Gender Differences in the Dating Experiences of African American Young Adults: The Challenge of Forming Romantic Relationships Within the Context of Power Imbalance

Leslie Gordon Simons,Tara E. Sutton,Antoinette M. Landor,Ashley B. Barr,Chalandra M. Bryant,Ellen M. Granberg

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0044118X19828097

2019-10-07

Abstract:Youth &Society, Ahead of Print.

sociology,social sciences, interdisciplinary,social issues

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Social-Contextual Influences on Adolescent Romantic Involvement: The Constraints of Being a Numerical Minority

R Kelly Raley,M Kate Sullivan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/02732170903346205

Abstract:This research explores white-black differences in adolescent heterosexual romantic involvement and how these differences are shaped by social context. We find that, parallel to patterns of marriage in adulthood, Non-Hispanic white girls are more likely to be in a romantic relationship than African American girls. This is particularly true when we focus on heterosexual romantic relationships formed with schoolmates. Among boys, African Americans are more likely to be romantically involved than Non-Hispanic whites. We investigate the contribution of two broad types of social-demographic factors to these race-ethnic differences, population composition and normative climate. We develop theory about why being a numerical minority should lead to lower levels of relationship formation, especially when interracial relationships are rare. Results support the population composition hypotheses but not the idea that race-ethnic differences arise because of differences in normative climate.
Social Exchange and The Progression of Sexual Relationships in Emerging Adulthood

Sharon Sassler,Kara Joyner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/sf/90.1.223

Abstract:Research has extensively examined matching on race and other characteristics in cohabitation and marriage, but it has generally disregarded sexual and romantic relationships. Using data from the 2002 National Survey of Family Growth and the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent Health, we examine the tempo of key transitions in the recent relationships of young adults aged 18 to 24. We focus on how the racial mix of partners in relationships is associated with the timing to sex, cohabitation, and marriage. We find evidence that relationships between white men and minority women proceed more rapidly than relationships involving other racial combinations from romance to sexual involvement and from sexual involvement to cohabitation. Our findings have important implications for social exchange perspectives on mate selection.
Racial Discrimination and Romantic Relationship Dynamics among Black Americans: A Systematic Review

TeKisha M Rice,August I C Jenkins,Shardé McNeil Smith,Chelsea Alexander,Casey M McGregor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jftr.12535

Abstract:Despite increasing research, the links between racial discrimination and Black Americans' romantic relationship dynamics remain unclear. Guided by models of mundane extreme environmental stress (Peters & Massey, 1983), sociocultural family stress (McNeil Smith & Landor, 2018), and Black marital outcomes (Bryant et al., 2010), we conducted a systematic review of the literature examining racial discrimination and relationship dynamics among Black Americans in same-race and interracial romantic relationships. Synthesizing findings from 32 published empirical articles, we find support for manifestations of each component of MEES in Black intimate life. We uncover evidence that racial discrimination is associated with compromised relationship functioning for Black Americans. Several psychosocial resources were also identified as either buffering these associations or posing drawbacks/limitations for Black Americans. We discuss notable gaps in the literature and directions for future research including intersectional investigations, broader examination of the MEES context, and de-centering whiteness among studies of interracial relationship dynamics.
Relational schemas, hostile romantic relationships, and beliefs about marriage among young African American adults

Ronald L. Simons,Leslie G. Simons,Man K. Lei,Antoinette M. Landor

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0265407511406897

IF: 2.681

2011-05-11

Journal of Social and Personal Relationships

Abstract:The present study tests a developmental model designed to explain the romantic relationship difficulties and reluctance to marry often reported for African Americans. Using longitudinal data from a sample of approximately 400 African American young adults, we examine the manner in which race-related adverse experiences during late childhood and early adolescence give rise to the cynical view of romantic partners and marriage held by many young African Americans. Our results indicate that adverse circumstances disproportionately suffered by African American youth (viz., harsh parenting, family instability, discrimination, criminal victimization, and financial hardship) promote distrustful relational schemas that lead to troubled dating relationships, and that these negative relationship experiences, in turn, encourage a less positive view of marriage.

