Where have all the beetles gone? Long‐term study reveals carabid species decline in a nature reserve in Northern Germany
Katharina Homburg,Claudia Drees,Estève Boutaud,Dorothea Nolte,Wiebke Schuett,Pascale Zumstein,Eick Ruschkowski,Thorsten Assmann
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/icad.12348
IF: 4.266
2019-04-01
Insect Conservation and Diversity
Abstract:In recent years, a drastic decline of insects has been detected in diverse habitats and ecosystems (Dirzo <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0018">2014</a></span>; Hallmann <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0025">2017</a></span>). Since then the insect decline has received a lot of attention, both in ecological and conservation research and in public media as the phenomenon might occur globally at a high pace, with yet unknown ecological consequences (Leather, <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0037">2018</a></span>). However, to entomologists this decline was not surprising news since early compilations (Didham <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0016">1996</a></span>), older studies (e.g. Driscoll & Weir, <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0019">2005</a></span>; Haskell, <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0027">2000</a></span>) or analyses of red lists and large‐scaled inventories (e.g. Desender <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0014">2010</a></span>; Schmidt <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0060">2016</a></span>) had already shown an increasing number of threatened and vulnerable insect species. One meaningful approach to deliver a better evidence base to understand extent, significance and potential drivers of the fate of insect populations and species is to carry out long‐term studies on specific sites. Only in such studies changes in assemblages or population sizes across time can be related to possible explanatory factors such as land use or climatic changes (e.g. Dieker <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0017">2011</a></span>). Such studies can surely help to collect valuable information needed to develop effective conservation measures for insect populations, species and communities. Currently, long‐term data on species' occurrences revealing insights into insect diversity and abundance trends are rare (see for exception: Brooks <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0010">2012</a></span>; Hallmann <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0026">2018</a></span>). This is in contrast to several well‐organised monitoring programs on birds and mammals (cf. Battersby & Greenwood, <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0002">2003</a></span>; Schmeller <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0059">2012</a></span>) that have already generated solid data over large temporal and spatial scales. Insects are the most diverse taxon on Earth in terms of species numbers, with beetles representing the largest proportion of this group of organisms. Insects are of considerable importance for ecosystem functioning (Samways, <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0057">2005</a></span>). Especially carabids can be used as indicators for habitat quality, environmental changes as well as ecosystem resilience (Koivula, <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0033">2011</a></span>) and are of high importance for the assessment of environmental impacts as well as for the evaluation of conservation measures (e.g. Kotze <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0034">2011</a></span>; Thom <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0064">2017</a></span>). Thus, the implementation of suitable conservation strategies for such a functionally important taxon requires specifically designed long‐term studies to enhance our understanding of potential drivers of diversity loss. The few long‐term trapping studies of carabids have focused mostly on heathland and grassland species (e.g. Hallmann <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0026">2018</a></span>; van Noordwijk <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0046">2017</a></span>). On local and country level, long‐term studies on carabids demonstrate in general a declining trend of species numbers and biomass (Hallmann <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0026">2018</a></span>; Kotze <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0034">2011</a></span>). Brooks <i>et al</i>. (<span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0010">2012</a></span>) revealed a similar trend for open habitat types in Great Britain and presume land‐use intensification in agricultural landscapes to be the main driver of species and biomass decline in carabids. In less intensively used forests and hedgerows, however, carabid abundance increased significantly (Brooks <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0010">2012</a></span>). Since forest management in some regions (e.g. Central Europe) has developed to be less intensive and more sustainable than in previous centuries (Brang <i>et al</i>., <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0009">2014</a></span>; Niedersächsisches Ministerium für Ernährung, Landwirtschaft und Forsten, <span><a href="#icad12348-bib-0042">1997</a></span>), carabid diversity and abundance may have increased also in Central European woodlands. In contrast, other arthropod taxa indicate a poor conservation status of Central European forests (Seibold <i>et al</i>., <span><a <p>-Abstract Truncated-</p>
entomology