Audit committee, internal audit function and earnings management: evidence from Jordan

Ebraheem Saleem Salem Alzoubi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/MEDAR-06-2017-0160

2019-10-07

Meditari Accountancy Research

Abstract:This study aims to examine the influence of audit committee existence and internal audit function on the earnings management of companies.

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

The Mediating Effects of Key Audit Matters on the Relationship Between Audit Quality and Earnings Management: Evidence from Jordan

Mohammad Ahmad Alqam,Yaser Mohd Hamshari,Haitham Yousef Ali

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18488/journal.73.2021.94.403.416

2021-12-07

Humanities and Social Sciences Letters

Abstract:The relationship between audit quality and earnings management has not been tested with consideration of key audit matters as a mediating variable. This study examined whether audit quality (AQ) decreases earnings management (EM) in shareholding corporations through improving key audit matters (KAMs) in Jordan’s emerging environment. A regression analysis was carried out on a sample that included financial reports and auditor reports of 105 industrial and service shareholdings companies listed on the Amman Stock Exchange (ASE) from 2017 to 2019. The study found a negative relationship between audit quality and earnings management. The results showed that audit quality increases key audit matters, which, in turn, decreases earnings management. Also, the study confirmed the mediating effect of KAMs between audit quality and earnings management. The study confirms the importance of key audit matters to provide more relevant and useful information for the users of financial reports and provides important indications to the regulatory authorities and standards bodies that key audit matters should be given more attention regarding the way that they are presented and disclosed.
Audit committee’s attributes, overlapping memberships on the audit committee and corporate risk disclosure: Evidence from Jordan

Malek Hamed Alshirah,Ahmad Farhan Alshira’h,Abdalwali Lutfi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5267/j.ac.2020.11.008

2021-01-01

Accounting

Abstract:This paper aims to contribute to the literature by examining whether audit committees' attributes affect risk disclosure practiced by Jordanian listed companies. Selecting a sample of 94 Jordanian companies listed on Amman Stock Exchange, the authors carried out a manual content analysis on annual reports to determine the level of risk disclosure. Random effect model was employed in the analysis. Empirical results show that the audit committee size had a positive effect on the level of risk disclosure. However, there was no evidence that the frequency of the audit committee meetings, expertise or overlapping of the audit committee membership were significantly related to the risk disclosure. The findings are important for standard setters to improve their comprehension about the influence of audit committee in disclosing risk information and reconsider the effective monitoring role played by audit committee.
The Role of Internal Audit Quality on Earnings Management

Mustafa Osamah Al-saedi,Oday Jasim Almaliki

DOI: https://doi.org/10.9756/iaje/v10i1/iaje1007

2023-04-17

International Academic Journal of Economics

Abstract:Financial statements are used by companies to evaluate their performance. They can help investors make informed decisions and improve their investments. However, they should be accompanied by independent evidence. Misuse of information is a common issue that managers can make. In the case of earnings management, the companys management uses accounting policies to ensure that the profits are not as transparent as possible. This practice can also lead to financial statements being non-transparable. Besides the quality of the audits, another important factor that an organization should consider is the internal auditor and the audit committees performance. The goal of an audit is to ensure that the financial statements of a company are not filled with irrelevant information. Auditors quality is often compared with that of financial reporting of an organization, as the internal control system of an organization is very important to the accuracy of its financial statements. This is also supported by a study that revealed that the coordination between the activities of the internal auditor and the external auditor is related to the quality of work. An internal auditor can provide a company with high-quality reports. By having a collaboration between BIG4 and an auditor, earnings management actions can be reduced.
Audit committees’ oversight role in developing countries: evidence from Jordan