family studies,psychology, social,communication
Gender Differences and Communication Technology Use among Emerging Adults in the Initiation of Dating Relationships

Damon L. Rappleyea,Alan C. Taylor,Xiangming Fang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/01494929.2013.879552

2014-01-01

Marriage & Family Review

Abstract:For many emerging adults, initiating and developing a romantic relationship is likely to be very different from the experiences of previous generations. Many studies address the abundant use of technology among young adults in virtually every aspect of their lives. Few studies, however, have investigated the use of communication technology and its impact on how relationships are discovered, initiated, and maintained among this group. Researchers collected data from 1,003 young adults (ages 18–25 years) through an online survey about communication technology use and dating behaviors. Results were analyzed using chi-square tests to assess for differences between groups. Findings suggest significant differences between men and women and their use of communication technology during the initiation of dating relationships. Additionally, young adults believe that “talking,” “hanging out,” and “sharing intimate details” are more important when compared with using communication technologies to establish a relationship. The information yields valuable understanding about the role communication technology plays in the intimate relationship development of emerging adults.
Understanding African American help‐seeking for romantic relationships: Advocacy, barriers, and considerations

Aimee Hubbard,Steven Harris,Mary Dick,DasJohn McGee

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/jmft.12692

2024-02-22

Journal of Marital and Family Therapy

Abstract:African American couples experience greater levels of relationship distress than other racial/ethnic groups, but they are less likely to seek formal couple counseling. Existing literature highlights the importance of community support in the form of church, family, and friends. While the literature suggests that African Americans encounter unique barriers, we do not know how racism and discrimination impact the couple help‐seeking process. This study seeks to address this gap and better understand unique barriers in the African American couple help‐seeking (AACHS) process via a grounded theory‐informed qualitative study. Findings from interviews with 11 African American individuals in committed relationships highlighted mistrust as a significant barrier to AACHS, while community supports are frequently sought out. Our findings add to current understandings about AACHS and highlight important areas for future research. In the clinical implications section, the authors outline tangible steps that clinicians can take based on the findings from this study.

psychology, clinical,family studies
Factors linking childhood experiences to adult romantic relationships among African Americans.

Leslie Gordon Simons,Ronald L. Simons,Antoinette M. Landor,Chalandra M. Bryant,Steven R. H. Beach

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/a0036393

2014-01-01

Journal of Family Psychology

Abstract:It is well known that a high-quality relationship with a romantic partner is related to a variety of positive outcomes associated with health and well-being. Establishing such relationships is an important developmental task for young adults, and past research indicates that there is a link between experiences in the family of origin and the success of later intimate relationships. It has been suggested that this association can be explained by the acquisition of social competencies (e.g., emotions, schemas, traits) that are acquired during childhood in the family of origin and, in turn, influence interaction with adult romantic partners. The current study builds on this foundation by identifying particular competencies expected to explain the association between childhood exposure to supportive and harsh parenting and later patterns of interaction with romantic partners. Specifically, we examine anger management, attachment style, hostile attribution bias, and self-control as potential mediators using prospective, longitudinal data from a sample of 345 African American young adults. Results from structural equation modeling indicate that each of the mediators in our study accounts for a significant portion of the effect of parenting on the quality of adult romantic relationships, although the constructs linking parenting to warm interactions with romantic partners are somewhat different from those that link parenting to hostile interactions with romantic partners. Even after accounting for the effect of the mediators, there is still a direct effect of parenting on both warm/loving and hostile/aggressive interactions with romantic partner. Implications for theory and practice are discussed.

psychology, clinical,family studies
“A Little More Ghetto, a Little Less Cultured”: Are There Racial Stereotypes about Interracial Daters in the United States?

