Abstract:Background: The Affordable Care Act mandated triennial community health needs assessments (CHNAs) for greater nonprofit hospital accountability in responding to community health needs. Over 10 years later, hospital spending on community benefits remains largely unchanged. While greater collaboration in CHNA implementation can increase hospital investment in community-based initiatives, nonprofit hospitals in conservative states are subject to policy, political, and economic factors that inhibit public health partnerships and magnify existing disparities in health care access. This participatory action research study explores the decision-making environment of collaborative CHNA implementation within a group of nonprofit hospitals in a north Texas urban county. Methods: In 2017 faculty from an urban anchor institution initiated an academic-community partnership with a coalition of nonprofit hospitals, public health departments, and academic institutions. An interdisciplinary research team engaged in multi-method document review and qualitative data collection to describe historical barriers for local CHNA processes and develop practical strategies for joint CHNA initiatives. Local CHNA documents were first reviewed through team-based content analysis and results applied to develop a qualitative study protocol. Key informants were recruited from county-based nonprofit hospitals, community-based nonprofit organizations, and public health systems. Seventeen senior- and mid-level professionals participated in semi-structured research interviews to describe their perspectives relating to CHNA-related planning and implementation decisions. Through iterative data collection and analysis, the research team explored CHNA-related knowledge, experiences, and processes. A constructivist lens was subsequently applied to examine historical barriers and future opportunities for local collaboration. Results: Findings reveal CHNA implementation is a multi-stage cyclical process in organizational environments with accountability to a wide range of public and private stakeholders. This promotes varied levels of inclusivity and conservatism in data collection and community benefit implementation. Decisions to collaborate are hindered by competing priorities, including compliance with existing guidelines, administrative simplicity, alignment with health care service delivery, and efficient resource use. Efforts to promote greater CHNA collaboration may be facilitated through intentional alignment with organizational priorities and clearly communicated benefits of participation for leaders in both public and private nonprofit health systems. Discussion: We consider implications for policymakers and health systems in restrictive political environments and advance a conceptual framework for greater CHNA collaboration.

Applying network analysis to assess the development and sustainability of multi-sector coalitions

What are the reasons for clinical network success? A qualitative study

Augmenting Predictive Modeling Tools with Clinical Insights for Care Coordination Program Design and Implementation

Sharing Social Needs Data Across Sectors: Lessons From the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Innovation Center's Accountable Health Communities Model

Collaboration in Health Care and Social Service Networks for Older Adults: Association With Health Care Utilization Measures

Morehouse Choice Accountable Care Organization and Education System (MCACO-ES): Integrated Model Delivering Equitable Quality Care

Implementing the ACHIEVE Model to Prevent and Reduce Chronic Disease in Rural Klickitat County, Washington

Effects of Resource Sharing Networks on Community Anti-Drug Coalitions' Outcomes: A Social Network Analysis

Multisectoral partnerships to tackle complex health issues at the community level: lessons from a Healthy Communities Approach in rural Alberta, Canada

Using attendance data for social network analysis of a community-engaged research partnership

Sustainable Academic-Clinical Alliance: A Model to Improve Academic-Practice Partnerships

An action research partnership in an urban Texas county to explore barriers and opportunities for collaborative community health needs assessments

Catalyzing Cross-Sector Collaboration: Lessons from a Virtual Pediatric Complex Care Coalition

Association of a care coordination model with health care costs and utilization: the Johns Hopkins Community Health Partnership (J-CHiP)

Strengthening Community-Based Health and Human Services in the Shadow of Structural Inequality: A Critical Case Study of the Collective Impact Model

Insights From Implementation Of A Community-Based Model For Collaborative Public Good Investing

Engaging the underserved: a process model to mobilize rural community health coalitions as partners in translational research

Development of an academic-practice partnership model to anchor care coordination and population health

Pediatric accountable health communities: Insights on needed capabilities and potential solutions

The Harvard Medical School Academic Innovations Collaborative: transforming primary care practice and education

Sustainability Strategies for Multisector Community Partnerships Addressing Social Determinants of Health