Salem Alhababsah

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/cg-05-2021-0196

2022-04-11

Corporate Governance: The International Journal of Business in Society

Abstract:Purpose This study aims to explore the opinions of audit committee (AC) members on the extent to which they fulfil the oversight role vested in them by the Jordanian Corporate Governance Code (JCGC). Design/methodology/approach This study uses semi-structured interviews with 18 AC members. Findings The findings suggest that although ACs largely meet the JCGC’s recommendations, their substantive oversight role in practice is limited. In particular, the responses indicate that ACs suffer from a lack of real power, especially concerning the appointment (or removal) of external auditors and the evaluation of internal control. Moreover, ACs have no actual role in issues deemed important for financial reporting quality (e.g. reviewing management estimates and evaluating chief financial officer (CFOs) and internal audit executives). Originality/value This study provides rich insights into ACs’ oversight processes in a setting outside the Anglo-Saxon corporate governance model where knowledge is scant on the ACs’ real function. Hence, the study injects the literature with new qualitative-based evidence from a peculiar civil law country. Also, Jordan has spent time and energy trying to strengthen corporate governance practices to boost investors’ confidence. However, the interviewees’ responses indicate that the oversight role of the AC is still far from what the regulators anticipate. Therefore, the findings offer useful feedback for regulators to think more deeply about the current governance regulations. The feedback from this study can be extended to other developing countries with similar institutional environments, especially countries in the Middle East and North Africa.
Exploitation of Earnings Management Concept to Influence the Quality of Accounting Information: Evidence from Jordan

Raed Kanakriyah,M. Shanikat,A. freihat

Abstract:This study aims to understand the nature impact of earnings management practice on the quality of accounting information in Jordan.The study used the quantitative technique to gather the data by using a questionnaire to understand the users’ attitudes about earnings management practice in Jordan and how this practice influences the quality of accounting information. To discover this issue, the researcher documented several criteria to identify the concept of "earning management'' and define the variables to measure it. The study states that all accounting information users believe that the earnings management practice is used by some companies in Jordan. They stated how the practice affects the quality of accounting information by detecting a significant effect of earnings management, which in turn has an impact on users' decisions, such as investors, financial analysts, and creditors . In addition, the study’s outcome specified that earnings management has an important influence on accounting information quality. Most companies resort to using earnings management techniques to meet shareholders’ wants, financial analysts’ expectations for the company's performance, or management’s desire to increase the net income which in turn increases the rewards they receive or to achieve their personal interests that resulted from agency problems. Finally, earnings management is considered a form of accounting manipulation practiced without breaching laws and standards.The consequences of the current study help users of financial reports, such as managers and investors, detect an effect of earning management on users’ decision making.It is believed that there is no Jordanian study to date examining the impact of earnings management on the quality of accounting information. Therefore, this study significantly contributes to the limited literature on the exploitation of the earnings management concept to influence the quality of accounting information in developing countries.The difficulty with using a questionnaire in developing countries, such as Jordan , also there are a number of users who do not care about the results of the study Keywords : Earnings management, real activity manipulation, accrual manipulation, consequences of earnings management, quality of accounting information, reasons for earnings management applications.

Business
Financial Factors Affecting Earnings Management and Earnings Quality: New Evidence from an Emerging Market

Isam Saleh,Malik Abu Afifa,Fadi Haniah

DOI: https://doi.org/10.35944/jofrp.2020.9.1.014

2020-01-01

ACRN Journal of Finance and Risk Perspectives

Abstract:The purpose of this study is to examine the effect of financial factors on earnings management and earnings quality. Moreover, the study examines the role of earnings management as a mediator in the effect of the financial factors on earnings quality. It provides some empirical evidences from an emerging market, especially from the Jordanian market. The study uses a panel data analysis method over a ten-year period (2009-2018). The study population includes all Jordanian insurance companies listed in Jordanian market at the end of the year 2019, and the study sample consists of 20 Jordanian insurance companies (a complete population), giving a total of 200 observations for each variable. The results indicate that all financial factors in the model combined affect the earnings management and earnings quality. In addition, earnings management negatively affects earnings quality, and earnings management fully mediates the effect of financial factors on earnings quality. The study advises that policy makers ought to follow good legislation to curb the company's earnings management activities. Hence, the policy makers need to apply regulations which enrich the company’s effectiveness and efficiency whilst protecting the investors and other interested parties from risk.
Audit committee features and earnings management