René D. Flores

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/2332649219835851

2019-04-02

Sociology of Race and Ethnicity

Abstract:Negative stereotypes about racial minorities, particularly African Americans, persist in the United States. Given the imperviousness of racial stereotypes about minorities, can individuals who date interracially also be stereotyped? The author investigates this by conducting the first systematic study of men’s attitudes toward white and black women who date outside their race. First, the author inductively uncovers these stereotypes through focus groups. Second, to assess these stereotypes’ nationwide prevalence and to minimize social desirability bias, the author applies a survey experiment, in which interracial dating is subtly primed via photographs of couples, to a national sample of men. The findings are mixed. In the experiment, crossing the white-black racial boundary does activate negative stereotypes for women, which may have reputational costs, but mostly among older white male respondents. These costs include changes in men’s perceptions of their class status, cultural values, and even sexual practices. In conclusion, interracial dating is a key social site where gender-based moral norms are policed, class divisions are constructed, and racial boundaries are maintained.

sociology,ethnic studies
Adolescent Exposure to Racially and Ethnically Diverse Neighborhoods and Schools: Implications for Interracial Dating, Cohabitation, and Marriage in Emerging and Young Adulthood

Xing Zhang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/02654075231193451

IF: 2.681

2023-08-03

Journal of Social and Personal Relationships

Abstract:Journal of Social and Personal Relationships, Ahead of Print. Background: Interracial romantic relationships and unions are a marker of social distance between racial and ethnic groups, but the role of geographic context at schools and neighborhoods during adolescence in shaping interracial romantic relationship formation in the transition to adulthood has been underexplored, which is important for understanding how intergroup contact in the school and neighborhood contexts during adolescence may have subsequent consequences for interracial union formation later in emerging and young adulthood. Methods: Using data from Waves I, III, and IV of the National Longitudinal Study of Adolescent to Adult Health, this study examines the roles of exposure to racial and ethnic diversity in schools and geographic regions in adolescence in shaping the likelihood of being in an interracial romantic relationship in emerging and young adulthood. Results: Adolescents who lived in a Census tract that had fewer of their own racial and ethnic groups were significantly more likely to be in interracial romantic relationships in emerging and in young adulthood. Adolescents who attended more racially and ethnically diverse high schools were also more likely to be in interracial romantic relationships in emerging adulthood. In young adulthood, Hispanic adolescents who went to primarily White high schools were more likely to be in interracial romantic relationships in emerging adulthood and young adulthood. Conclusions: Exposure to racially and ethnically diverse neighborhoods and schools is associated with an increased likelihood of interracial union formation in emerging and young adulthood.

family studies,psychology, social,communication
"Don't you care about the well-being of your race?": African American couples discuss racial differences involving criticisms of other Black people

Shalonda Kelly,Tara Kellman

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/famp.12690

Abstract:African American couples have unique racial stress and high relationship instability, although few studies have examined the role of racial stressors in their relationships. This qualitative study used grounded theory to examine 10 African American couples' disagreements about criticisms of other Black people. Each couple completed a standard couple problem-solving task modified to focus solely on racial differences between the partners. Two models of couple relationships framed the approach; the general vulnerability-stress-adaptation model (Karney & Bradbury, Psychol. Bull., 118, 1995, 3) was combined with a comprehensive race-focused model (Bryant et al., J. Fam. Theory Rev., 2, 2010, 157). The goal was to understand racial stress faced by African Americans, including its context, how and why it is stressful, how they cope, and its consequences in their relationship. A tentative model emerged, suggesting that some African Americans have early race-related experiences that make them vulnerable to concerns about how Black people are seen by others. This may result in a unique minority status stressor that appears indicative of internalized stereotypes and may often include gendered criticisms of their partners. Partners seem to adapt by looking to other African Americans to take personal responsibility for their behavior and defending their racial group. Black male-female gender role issues appear to emerge as a consequence of racial stress that also seems salient across all aspects of the model. Future studies can further examine culturally specific models involving African Americans' criticisms of other Black people and identify successful couple-level strategies to overcome internalized oppression.
Something Old, Something New: Black Women, Interracial Dating, and the Black Marriage Crisis

Renee Romano

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1215/10407391-6999802

2018-09-01

differences

Abstract:This article focuses on the emergence of a new genre of advice literature in the mid-2000s. Primarily written by and aimed at black women, it urges them to date and marry outside the race as a way to address the plight of successful educated black women who cannot find black husbands. In arguments that illuminate contemporary perspectives on long-standing debates among blacks about when and how to put down the burdens of history; racial identity and authenticity; the loyalty an individual owes to the community; and gender roles and responsibilities, this new advocacy literature urges black women to embrace their power and desirability in American society. At the same time, the literature reveals a nostalgic desire for a world where men were providers, women could afford to be the weaker sex, and traditional marriage could be a path to both personal and group advancement. Advocates offer their readers a romantic and appealing narrative that emphasizes black women’s power and agency, but this prescription has the potential to delegitimize black women’s lived experience and to reinforce discourses that stigmatize the black community.
Following Their Lead? Connecting Mainstream Media Use to Black Women’s Gender Beliefs and Sexual Agency

