Abstract:The microbiome includes both ‘mutualist’ and ‘pathogen’ microbes, regulated by the same innate immune architecture. A major question has therefore been: how do hosts prevent pathogenic infections while maintaining beneficial microbes? One idea suggests hosts can selectively activate innate immunity upon pathogenic infection, but not mutualist colonization. Another idea posits that hosts can selectively attack pathogens, but not mutualists. Here I review evolutionary principles of microbe recognition and immune activation, and reflect on newly observed immune effector–microbe specificity perhaps supporting the latter idea. Recent work in Drosophila has found a surprising importance for single antimicrobial peptides in combatting specific ecologically relevant microbes. The developing picture suggests these effectors have evolved for this purpose. Other defence responses like reactive oxygen species bursts can also be uniquely effective against specific microbes. Signals in other model systems including nematodes, Hydra , oysters, and mammals, suggest that effector–microbe specificity may be a fundamental principle of host–pathogen interactions. I propose this effector–microbe specificity stems from weaknesses of the microbes themselves: if microbes have intrinsic weaknesses, hosts can evolve effectors that exploit those weaknesses. I define this host–microbe relationship as ‘the Achilles principle of immune evolution’. Incorporating this view helps interpret why some host–microbe interactions develop in a coevolutionary framework (e.g. Red Queen dynamics), or as a one-sided evolutionary response. This clarification should be valuable to better understand the principles behind host susceptibilities to infectious diseases. This article is part of the theme issue ‘Sculpting the microbiome: how host factors determine and respond to microbial colonization’.

Cross-Kingdom Infection of Macrophages Reveals Pathogen- and Immune-Specific Global Reprogramming and Adaptation

A Human Commensal-Pathogenic Fungus Suppresses Host Immunity Via Targeting TBK1

Infectogenomics: Aspect Of Host Responses To Microbes In Digestive Tract

Commensal-to-pathogen transition: One-single transposon insertion results in two pathoadaptive traits in Escherichia coli -macrophage interaction

Gut microbiome carbon and sulfur metabolisms support during pathogen infection

Stratifying macrophages based on their infectious burden identifies novel host targets for intervention during Crohn’s disease associated adherent-invasive infection

Modulation of Macrophage Immunometabolism: A New Approach to Fight Infections

After the Infection: A Survey of Pathogens and Non-communicable Human Disease

Immunometabolic crosstalk during bacterial infection

Innate immunity to intracellular pathogens: macrophage receptors and responses to microbial entry

The cross talk between microbiota and the immune system: metabolites take center stage

Genome Analyses of A Worldwide Multisource Collection of Reveal Adaptation Relevant for Human Infection

Stratifying macrophages based on their infectious burden identifies novel host targets for intervention during Crohn's disease associated adherent-invasive Escherichia coli infection

Within-host competition sparks pathogen molecular evolution and perpetual microbiota dysbiosis

Innate and Adaptive Immunity Cooperate Flexibly to Maintain Host-Microbiota Mutualism.

Dynamic genetic adaptation of Bacteroides thetaiotaomicron during murine gut colonization

Macrophages As Drivers of an Opportunistic Infection

Rapid Transcriptional and Metabolic Adaptation of Intestinal Microbes to Host Immune Activation.

Inter-kingdom relationships in Crohn's disease explored using a multi-omics approach

The past, present and future of polymicrobial infection research: Modelling, eavesdropping, terraforming and other stories

When the microbiome shapes the host: immune evolution implications for infectious disease