Farzaneh Nassir Zadeh,Davood Askarany,Ali Shirzad,Mahdi Faghani

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.heliyon.2023.e20825

IF: 3.776

2023-10-12

Heliyon

Abstract:Purpose: Past studies have investigated the relationship between audit committee features and earnings management and reported mixed and inconclusive results. Some studies have found a significant relationship, while others have not. This study aims to explain these mixed results in the literature by dividing earning management into two groups: accrual and real earnings management (at three levels of sales, general and administrative costs, production costs and cash flows operation) and re-examining the relationship. Design/methodology/approach: The statistical model used in this study is a multivariate regression model; further, the statistical technique used to test the hypotheses is panel data. Findings: The findings show that both the audit committee members' financial expertise and the audit committee's size affect the accrual earnings management. However, the results show no meaningful relationship between the audit committee features and real-based earnings management at any levels of sales, general and administrative costs, production costs and cash flow operation. In addition, the findings suggest no meaningful relationship between the independence of the audit committee's members and accrual earnings management. In other words, not separating the earning management into 'accrual' and 'real' could be the critical factor for the reported mixed and inconsistent results in the literature. Practical implications: The findings of the current study provide an important guideline for investors and stakeholders to separate 'accrual' from 'real' earning management and pay more attention to the importance of audit committee features to limit the opportunities of earnings management. Indeed, by understanding the relationship between audit committee features and earnings management, investors and stockholders can make appropriate decisions regarding the optimal choice of funds. Originality/value: Dividing the earning management into two groups (accrual versus real) and re-examining its relationship with the audit committee features is new in this paper. Identifying one of the possible reasons for the past mixed and inconsistent results in the literature is also an incremental contribution provided by this study.
Does the audit quality have any moderating impact on the relationship between ownership structure and dividends? Evidence from Jordan

Mohammed Zakaria Soda,Mohammed Hassan Makhlouf,Yazan Oroud,Abdul Razzak Alshehadeh,Rania Al Omari,Haneen A Al-Khawaja,Haneen A. Al-Khawaja

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5267/j.uscm.2023.6.012

2023-08-20

Uncertain Supply Chain Management

Abstract:The article aims at investigating whether audit quality impacts the relationship between ownership structure and dividends in companies listed on the Amman Stock Exchange (ASE). The article is constructed on the analysis of time-series–cross-section (TSCS) (Panel Data). The study sample comprises 34 companies listed on the Amman Stock Exchange between 2016 and 2021. The study sample's content of the financial reports is analyzed to attain appropriate data for the study. The Findings indicate that family ownership and ownership of board members negatively impact dividends. In contrast, institutional ownership and concentrated ownership positively impact dividends, as no effect of foreign ownership is found on dividends. By introducing audit quality as a modified variable on the relationship between ownership structure and dividends, the findings demonstrate that audit quality positively enhances and strengthens this relationship. This article with its results is of great significance to future stockholders and shareholders, as they help in selecting companies capable of distributing higher dividends than other companies and achieving satisfactory investment returns. The findings of the study also focus on the significance of audit quality as a guarantor for regulating the relationship between forms of ownership structure and the distribution of dividends. This study is regarded among the little research investigating the factors that would impact the relationship between ownership structure and dividends. This article plays a key role in bridging the research gap related to the lack of studies dealing with the relationship between ownership structure and dividends in emerging markets.
The Effect of Corporate Governance Mechanisms on Earnings Management in Malaysian Manufacturing Companies

Murad Ali Ahmad Al-Zaqeba,Abdul Hamid S,Nehad Ibrahim Ineizeh,Obada Jebreen Hussein,Ala Hussein Albawwat

