Abstract:Background: In many countries around the world, physical education (PE) has been identified as a marginalized subject. PE teachers have been found to feel negative consequences associated with marginality, such as stress, burnout, and early career attrition. Recent evidence also indicates that physical educators can develop a sense of perceived mattering both in relation the subject of PE and their role as that teacher of that subject. Less is known, however, about the relationship between perceived mattering and marginalization, and how teachers navigate social messages associated with each that they receive while teaching. Role socialization theory has emerged as an approach to studying teachers’ experiences in school environments, and can be used to understand their experiences with marginality and mattering. Aims: The purpose of this study was to understand how the social environment of schools influences PE teachers’ perceptions of marginalization and perceived mattering, and how these two constructs interact. Method: The investigation was conceptualized as an interview study, and framed using a social constructivist epistemology. Participants included 30 in-service PE teachers (16 males, 14 females) from the Midwest region of the US. Data were collected using in-depth qualitative interviews, and analyzed through a collaborative approach to data analysis that drew upon both inductive and deductive forms of analysis. Results: Participants identified experiences with both perceived mattering and marginalization in their work, and noted that sometimes these messages were contradictory. Some participants felt the effects of marginalization as their discipline was viewed as a dispensable commodity that is only meaningful for the service it provides to other teachers (e.g. gives elementary classroom teachers a break for planning). Some of the teachers internalized their marginal status and began to see their primary function as supporting the work of teachers in other subjects. Nevertheless, the participants derived a sense of mattering by building relationships with colleagues, administrators, and students, and by advocating for the discipline. Teachers also felt validated when colleagues acknowledge their attempts to implement effective practices, but struggled when working with colleagues who are resistant to change. Conclusions: PE teachers experience both marginalization and perceived mattering, which are shaped largely by social interactions within the school environment. This study specifically lends to the view of marginalization and perceived mattering as two constructs at opposite ends of a continuum, rather than a binary conceptualization. This suggests that it could be the summation of marginalizing experiences and those that promote mattering that lead physical educators to develop overall impressions of their role in schools. Furthermore, this study adds to the literature indicating that physical educators may eventually internalize feelings of marginalization when consistently told that they do not matter. This has implications related to the washout effect whereby teachers who no longer feel as if they are making meaningful contributions to children’s education may compromise their teaching practice.

Under a growth-centered accountability system: A job demand and resource perspective for physical educators

Becoming a primary physical educator

Teaching Physical Education in an Urban Intensive Environment

Physical education teachers’ perceptions of perceived mattering and marginalization

Now That We're “Well Rounded,” Let's Commit to Quality Physical Education Assessment

Challenges to Culturally Responsive Teaching in Physical Education Teacher Education Alumni: A Mixed-Methods Analysis

When the Achievement Gap Becomes High Stakes for Special Education Teachers: Facing a Dilemma with Integrity

Emotional labor, teacher burnout, and turnover intention in high-school physical education teaching

Association of Physical Educators' Socialization Experiences and Confidence with Respect to Comprehensive School Physical Activity Program Implementation

Physical education curriculum reform in China: a perspective from physical education teachers

Prevalence and Sources of Burnout in Singapore Secondary School Physical Education Teachers

Engaging Students in Physical Education: Key Challenges and Opportunities for Physical Educators in Urban Settings

Analysis of Burnout and Self-Efficacy of Teachers of Physical Education During Online Learning

Physical Well-being in Early Childhood Teachers: Correlates of Work-related Musculoskeletal Issues and Fitness among these “Educational Athletes”

Preservice teachers’ learning to implement culturally relevant physical education with the teaching personal and social responsibility model

“No One Works in Isolation Here”: The Socialization of Physical Education Teachers Into a Professional Learning Community

What Causes Burnout in Special School Physical Education Teachers? Evidence from China

Current teachers' perceptions and students' perspectives regarding activities modalities, instructional settings during primary school physical education classes in China: a cross-sectional observational study

Continuing Professional Development for Physical Education Teachers in China: Basis for Teaching Enhancement Program

Physical Activity-Related Practices and Psychosocial Factors of Childcare Educators: A Latent Profile Analysis

Perceived organizational support, marginalization, isolation, emotional exhaustion, and job satisfaction of PETE faculty members