The role of agricultural cooperatives in serving as a marketing channel: evidence from low-income regions of Sichuan province in China

Yuying Liu,Wanglin Ma,Alan Renwick,Xinhong Fu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22434/IFAMR2018.0058

2019-10-07

International Food and Agribusiness Management Review

Abstract:International Food and Agribusiness Management Review, Ahead of Print.

agricultural economics & policy

What problem does this paper attempt to address?

Farmer cooperatives in China: frontiers in development and research

Qiao Liang,Ziming Han

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4337/9781802202618.00037

2023-01-01

Abstract:Agriculture in China is featured by the large quantities of smallholder farmers due to limited farmland and large rural population. Farmer cooperatives are considered to play an essential role in promoting common prosperity in rural areas in China. This paper firstly introduces the principles and governance features of Chinese cooperatives, with a special focus on the distinction between core and common members. Then we map the development of China's farmer cooperatives by an overview of the numbers of cooperatives, membership size, revenue, and governmental support for cooperatives. Next, a systematic review of farmer cooperatives in the Chinese literature is conducted to analyze the main topics that Chinese scholars focus on in recent years.
Cooperation Performance and its Surplus Allocation along Agri-food Supply Chain during "Farmer-Supermarket Direct Purchase"——Evidence from the Mode of "Farmer+Cooperative+Supermarket"

Shi Sheng,Wei Longbao,Wu Junqian

2012-01-01

Abstract:Using the survey data in the province of Shandong,Hainan and Zhejiang and taking the process from production to sale of broccoli as the example,the paper analyses the cooperation performance and its surplus allocation among farmers,cooperatives and supermarkets during "farmer-supermarket direct purchase".The results indicate that,an effective cooperation based on the mode of "farmer + cooperative + supermarket" among farmers,cooperatives and supermarkets has successfully increased broccoli's market value.The econometrics model results of factors of farmer's net income per Mu of producing broccoli also show that,marketing channel has significant effect on farmer's net income per Mu of producing broccoli.From "cooperative directly sale broccoli to supermarket",farmers gain more net income than that of other farmers via "cooperative but not directly sale to supermarket" and "sale not through cooperative".Furthermore,surplus allocation depends on the partners' ability of information acquisition and risk control during "farmer-supermarket direct purchase".Among the three partners of supply chain,a part of the surplus act as farmer's efficiency wage regarding production,a part of the surplus is shared by cooperatives as economical rent for their social network resources and the remains is distributed to the supermarket in the form of excess profit.
Cooperatives As Competitive Yardstick in the Hog Industry?—evidence from China

Qiao Liang,Xinxin Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/agr.21630

2019-01-01

Agribusiness

Abstract:The competitive yardstick role of marketing cooperatives refers to the fact that the presence of cooperatives drives the market towards competitiveness. We conduct an empirical study based on panel data from the hog industry in China to examine the existence of competitive yardstick effect of cooperatives. Data including information regarding hog producer cooperatives, farm gate prices of hogs, and other relevant factors in China's 21 provinces in the years 2009–2012 are used. Various methods, including ordinary least squares regression, random‐effect model, and fixed‐effect model, are adopted to predict the effect of cooperatives development on farm gate prices. The results confirm the role of hog producer cooperatives as the competitive yardstick of markets, that is, a positive effect of strength of cooperatives on the farm gate prices received by hog producers with various production sizes. [EconLit classifications: Q13, L16]
The Role of Farmer Cooperatives in Promoting Environmentally Sustainable Agricultural Development in China: A Review

Qiao Liang,Kewei Ma,Wenhao Liu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1111/apce.12444

2023-01-01

Abstract:Environmentally sustainable agricultural development is an essential part of the Sustainable Development Goals proposed by the United Nations in 2015. This article systematically reviews studies on the role of farmer cooperatives in promoting environmentally sustainable agricultural development and uses China as a case study to analyze the measures and function mechanisms of farmer cooperatives in promoting the adoption and scaling of sustainable farming practices by farmers. Farmer cooperatives in China influence farmers’ farming practices and benefits by not only serving farmers with various information and technologies but also supervising farmers’ production processes. Nevertheless, farmer cooperatives, both in general and in China in particular, face challenges in effectively promoting the adoption of environmentally sustainable farming practices. A few policy implications are proposed based on these analyses.
Do Chinese Farmers Need Their Cooperatives:An Empirical Analysis of Farmers' Attitude to These Organizations in Coastal China