DOI: https://doi.org/10.55493/5002.v12i5.4490

2022-05-20

Asian Economic and Financial Review

Abstract:Earnings management (EM) firms produce less predictable accounting earnings that do not reflect the company's genuine financial success. However, EM is regarded as one of the most significant issues regarding financial reporting, especially in light of the COVID-19 pandemic. Nevertheless, this paper aims to investigate the effect of corporate governance mechanisms on earnings management in Malaysian manufacturing companies (MMCs). Data was collected from 2010 to 2019 for MMCs. By highlighting the updating of corporate governance rules, the market value and competitiveness of institutions will improve. Moreover, this paper provides evidence of the effect of corporate governance on earnings management. Therefore, the results may help policymakers to take a new approach to the development of corporate governance instructions, and stakeholders, which would enhance earnings quality and improve the quality of financial reports. This could help them build a more comprehensive picture of the firm and improve the decision-making process.
The effect of audit committee characteristics on earnings management in Nigerian listed firms

Abdulsalam Nasiru Kaoje,Mohammed Yusuf Alkali,Abubakar Modibbo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.15587/2706-5448.2023.272875

2023-01-30

Technology audit and production reserves

Abstract:This study focuses on the effect of audit committee characteristics on earnings management among Listed Firms in Nigeria with aim to ascertain whether audit committee characteristics has effect on earnings management. Audit committee in an organization is to support firm’s governance and oversight functions with the regard to financial reporting, risk management system internal control structure, ethical accountability and internal and external audit functions. Earnings management is an attempt by managers to alter financial information either for their private gain or for the gain of stockholders. The study population was 190 firms listed in the Nigerian Stock Market. The study sample was 150 firms because 40 firms could not provide the needed data for the study as at 2014 to 2019. The study data was generated from the Thomson Reuters Data stream and other variables were handpicked from the firm’s annual reports covering the period of 2014–2019. A Generalized Least Square (GLS) estimator was used in estimating the parameters. The study provides positive and significant relationship between Audit Committee Independence (ACIND), Audit Committee Meetings (ACMT) and Earnings Management of listed Nigerian Firms in Nigeria. However, negative relationship between Audit Committee Size, Audit Committee Financial Expertise, Firm Size and Earnings Management was reported among the Listed Firms in Nigeria. Policy maker should provide policy on the composition of Audit for the committee members to clearly spelt out to enable members perform their functions effectively. Further study should look at diversity of audit committee, ethnicity, and religious influence because of the Nigerian diversity on ethnicity and religion.
Audit Committee Features and CSR Disclosure: Additional Evidence From an Emerging Market

Sumaia Ayesh Qaderi,Turki Raji Alhmoud,Belal Ali Abdulraheem Ghaleb

DOI: https://doi.org/10.5430/ijfr.v11n5p226

2020-10-04

International Journal of Financial Research

Abstract:This study aims to measure the level of corporate social responsibility disclosure (CSRDL) in an emerging market, Jordan. It also aims to investigate the effect of audit committee (AC) features on CSRDL. The study’s data, obtained from annual reports, comprises 576 company-year observations from industrial and services companies listed on the Amman stock exchange for the period 2011 to 2016. Content analysis is used to measure CSRDL, and multiple regression techniques to test the proposed relationships. The results show that CSRDL among Jordanian listed companies is low, suggesting that companies have less incentive to disclose CSR practices. Additionally, AC independence and AC ownership positively influence CSRDL. The findings from this research have limited generalisability due to the specific characteristics of the sample, which is from a developing country. However, they have implications and value for policymakers and different stakeholders interested in improving CSR initiatives. The findings are also significant in reducing agency costs and enhancing corporate transparency. Within the limits of the authors’ knowledge, this research is among the first to provide preliminary evidence on the effect of AC features on CSR disclosure in an emerging market context, specifically in Jordan.
Audit Committee Leadership Attributes and CSR Reporting: Evidence from Jordan

