Does Chinese Social Work Students’ Career Intention Match Their Professional Identity? the Role of Background Factors
Tingting Liu,Songguo Yi,Yuhong Zhu
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1093/bjsw/bcac201
2022-01-01
Abstract:Professional identity is essential for the career choice of social work. Exploring social work students' perceptions of professional identity and career intention is necessary to understand the phenomenon of major-to-occupation mismatch in China. The present study involved a national sample of 2,018 social work undergraduates and postgraduates to investigate whether students displayed matching levels of professional identity and career intention and the association with their personal and educational background. To differentiate between social work as a discipline and an occupation, the concept of professional identity was split into two variables: disciplinary and occupational identity. Three groups of students were identified and labelled as having matching perceptions (49.8/44.1 per cent), lower disciplinary/occupational identity and higher career intention (7.8/5.6 per cent) and higher disciplinary/occupational identity and lower career intention (42.5/50.3 per cent), respectively. Multinomial logistic regression analyses revealed that students' residential area, family economic status, degree programme, grade of study, university category and university location were significantly associated with whether they reported matching levels of professional identity and career intention. The findings can be explained by the imbalanced development of social work education and practice in China, implying the necessity of promoting social work employment benefits and cooperation between academic institutions and service organisations. In China, most students majoring in social work do not choose the profession as their career, which is known as major-to-occupation mismatch. To understand the unique phenomenon, it is important to explore how students' background factors contribute to the mismatch between professional identity and career choice. The present study split the concept of professional identity into disciplinary and occupational identity. All students were classified into three groups: those with matching perceptions (49.8/44.1 per cent); those with lower disciplinary/occupational identity and higher career intention (7.8/5.6 per cent); and those with higher disciplinary/occupational identity and lower career intention (42.5/50.3 per cent). Students' personal and educational backgrounds-such as residential area, family economic status, degree programme, grade of study, university category and university location-were found to influence perceived matching levels of professional identity and career intention. The mismatched perceptions are rooted in the imbalanced development of social work education and practice in China, which impedes the supply of trained talent and cultivation of professional competence in the field. Therefore, more efforts are needed to improve the employment benefits and cooperation between academic institutions and service organisations to promote social work development in China towards a more balanced direction.