L. Monique Ward,Morgan Jerald,Lanice Avery,Elizabeth R. Cole

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1080/00224499.2018.1554741

2019-01-09

The Journal of Sex Research

Abstract:Although media exposure has emerged as a significant predictor of consumers' sexual decision making, less is known about the mechanisms involved and about the dynamics of these relations for adults, in general, and for African American adults, in particular. To address these gaps, we used structural equation modeling (SEM) to test whether heterosexual Black women's endorsement of traditional gender and sexual roles mediates connections between their consumption of four mainstream media (music videos, reality TV programming, movies, and women's magazines) and three dimensions of their sexual well-being (sexual assertiveness, sexual inhibition, and sexual deception). We surveyed 594 heterosexual Black women aged 17 to 55 who were undergraduate and graduate students at two universities (one historically Black university and one predominantly White institution). Results confirmed expectations, such that greater media consumption was associated with greater support of traditional gender and sexual roles; in turn, endorsing these roles predicted lower levels of sexual assertiveness, greater sexual inhibition, and more frequent use of sexual dishonesty to retain a partner. We discuss implications of these findings for psychology and sexuality research and also for Black women's sexual relationships.
Dating and commitment choices as a function of ethnicity among American college students in California

Martin S Fiebert,Dusty Nugent,Scott L Hershberger,Margo Kasdan

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2466/pr0.94.3c.1293-1300

Abstract:The incidence of interracial and interethnic dating and marriage in the United States has increased. This investigation examined dating and commitment choices as a function of ethnicity and sex among groups of Euro-American, Hispanic-American, Asian-American, and African-American college students. A convenience sample of college students comprising 329 heterosexual subjects (134 men, 195 women) was surveyed regarding their partner preferences for dating, visiting parents, marriage, and bearing children. It was hypothesized that subjects would consider dating partners from different ethnic groups, but when making a commitment to marriage and children would prefer members of their own group. This hypothesis was supported in half of the groups: Euro-American men, African-American men, Asian-American women, and African-American women. A discussion of dating and commitment choices among ethnic and sex groups is presented and discussed.
How Black Teen Girls Navigate Social Media to Form Romantic Relationships

Veronica U. Weser,Ijeoma Opara,Brandon E. Sands,Claudia-Santi F. Fernandes,Kimberly D. Hieftje

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/20563051211033823

2021-07-01

Social Media + Society

Abstract:The purpose of this study was to explore the use of social media within the context of heterosexual Black teen girls’ romantic partner selection processes. To better understand Black teen girls’ experiences, five focus groups ( N = 27; aged 14–18 years) were conducted over Zoom. An inductive thematic analysis revealed four major themes: (1) the use of different platforms to gather different types of information, (2) the rules of social media scouting, (3) detecting partner qualities through social media, and (4) exploring Black teen girls’ experience with social media and dating. Participants in our study primarily used Instagram to understand a potential partner’s true self, while Twitter was used to assess a potential partner’s political leanings. Our participants shared numerous “rules” related to the partner-scouting process. Black teen girls in our study explained that photos index a potential partner’s style and hygiene, while memes were used to gauge sense of humor compatibility. More specific to Black teen girls, across all focus groups, participants shared their experiences of racism and bias, such as being associated with Black stereotypes, cultural invalidation, and being accused of “acting White.” Although teen girls of various racial and ethnic groups may use social media to vet romantic partners, findings reveal that Black teen girls navigate social media in a unique way, including being highly attuned to signs of bias. Our findings suggest that in the first few months of COVID-19 social distancing had little impact on our participant’s practice of using social media to vet potential romantic partners.

communication
Black Males' Structural Conditions, Achievement Patterns, Normative Needs, and “Opportunities”