Sumaia Ayesh Qaderi,Belal Ali Abdulraheem Ghaleb,Abdulwahid Ahmed Hashed,Turki Raji Alhmoud,Hasnah Kamardin

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/21582440231182593

IF: 2.032

2023-08-20

SAGE Open

Abstract:SAGE Open, Volume 13, Issue 3, July-September 2023. Even though audit committee (AC) characteristics and corporate social responsibility (CSR) relationship has long been well investigated, scarce research on committee leadership is observed in the literature. Considering the growing emphasis on the potential role of the audit committee chair (ACC) on financial and non-financial reporting, the current study aims to fill this literature gap by analyzing the influence of ACC characteristics on the level of CSR. Using a Jordanian sample of 475 firm-year observations over the period 2014 to 2018, this study employs content analysis to quantify CSR disclosure and ordinary least squares (OLS) regression to test the proposed hypotheses. The study findings show that ACC independence, legal expertise, and education level are positively and significantly associated with CSR reporting. However, ACC age has a significant inverse relationship with CSR reporting, suggesting that older ACC perform more poorly in a committee function. Importantly, ACC tenure and financial expertise have an insignificant relationship with CSR reporting. These findings are robust under a battery of sensitive tests such as employing OLS with robust standard errors and using alternative measurements of ACC features. The sub-sample analysis results also show that ACC characteristics predominantly enhance CSR reporting in large firms but not in small firms, implying that firm size strengthens the relationship between ACC characteristics and CSR reporting. The current study provides new evidence of the significant role of ACC on non-financial reporting in an emerging economy, Jordan. Policymakers, researchers, and stakeholders may benefit from these results in recognizing the potential role of ACC in advancing CSR reporting.

social sciences, interdisciplinary
Political connections, government ownership, and earnings management: evidence from Jordan

Mohammad Alhadab,Modar Abdullatif,Ahmed Hassan Ahmed,Yasean Tahat,Israa Mansour,Hassan Ahmed

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1504/ijaape.2021.117575

2021-01-01

International Journal of Accounting, Auditing and Performance Evaluation

Abstract:This study examines the impact of political connections and government ownership on accrual and real earnings management. Based on a Jordanian sample of 310 firm-year observations, the study finds evidence that politically-connected firms exhibit a higher level of real earnings management, compared to non-politically-connected firms. This evidence suggests that politically-connected firms in Jordan opportunistically manipulate reported income to obtain a private gain through the use of real activities-based manipulation, at the expense of other minority shareholders. This may be caused by real earnings management activities being less subject to the risk of detection and monitoring. Further, the study finds evidence that government-connected firms engage in a lower level of accrual and real earnings management compared to non-government-connected firms, suggesting a positive effect for government ownership on the quality of financial reporting.
Impact of audit committee characteristics on firm performance: Evidence from Bahrain

Abdulla Al-Jalahma

DOI: https://doi.org/10.21511/ppm.20(1).2022.21

2022-02-14

Problems and Perspectives in Management

Abstract:The purpose of this study is to analyze the relationship between different audit committee attributes and company performance in Bahrain. This paper investigates the impact of audit committee independence, size, and meeting frequency on company performance (employing ROE, ROA, and Tobin’s Q). Data from all 14 non-financial publicly listed companies on Bahrain Bourse during 2005–2019 were used. The results revealed that companies with independent audit committees and big audit committees in terms of size are performing poorly. It is also shown that the number of audit committee meetings does not affect company performance. Further, this study failed to find any association between the number of audit committee meetings and company performance. The findings show that shareholders might lack knowledge of the importance of corporate governance mechanisms. The results of this study should be of potential interest to different stakeholders, including regulators, investors, and auditors, in their attempts to improve company performance and monitoring mechanisms in emerging economies.

