Abstract:The present paper provides some arguments surrounding the controversies of boundary vorticity creation for incompressible viscous flow. Our discussion shows that boundary vorticity creation must be a viscous physical process. Importantly, it is emphasized that not only viscosity is responsible for spreading the generated vorticity out of the boundary, but also must be involved in the process of boundary vorticity creation to realize the no-slip boundary condition. Lyman flux is a part of the boundary vorticity flux under the Lighthill-Panton-Wu's definition, which provides an alternative interpretation of boundary vorticity dynamics. Different from the existing inviscid interpretation, we insist that viscosity is fully indispensable for generating the Lyman flux through the tangential boundary acceleration and surface pressure gradient where the acceleration adherence is shown to be derived from the velocity adherence directly. Through a detailed discussion on interfacial vortex sheet and slip velocity, it is revealed that the velocity jump across the material interfacial vortex sheet (a thin viscous shear layer as the fluid viscosity approaches to zero) is physically different from that across the interface. In addition, it is shown that the formation of surface pressure distribution is an inviscid process while the subsequent boundary vorticity generation by the tangential pressure gradient must be a viscid process (contributed by the non-equilibrium particle relaxation effect). These two processes are separated by a non-zero time increment with the same order as the particle relaxation time. Then, the hydrodynamic limit of the Boltzmann equation is revisited to elaborate the crucial roles of viscosity for both the continuum and slip regimes. For continuum flows with a no-slip boundary, the physical carrier of the slip velocity in the inviscid Euler theory originates from the produced vorticity concentrated in the thin material vortex sheet. Interestingly, we find that Lyman flux must be a viscous boundary flux even for a slip boundary where the implicit viscid mechanism is attributed to the non-continuum effect hidden in the Knudsen layer. The present exploration suggests that a complete physical picture including the boundary vorticity creation and the formation of airfoil circulation should be built upon the viscous flow theory.

Indirect physical mechanism of viscous forces: vortex stretching and twisting

On physics of boundary vorticity creation in incompressible viscous flow

Twisting vortex lines regularize Navier-Stokes turbulence

The force on a body moving in an inviscid fluid

Viscous Strength of Water

Steady Vortex Force Theory and Slender-Wing Flow Diagnosis

Vibrations of Cylindrical Objects Obstructing a Poiseuille-type Flow

Vortex shedding and induced forces in unsteady flow

Newton saw the truth -- on the nature of fluid flow and viscous interaction

Nonlinear asymptotic stability of compressible vortex sheets with viscosity effects

Vorticity amplification in viscoelastic channel flows with long-wave surface distortions

Sinuous Distortion Of Vortex Surfaces In The Lateral Growth Of Turbulent Spots

Vortical Fluid-Dynamic Force and Moment

A Theoretical Framework of Vorticity Dynamics for Two Dimensional Flows on Fixed Smooth Surfaces

Integral Force Acting on a Body Due to Local Flow Structures

A Two-Dimensional Multibody Integral Approach for Forces in Inviscid Flow with Free Vortices and Vortex Production

Depicting Vortex Stretching and Vortex Relaxing Mechanisms

Vorticity gradient stretching in the direct enstrophy transfer process of two-dimensional turbulence

Experimental Study on the Role of Spanwise Vorticity and Vortex Filaments in the Outer Region of Open-Channel Flow

Filament formation via the instability of a stretching viscous sheet: Physical mechanism, linear theory, and fiber applications