equivalence in a beluga whale

Equivalence classification, learning by exclusion, and long-term memory in pinnipeds: cognitive mechanisms demonstrated through research with subjects under human care and in the field

Cetacean Translation Initiative: a roadmap to deciphering the communication of sperm whales

The Dynamic Multisensory Engram: Neural Circuitry Underlying Crossmodal Object Recognition in Rats Changes with the Nature of Object Experience

Reflections on Cross-Modal Correspondences: Current Understanding and Issues for Future Research

Invariant crossmodal equivalence evokes visual imagery from sounds in rhesus monkeys

Lessons learned in animal acoustic cognition through comparisons with humans

The Relevance of Ecological Transitions to Intelligence in Marine Mammals

Effects of experience and familiarity on visual attention and behaviours of bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus) in presence of humans

Cognition of the manatee: past research and future developments

Chimpanzees process structural isomorphisms across sensory modalities

Possible limitations of dolphin echolocation: a simulation study based on a cross-modal matching experiment

Information-seeking across auditory scenes by an echolocating dolphin

Old and New Approaches to Animal Cognition: There Is Not “One Cognition”

Unpacking the navigation toolbox: insights from comparative cognition

Hearing How Smooth It Looks: Selective Attention and Crossmodal Perception in the Arts

An introduction to multimodal communication

Categorical perception in animal communication and decision-making

Perceptual Specializations for Processing Species-Specific Vocalizations in the Common Marmoset (callithrix Jacchus).

Experience transforms crossmodal object representations in the anterior temporal lobes