English Else
Audit Committee Impact on Corporate Profitability in Oman Companies: an Auditing and Management Accounting Perspective

Tariq Tawfeeq Yousif Alabdullah,Essia Ries Ahmed

DOI: https://doi.org/10.23917/reaksi.v5i2.11836

2020-10-26

Riset Akuntansi dan Keuangan Indonesia

Abstract:This work investigates the impact of audit committees’ features as predictor variables of corporate profitability with a sample of firms belong to non-financial sector in Muscat Securities Market (MSM). This work analyzed cross sectional data for 60 non-financial firms. It used annual reports for the year of 2019 to analyze the impact of audit committees’ features on corporate profitability. The present work tested its hypotheses and utilized its variables via utilizing the Smart-PLS for data analysis. The findings revealed that a positive association between all the predictors and dependent variables are exist among the whole variables; audit committee, audit Independence, meeting of audit committee, and corporate profitability measured by management accounting’s indicators represented by ROA and ROE. This work is a new in its kind to be applied in Oman context via examining the relation between its predictors of audit committees’ features towards their impact on corporate profitability. The current study presents a theoretical and practical implications as a contribution relevant to practitioners working and academics in areas related to corporate profitability. In that, it furnishes empirical evidence for the policymakers, researchers and other interested parties.

English Else
Impact of cash flow on earnings management in Jordan

Khaled Eriej Aburisheh,Ahmad Abdelrahim Dahiyat,Walid Omar Owais

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/23311975.2022.2135211

2022-10-30

Abstract:This article aimed to examine what do operate cash flow and free cash flow are to reveal the effect on earnings management? Evidence: industrial companies listed on the Amman stock exchange during the period from 2011 to 2020. Several control variables were used to examine the relationships. The survey method adopted was employed in the choosing of a sample of 56 industrial firms. The information has been extracted from the available financial reports through the use of panel data regression. The findings from the study showed that, as independent factors, free cash flow, operating cash flow, and control variables including managerial ownership and financial leverage have an impact on earnings management. However, firm size as the control variable has no impact on earnings management.
The moderating role of audit quality on the relationship between auditor reporting and earnings management: empirical evidence from Tunisia

Fakhfakh Imen,Jarboui Anis

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1108/EMJB-03-2020-0024

2021-08-12

EuroMed Journal of Business

Abstract:The purpose of this study is to examine the interrelationship between modified audit opinions and earnings management as measured by discretionary accruals and develop a thorough understanding regarding the moderating effect of audit quality on this relation. This study uses a sample of Tunisian listed firms on the Tunis Stock Exchange during 2006–2013. Four models are developed and tested by using panel logistic and Feasible Generalized Least Squares (FGLS) regressions. The results show that earnings management increases the likelihood of receiving a modified audit opinions. Then firms receiving modified audit opinions manage earnings more than those receiving clean opinions. It is also discovered that audit quality moderates the relationship between audit opinion and earnings management. This paper contributes to the literature of both audit and management studies and represents the first effort to examine the relation between audit opinion and earnings management, with audit quality as a moderating variable. This study extends existing research on earnings management and audit opinion. Thus, this study has the potential to help stakeholders, board of directors, regulators and auditors, who are related with enhancing the supervision of firms and reducing the opportunities given to managers, to engage in earnings management. It constitutes an addition to previous knowledge about audit opinion in the Tunisian context before and after revolution.
The Impact of Internal Control and Electronic Disclosure on the Electronic Auditing Risk in the Jordanian Industrial Public Shareholding Companies

