Abstract:We investigate the issue in determining the significance of candidate transient gravitational-wave events in a ground-based interferometer network. Given the presence of non-Gaussian noise artefacts in real data, the noise background must be estimated empirically from the data itself. However, the data also potentially contains signals, thus the background estimate may be overstated due to contributions from signals. It has been proposed to mitigate possible bias by removing single-detector data samples that pass a multi-detector consistency test from the background estimates. We conduct a high-statistics Mock Data Challenge to evaluate the effects of removing such samples, modelling a range of scenarios with plausible detector noise distributions and with a range of plausible foreground astrophysical signal rates. We consider the two different modes: one in which coincident samples are removed, and one in which all samples are retained and used. Three algorithms were operated in both modes, show good consistency with each other; however, discrepancies arise between the results obtained under the "coincidence removal" and "all samples" modes, for false alarm probabilities below a certain value. In most scenarios the median of the false alarm probability (FAP) estimator under the "all samples" mode is consistent with the exact FAP. On the other hand the "coincidence removal" mode is found to be unbiased for the mean of the estimated FAP. While the numerical values at which discrepancies become apparent are specific to the details of our experiment, we believe that the qualitative differences in the behaviour of the median and mean of the FAP estimator have more general validity. On the basis of our study we suggest that the FAP of candidates for the first detection of gravitational waves should be estimated without removing single-detector samples that form coincidences.

Noise spectral estimation methods and their impact on gravitational wave measurement of compact binary mergers

Parameter estimation with non stationary noise in gravitational waves data

Bayesian power spectral estimation of gravitational wave detector noise revisited

Calibrating signal-to-noise ratio detection thresholds using gravitational-wave catalogs

Data analysis strategies for the detection of gravitational waves in non-Gaussian noise

Gravitational-Wave Parameter Estimation in non-Gaussian noise using Score-Based Likelihood Characterization

A Sensitive Test of Non-Gaussianity in Gravitational-wave Detector Data

Gravitational-wave parameter estimation with relative binning: Inclusion of higher-order modes and precession, and applications to lensing and third-generation detectors

Inferring Binary Properties from Gravitational Wave Signals

Foreground signals minimally affect inference of high-mass binary black holes in next generation gravitational-wave detectors

Method for estimation of gravitational-wave transient model parameters in frequency-time maps

Toward robust detections of nanohertz gravitational waves

Measuring violations of General Relativity from single gravitational wave detection by non-spinning binary systems: higher-order asymptotic analysis

The effect of noise artefacts on gravitational-wave searches for neutron star post-merger remnants

Systematic errors in estimation of gravitational-wave candidate significance

Effect of Noise Estimation in Time-Domain Ringdown Analysis: A Case Study with GW150914

Detecting non-Gaussian gravitational wave backgrounds: a unified framework

Extension of the characterization method for non-Gaussianity in gravitational wave detector with statistical hypothesis test

Astrophysical and cosmological relevance of the high-frequency features in the stochastic gravitational-wave background