Abstract:Hans-Christian Kolberg 1 , Rachel Würstlein 2 1 Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Marienhospital Bottrop, Bottrop, Germany; 2 Breast Cancer Center, Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Ludwig-Maximilian-University Hospital, Munich, Germany Comment on: Diao K, Lei X, He W, et al . Patient-Reported Quality of Life after Breast Conserving Surgery with Radiotherapy versus Mastectomy and Reconstruction. Ann Surg 2023;278:e1096-e1102. Keywords: Breast cancer; mastectomy; breast conserving surgery; quality of life; patient-reported outcome (PRO) Submitted Dec 20, 2023. Accepted for publication Feb 27, 2024. Published online Mar 22, 2024. doi: 10.21037/gs-23-522 In a population-based study of long-term quality of life among breast cancer survivors, Diao et al. demonstrated an association of mastectomy and reconstruction with worse sexual well-being compared to breast conserving surgery and radiotherapy. Patients older than 65 who received breast conserving surgery and radiotherapy and young patients who received mastectomy and autologous reconstruction reported the highest quality of life scores. Of the 1,215 included patients with breast cancer stage 0–II and a median follow up of 9 years, 631 had received breast conserving surgery and radiotherapy and 584 had been treated by mastectomy and reconstruction. All patients answered paper surveys using BREAQST-Q and Patient-Reported Outcome Measurement Information System (PROMIS). Of the items investigated, including psychosocial well-being, physical function and well-being, upper extremity function, satisfaction with breasts and sexual well-being, only sexual well-being showed a statistically significant difference between the two groups as mentioned above. No difference in overall survival could be demonstrated. However, the use of chemotherapy had a negative impact (1). With a median follow up of 9 years the authors focused on long term quality of life. This is a very important aspect of the analysis, because it is known that quality of life changes over time. Short-term analyses demonstrate a better quality of life in patients after breast conserving surgery compared to mastectomy (2). In a recently published study from Germany, patients after mastectomy had an impairment of quality of life shortly after surgery whereas after 24 months it had improved substantially and was even better than in patients after breast conserving surgery (3). Satisfaction after reconstructive surgery also changes over time. While the satisfaction with the body image improves after breast conserving surgery and simple mastectomy, the opposite has been demonstrated for mastectomy and immediate reconstruction (4). These findings underscore the importance of long-term approaches as chosen in the study conducted by Diao et al. The main goal of breast surgery for early breast cancer—survival—is always a long-term endpoint. But other endpoints like quality of life and body image also have to be investigated with an adequate follow up, because in a situation with curative intent the next 10 to 20 years do matter. Age plays an important role in the deterioration of quality of life after breast cancer surgery. While this has been demonstrated for all surgical approaches, the effect is more pronounced after mastectomy (5). In another recently published analysis young age was associated with poorer social and sexual function, as well as poorer sexual enjoyment and lower expectations of the future (6). These data demonstrate the importance to include the factor age in all analyses regarding quality of life after breast cancer surgery. The new aspect in the work discussed here is that there is a difference between women younger than 50 and women older than 65 in the long-term quality of life depending on the type of surgery, with younger women being more satisfied with mastectomy and autologous (but not implant) reconstruction and older women with breast conserving surgery and radiation. This result can add a very important aspect in the situation of preoperative counseling. However, many factors have an impact on the quality of life and this is not always associated with the type of surgery. Thus the interpretation of dichotome results as in the paper of Diao et al. always warrants caution. Some caveats and limitations of the analysis have to be mentioned. The approach of a long-term follow up resulted in a response rate of only 25% and that may have an impact on the results and furthermore as always in long-term observations included patients with techniques of surgery and radiation as well as systemic regimens that are no longer state of the art. Also adding to the possibility of a selection bias is the fact that the indications for mastectomy are not discussed. Maybe the decision for a mastectomy in a situation where -Abstract Truncated-

Dynamic changes in quality of life, psychological status, and body image in women who underwent a mastectomy as compared with breast reconstruction: an 8-year follow up

Dynamic Changes in Quality of Life, Psychological Status, and Body Image in Women With Different Types of Breast Cancer Surgery: 8-year Follow Up

Breast conserving surgery versus mastectomy: the effect of surgery on quality of life in breast cancer survivors in Malaysia

The role of breast reconstruction choice on body image patient‐reported outcomes at four years post‐mastectomy for breast cancer: A longitudinal prospective cohort study

A Comparison of Patient-Reported Outcomes After Breast-Conserving Surgery and Mastectomy with Implant Breast Reconstruction

Life satisfaction, body image and associated factors among women with breast cancer after mastectomy

Psychosocial effect of mastectomy versus conservative surgery in patients with early breast cancer

Long-term quality of life after breast surgery—are breast conserving surgery and mastectomy comparable?

Impact on the quality of surgical breast cancer patients at different stages of life

Enhancing Women's Quality of Life: Exploring the Impact of Mastectomy with and without Breast Reconstruction among Breast Cancer Survivors in Iraq

Psychological impact and cosmetic outcome of surgical breast cancer strategies

Dynamics in Quality of Life of Breast Cancer Patients Following Breast-Conserving Surgery Versus Mastectomy: Protocol for Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

Health-related quality of life following breast reconstruction compared to total mastectomy and breast-conserving surgery among breast cancer survivors: a systematic review and meta-analysis

Comparing Quality of Life in Breast Cancer Patients Who Underwent Mastectomy Versus Breast-Conserving Surgery: A Meta-Analysis

Disparities in quality of life among patients with breast cancer based on surgical methods: a cross-sectional prospective study

[Effects of mastectomy on dimensions of psychological and psychosocial experience and behavior of affected women]

Assessment of the quality of life in breast cancer depending on the surgical treatment

Longitudinal Trends in Patient-Reported Outcomes in the First Year After Lumpectomy Versus Mastectomy

The Effects of Surgery Type and Chemotherapy on Early-Stage Breast Cancer Patients' Quality of Life Over 2-Year Follow-up