Abdalla Alassuli,Mo'taz Alzobi

DOI: https://doi.org/10.26668/businessreview/2023.v8i3.1055

2023-03-08

International Journal of Professional Business Review

Abstract:Purpose: The aim of this study is to examine the possibility of the risk associated with electronic auditing by identifying the relationships between the various internal control aspects (control activities, control environment, monitoring, information and communications, and electronic disclosure) Theoretical framework: The Jordanian Industrial Public Shareholding Companies as other sectors, apply standards for internal audit that set by experts and electronic auditing using a new electronic technique that may affected by IC and ED. Design/methodology/approach: The descriptive statistics used to describe the electric questionnaire responses of the study sample using SPSS statistical analysis. The study population was made up of the finance department personnel and financial managers of the 45 public shareholding businesses, and 225 companies that were listed on the Amman Stock Exchange up until the end of December 2021. Findings: The results show that in Jordanian public shareholding businesses, risk assessment with its aspects (internal control and electronic disclosure) had a statistically significant influence on reducing audit risk in their dimensions (control risk, inherent risk, and discovery risk). In addition, the study determined that electronic disclosure had a statistically significant impact on lowering audit risk in Jordanian public shareholding corporations. Research, Practical & Social implications: The implications for Practice of the adoption of electronic systems will raise the risks to the confidentiality and reliability of accounting data. This is the purpose of electronic auditing, since it decreases the possibility of misrepresentation and manipulation of accounting data provided electronically. Further study can involve many countries in the region so as the conducted results can be widespread and globalized. Originality/value: The study among the first highlighted the impact of internal control and electronic disclosure for the risk associated with the electronic auditing in the Jordanian Industrial Public Shareholding Companies.
Ownership Structure and Financial Reporting Quality: Influence of Audit Quality Evidence from Jordan

Hamza Kamel Qawqzeh*,Wan Anisah Endut*,Norfadzilah Rashid,Mohammad Mustafa Dakhlallh

DOI: https://doi.org/10.35940/ijrte.d7896.118419

2019-11-30

International Journal of Recent Technology and Engineering

Abstract:The issues of ownership structure, audit quality, earnings management and financial reporting quality have received more consideration from public, profession and other interested parties particularly after persistent firms' scandals. Ownership structure play essential role in improve financial reporting quality (FRQ) through acting as effective internal control. This study examines the influence of the various types of ownership on the FRQ and the influence of audit quality. A stream of literature has examined the relationships between the different types of ownership, audit quality and FRQ. This study aims to connect such of these variables to produce an integrated model describing the influence of ownership structure with in the company and audit quality on FRQ. Therefore, the following relationships are tested: Ownership structure and FRQ, Mediating effect of auditor quality on these relationships, and audit quality and FRQ. Using Panel Data of 180 Jordanian company listed in ASE from 2009-2017, results showed that directors' and family ownership have significantly positive effect on FRQ through reducing earnings management; Institutional ownership has significantly negative influence on FRQ; Managerial ownership has insignificant impact on FRQ. Audit quality has partial mediating impact on these relationships. Audit quality found to has significantly positive impact on FRQ, it implies that audit quality is considered as deterrent to earnings management. This study suggests to increase the supervisory and monitoring role of institutional ownership on the management when preparing financial statements.
Corporate Governance and the Quality of Audit Process: An Exploratory Analysis Considering Internal Audit, Audit Committee and Board of Directors