Dena Phillips Swanson,Michael Cunningham,Margaret Beale Spencer

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/0042085903256218

2003-09-01

Urban Education

Abstract:The relations between normative developmental transitions, contextual influences, and life-stage outcomes such as academic achievement for African American males are examined. The integration ofaffective and cognitive processes are reviewed for preschool- and elementary-aged boys, and an empirical examination ofvulnerable and resilient outcomes of219 urban adolescent males is used to illustrate how structural conditions provide opportunities for vulnerable and successful academic outcomes. The results indicate that negative stereotyping and tracking from early experiences in educational settings influence African American males' scholastic achievement. By adolescence, given normative developmental experiences ofsocial mobility and increased cognitive reasoning, experiences in their community as well as school contexts influences African American males' reactive or proactive coping strategies that influence vulnerability and resilience in school. Suggestions for future research and intervention efforts are offered.

education & educational research,urban studies
Dating Apps and Shifting Sexual Subjectivities of Men Seeking Men Online

Barry D Adam,David J Brennan,Adam Wj Davies,David Collict

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12119-024-10231-1

Abstract:Leading theories of the recent history of sexuality have pointed to trends toward detraditionalization and precarity in intimate relations, but also to democratization and innovation. This study grounded in 79 qualitative interviews with men seeking men online considers their experiences in light of these theories. The rise of dating apps has generated sexual fields that have shaped the sexual subjectivities of the current era in multiple ways. The narratives of study participants show much more than the hook-up culture that dating apps are best known for. They speak to experiences of superficiality, unmet expectations, and sometimes bruising intersections with hierarchies defined by age, race, body type, gender expression, and serostatus. Yet at the same time, they show a strong aspiration to sociability, social network building, and reach for a language of affiliation beyond the kin and friendship terms of the larger society. Generational comparisons indicate the shifting sexual subjectivities that dating apps have shaped by constituting virtual sexual fields.
Love on campus: College students of color, racial identity, and interracial dating

Rob Eschmann,Shantel Gabrieal Buggs,Ryan Gryder

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/fare.12957

2023-10-13

Family Relations

Abstract:Objective This study explores the relationship between racial identity and interracial dating patterns. Background We draw on multiple literatures, including research on race and interracial dating, and the importance of racial identity on well‐being and mental health outcomes. Method Utilizing data from the National Longitudinal Survey of Freshmen we assess how dimensions of racial identity predict likelihood of interracial dating for Black, Asian, and Hispanic students enrolled at elite, predominantly White institutions of higher education. Results Multiple dimensions of racial identity predict whether Black or Asian students have dated interracially, and Hispanic students were more likely to have dated interracially than either Asian or Black students. School‐level characteristics, like the percentage of students who are White at each school, are the most consistent predictors of interracial dating patterns. Conclusions Our findings contribute to broader work on how interracial dating practices (in this case, specifically for college students of color) are influenced not just by the race and gender of the individuals but specifically the salience of their racial identity. Implications This study expands the potential research utility of racial identity measures and adds greater nuance to analyses of interracial relationships among emerging adults.

social work,family studies
Applying the Structure Versus Agency Discourse to the Challenges of Black Men Who Have Sex with Men

Sandra L. Barnes

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s12119-020-09777-7

2020-08-11

Abstract:Studies on the experiences of Black men who have sex with men (BMSM) often focus on HIV-related topics rather than other dimensions of their lives such as how they endeavor to be agentic as they navigate systemic forces. The Structure versus Agency discourse is used here as a theoretical backdrop to examine the challenges and reflections of BMSM. Based on a mixed-methodological analyses and 168 BMSM who reside in the South of the United States, the study considers whether and how they identify and respond to problems and tensions. Results show that BMSM emphasize personal challenges linked to economics, bullying, stereotypes, and intra-group tensions, often under the specter of racism, that result in greater salience of their racial and/or sexual identities. Moreover, despite references to structural impediments, BMSM are more apt to offer agency-based strategies for redress. Findings inform existing literature to better understand both the nuanced lives and varied needs of this population.
"It Doesn't Feel Like You Can Win": Young Women's Talk About Heterosexual Relationships

