Abstract:We compare Joule Heating rates as derived from ground-based magnetic field and all-sky camera data, from Low Earth Orbit satellite data (ESA Swarm) and from a MHD simulation (GUMICS-5) with each other in a case study of an auroral arc system. The observational estimates of Joule Heating rates provide information on regional scales and with high spatial resolution (10–100 km). Their comparison with global MHD results is conducted for a quiet time interval of a few minutes, just before a magnetic substorm. Analysis of the ground-based observations yields electric field with dominating North-South component pointing towards the arcs and having maxima values in the range 20–35 V/km. Combining these values with Pedersen conductance estimates from optical data (5–10 S) yields Joule Heating rates in the range 2.5–3.5 mW/m 2 . Swarm electric field measurements are consistent in their direction and intensity with the ground-based estimates. They also show that heating is increased particularly in the region where the conductance is low. The total amount of Joule heating in the area between the Swarm A and C satellite footprints while crossing the all-sky camera field of view is estimated to be 46 MW and the total amount energy dissipation during the 80 s overflight is around 3.6 GJ (1000 kWh). GUMICS-5 estimate of the peak Joule Heating in the magnetic local time sector of the arc system is smaller than that from the ground-based data with a factor of 2.9. Comparisons of GUMICS-5 results with Space Weather Modelling Framework (SWMF), shows that the latter gives on average larger heating rates being thus more consistent with our regional observations. However, both MHD-codes yield smaller Joule Heating rates around the time of the arcs and during the following substorm than the CTIP-e code. CTIP-e has a more detailed description of ionosphere-thermosphere interactions than the MHD-codes and its convection electric field is enhanced with a randomly varying additional component mimicking small scale structures. GUMICS-SWMF comparisons of global Joule Heating patterns in the Northern polar area reveal that the two simulations have significant differences in their spatial distribution of heating rates. Main cause for these deviations is the difference in the derivation of ionospheric Pedersen conductance. Our results emphasize the fact that future estimates of the global energetics in the magnetosphere–ionosphere–thermosphere system require better knowledge on ionospheric conductivities, both by new measurement concepts and by better understanding on the background physics controlling conductivity variations.

Latitudinal Impacts of Joule Heating on the High‐Latitude Thermospheric Density Enhancement during Geomagnetic Storms

Wind and Temperature Effects on Thermosphere Mass Density Response to the November 2004 Geomagnetic Storm

Thermospheric Density Perturbations Produced by Traveling Atmospheric Disturbances during August 2005 Storm

Analyzing the Hemispheric Asymmetry in the Thermospheric Density Response to Geomagnetic Storms

On the relationship between thermosphere density and solar wind parameters during intense geomagnetic storms

High‐ and Middle‐Latitude Neutral Mesospheric Density Response to Geomagnetic Storms

Responses of Thermospheric Mass Densities to the October 2016 and September 2017 Geomagnetic Storms Revealed From Multiple Satellite Observations

Rapid recovery of thermosphere density during the October 2003 geomagnetic storms

Importance of Regional‐Scale Auroral Precipitation and Electrical Field Variability to the Storm‐Time Thermospheric Temperature Enhancement and Inversion Layer (TTEIL) in the Antarctic E Region

Observations and simulations of the ionospheric and thermospheric response to the December 2006 geomagnetic storm: Initial phase

Joule Heating rate at high-latitudes by Swarm and ground-based observations compared to MHD simulations

Low and middle latitude thermosphere and ionosphere responses to geomagnetic activity

Ionospheric Response to the Initial Phase of Geomagnetic Storms: Common Features

An Empirical Relation to Correct Storm-Time Thermospheric Mass Density Modeled by NRLMSISE-00 with CHAMP Satellite Air Drag Data

Study on the Thermospheric Density Distribution Pattern During Geomagnetic Activity

A Comparison Of The Effects Of Cir- And Cme-Induced Geomagnetic Activity On Thermospheric Densities And Spacecraft Orbits: Case Studies

Vertical Characterization on Global Ionospheric Variations During the Magnetic Storm in September 2017 with Hierarchical Subtraction Method

The Impact of Helium on Thermosphere Mass Density Response to Geomagnetic Activity During the Recent Solar Minimum

Changes in the longitudinal structure of the low-latitude ionosphere during the July 2004 sequence of geomagnetic storms

Different Effects of a Super Storm on Atmospheric Electric Fields at Different Latitudes