Nashat Ali Almasria

DOI: https://doi.org/10.24018/ejbmr.2022.7.1.1210

2022-01-22

European Journal of Business and Management Research

Abstract:This research aims to offer a better understanding concerning the relationships between Internal Corporate Governance Mechanisms and quality of the external audit process and what are the governance mechanisms that can influence some aspects of the quality of the external audit process. Semi-structured interviews were employed in order to get detail views of the external auditors to explain and clarify how the Internal Corporate Governance Mechanisms can influence the quality of the external audit process as well as offer a better understanding of the relationships between the governance mechanisms and the quality of the external audit process. Adopting this research design (exploratory) was mainly as a response to the recent calls as there is a lack of this kind of study that investigate the relationship between the Internal Corporate Governance Mechanisms can influence the quality of the external audit process. This research focuses on the perception/insight of the Jordanian external auditors regarding the influence of Internal Corporate Governance Mechanisms on quality of the external audit process. Thus, this study uses a sample of 206 Jordanian external auditors for the survey and 13 participants from this sample for the interview. The qualitative study employed the thematic analysis to analyse the interview data. The interview results highlighted that there are different ways and stages that the ICGMs can influence the EAQ, for example, through holding effective regular meeting, ensuring the auditor compliance with the audit requirements “regular monitoring”, discussing the initial and significant audit results “draft of discussion”, taking necessary follow-up actions “feedback” as well as requesting the auditor to conduct additional tests which can in turn enhance the EAQ. The results also suggest that ICGM can assist improving different aspects of EAQ such as the quality of the evidence that are collected by the ICGM and the valuable guidance from the ICGM to the external auditor. The communication between the ICGM and external auditor can be focused on different issues related to the audit process such as auditors’ findings, the effectiveness of internal control, scope limitations and material misstatements which allow improving the effectiveness of audit process. This indicates that, the auditor must be aware of the dynamic deciding of the role of particular mechanisms in improving the external audit process. The results have implications for the practitioners and regulators who are assessing the role of ICGM in improving the reliability of the financial report and auditor’s report. The empirical findings demonstrate that different ICGM can influence different aspects of the EAQ. More importantly, the results reveal that audit practice in Jordan is experiencing some difficulties in terms of the independence of the auditor especially, for the small local firms and providing non-audit service. In addition, there is no professional body for board of director; internal audit and audit committee like Jordanian association of certified public accountant (JACPA) for the external auditor, thus, responsibilities of these mechanisms need to be formally overseen by a higher authority. For the policymakers, this study offers a unique proposition to improve the effectiveness of the ICGM to achieve EAQ. These empirical findings of this study also highlight the importance of improving EAQ as a solution for the agency problems through reducing information asymmetry, improving the disclosure practice, level of confidence and assurance of the financial reporting as well as deterring the opportunistic behaviour from different parties. This research extended the existing empirical evidence that investigated the role of the internal governance mechanisms in the audit process.

Audit committee, internal audit function and earnings management: evidence from Jordan

The Mediating Effects of Key Audit Matters on the Relationship Between Audit Quality and Earnings Management: Evidence from Jordan

Audit committee’s attributes, overlapping memberships on the audit committee and corporate risk disclosure: Evidence from Jordan

The Role of Internal Audit Quality on Earnings Management

Audit committees’ oversight role in developing countries: evidence from Jordan

Exploitation of Earnings Management Concept to Influence the Quality of Accounting Information: Evidence from Jordan

Financial Factors Affecting Earnings Management and Earnings Quality: New Evidence from an Emerging Market

Audit committee features and earnings management

Does the audit quality have any moderating impact on the relationship between ownership structure and dividends? Evidence from Jordan

The Effect of Corporate Governance Mechanisms on Earnings Management in Malaysian Manufacturing Companies

The effect of audit committee characteristics on earnings management in Nigerian listed firms

Audit Committee Features and CSR Disclosure: Additional Evidence From an Emerging Market

Audit Committee Leadership Attributes and CSR Reporting: Evidence from Jordan

Political connections, government ownership, and earnings management: evidence from Jordan

Impact of audit committee characteristics on firm performance: Evidence from Bahrain

Audit Committee Impact on Corporate Profitability in Oman Companies: an Auditing and Management Accounting Perspective

Impact of cash flow on earnings management in Jordan

The moderating role of audit quality on the relationship between auditor reporting and earnings management: empirical evidence from Tunisia

The Impact of Internal Control and Electronic Disclosure on the Electronic Auditing Risk in the Jordanian Industrial Public Shareholding Companies

Ownership Structure and Financial Reporting Quality: Influence of Audit Quality Evidence from Jordan

Corporate Governance and the Quality of Audit Process: An Exploratory Analysis Considering Internal Audit, Audit Committee and Board of Directors