Tanja Samardzic,Paula C Barata,Mavis Morton,Jeffery Yen

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1177/03616843221135571

Abstract:Scholars have long explored the expectations of women to maintain intimate relationships and the gendered discourses governing those expectations. Despite the dating landscape changes, having intimate relationships remains important for young women. Amid these changes and the impacts of #MeToo/#TimesUp, investigating the discourses at play within women's talk about intimate relationships produces a current snapshot that contrasts with past literature. Young, heterosexual women of diverse racial, educational/work, and relationship backgrounds aged 18-24 years (N = 28) attended one of five online videoconferencing focus groups. Using an eclectic theoretical approach informed by feminist post-structuralism and discursive psychology, we analyzed women's talk about doing relationships. Mobilizing a discourse of intimate relationship necessity/importance, young women (a) were positioned as "the silenc(ed/ing) woman," demonstrating a shared understanding of the necessity of silence when doing intimate relationships; and/or (b) actively took up "the communicative woman," which they conceptualized as the hallmark of a healthy relationship. Tensions between these subject positions were evident (e.g., needing to be "cool"). Also, women described no-win situations in relationships despite attempts to contend with these contradictions and limitations. These findings may contribute to educational materials and youth programming delivered in high school or college.
Discrimination, gender, and class: An intersectional investigation of Black Americans’ personal and relational well-being.

TeKisha M. Rice,Brian G. Ogolsky

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1037/fam0001173

2024-01-18

Journal of Family Psychology

Abstract:Discrimination is a chronic stressor for Black Americans that occurs alongside other social positions and has implications for personal and relational well-being. Using data from the Survey of Midlife in the United States, this study examined the relative and multiplicative effects of gender and financial strain on the links between discrimination and personal and relational well-being among Black Americans in romantic relationships (<i>N</i> = 443). Results indicate that financial strain was associated with poorer personal well-being and that being female was associated with poorer relational well-being. Further, among women (but not men), discrimination was associated with poorer quality of life across levels of financial strain. The findings speak to the potential resilience of Black individuals and their relationships in the face of discrimination. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).

psychology, clinical,family studies

Gender Differences in the Dating Experiences of African American Young Adults: The Challenge of Forming Romantic Relationships Within the Context of Power Imbalance

Social-Contextual Influences on Adolescent Romantic Involvement: The Constraints of Being a Numerical Minority

Social Exchange and The Progression of Sexual Relationships in Emerging Adulthood

Racial Discrimination and Romantic Relationship Dynamics among Black Americans: A Systematic Review

Relational schemas, hostile romantic relationships, and beliefs about marriage among young African American adults

Gender Differences and Communication Technology Use among Emerging Adults in the Initiation of Dating Relationships

Understanding African American help‐seeking for romantic relationships: Advocacy, barriers, and considerations

Factors linking childhood experiences to adult romantic relationships among African Americans.

“A Little More Ghetto, a Little Less Cultured”: Are There Racial Stereotypes about Interracial Daters in the United States?

Adolescent Exposure to Racially and Ethnically Diverse Neighborhoods and Schools: Implications for Interracial Dating, Cohabitation, and Marriage in Emerging and Young Adulthood

"Don't you care about the well-being of your race?": African American couples discuss racial differences involving criticisms of other Black people

Something Old, Something New: Black Women, Interracial Dating, and the Black Marriage Crisis

Following Their Lead? Connecting Mainstream Media Use to Black Women’s Gender Beliefs and Sexual Agency

Dating and commitment choices as a function of ethnicity among American college students in California

How Black Teen Girls Navigate Social Media to Form Romantic Relationships

Black Males' Structural Conditions, Achievement Patterns, Normative Needs, and “Opportunities”

Dating Apps and Shifting Sexual Subjectivities of Men Seeking Men Online

Love on campus: College students of color, racial identity, and interracial dating

Applying the Structure Versus Agency Discourse to the Challenges of Black Men Who Have Sex with Men

"It Doesn't Feel Like You Can Win": Young Women's Talk About Heterosexual Relationships

Discrimination, gender, and class: An intersectional investigation of Black Americans’ personal and relational well-being.