石敏俊,金少胜

DOI: https://doi.org/10.3785/j.issn.1008-942x.2004.03.005

2004-01-01

Abstract:This paper focuses on Chinese farmers' attitudes and preference to farmers' cooperatives in the coast areas, based upon a survey conducted in 2002 in East China's Zhejiang Province. In the past decade, as the most developed province of coastal China, Zhejiang's agricultural development has undergone a significant structural change. Commercial management has become a leading factor of agricultural development. Agricultural commercialization has induced needs for farmers' cooperatives to provide individual farmers with services in marketing, information and technological guidance. More than half of the producers have manifested positive attitude to join cooperatives. Up to now, however, only about 2% of the farmers have been involved in farmers' cooperatives. Most of them still seek help mainly from relatives or friends, or turn to pay commercial service, when they come across problems about information, technology, seasonally inadequate labor and capital input. An increase in the number of part-time farmers and those giving up farming has become such a factor as to prevent individual farmers from involving themselves in farmers' cooperatives. Unwillingness on the part of experienced farmers such as flower producers to share their technology of intensive farming with others is also considered to be a negative factor for the establishment of farmers' cooperatives. Better educated farmers and those who have made considerable investment in intensive farming have been obviously active in setting up farmers' cooperatives, of which they may become initiators. Good policies will be of significance to promote farmers' cooperatives. The replacement of supply and marketing cooperatives by farmers' cooperatives is one of them. Finally, farmers' knowledge of their right to vote, membership, stipulations about joining and withdrawing from a cooperative, etc. will be favorable for them to adopt a positive attitude towards the cooperatives. The proper design of the structure of the cooperatives will also be of vital importance to attract more farmers to join such cooperatives.
Characterizing Cooperatives In China

Yining Xu,George W. J. Hendrikse,Hongdong Guo,Qiao Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-57276-5_12

2017-01-01

Abstract:Scholars question whether Chinese cooperatives are different from Western cooperatives. Five cooperatives in Zhejiang province are described, and they are evaluated from various perspectives. Next we address various differences between cooperatives in China and the Western world. We highlight aspects of the political and the economic environment, such as the farmland system, the cooperative law, the financial support and intervention from the government, the limited education of most farmers, and the substantial capital requirements in order to have a successful cooperative.
A Hybrid Form of Agricultural Organization: the Case of the Beizhijiang Vegetable Cooperative in China

Qiao Liang,Weibin Hu,Fu Jia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22434/ifamr2018.0006

2019-01-01

Abstract:Farmer cooperatives in China have been developing a hybrid form of governance with features that are seldom observed in other countries. The Beizhijiang vegetable cooperative (hereafter BZJ cooperative), which was founded in 2009, is a case in point. The chairperson of the BZJ cooperative has dominant control over the decision-making and income rights of the cooperative and is also president of the Pangu corporation, a downstream buyer of BZJ products. The purpose of this case study is to allow students to understand the special form of the cooperative in a Chinese context and to compare it to the International Cooperative Association principles regarding cooperatives. This article is aimed at senior undergraduate and graduate students in agribusiness management and agricultural economics and has practical value for agricultural enterprises and related governmental departments.
Adoption of Food Safety and Quality Standards by China’s Agricultural Cooperatives: A Way out of Monitoring Production Practices of Numerous Small-scale Farmers ?

Jiehong Zhou,Shaosheng Jin

2009-01-01

Abstract:China has experienced frequently food safety scares due to pesticide residue issues in recent years. This excessive of illegal use is often tied to numerous small-scale farmers. As it is a great challenge for Chinese government to monitor production practices of small-scale farmers directly, encouraging the adoption of food safety and quality standards by China’s agricultural cooperatives serves as an alternative approach to monitor the production practices of the small-scale farmers, and thus ensure improved quality of foods they produce. Based on the survey data from 124 vegetable cooperatives in Zhejiang Province, this study is designed to analyze the factors that affect adoption of food safety and quality standards by agricultural cooperatives in China. Our qualitative analysis suggests that cooperative size, perception and attitude toward standards, reputation, expected cost and benefit and the destination market have positive and statistically significant relationship with the cooperatives decision to adopt standards. The positive and significant effects of other factors such as innovativeness, price premium, customer attraction, and availability of support are not confirmed. Policy implications to encourage the adoption of food safety and quality standards by agricultural cooperatives are also discussed.
Understanding Farmer Cooperatives' Self-Inspection Behavior to Guarantee Agri-Product Safety in China

Jiehong Zhou,Zhen Yan,Kai Li

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2015.05.035

IF: 6

2016-01-01

Food Control

Abstract:Both global and domestic markets place increasing importance on the quality and safety of food products that are produced in China. The presence of microbial agents, toxic animal and plant products and chemical contamination remain because of the existence of small and dispersed farmers, who are not educated to use agricultural inputs correctly. This inability raises the issue of safety control in the agricultural sector. This study proposes that cooperatives' self-inspection of agricultural products before they enter the market can better organize small farmers to utilize a standardized production and safety management system. Therefore, we attempt to explore the factors that influence farmer cooperatives' self-inspection behavior. An Ordered Logistic Regression Model is employed to estimate the factors that influence cooperatives' choices of inspection frequency. The results show that the respondents expressed a medium to high level of implementing self-inspection but a lower level of concern in testing products by batch. The regression results indicate that subjective norms from the social environment, the perceived behavioral control of managers, ability and rules including input management, production documentation, and social demographic variables, significantly affect cooperatives' self-inspection behavior. The future implementation of safety inspection depends on the extent to which subjective norms, ability, and internal rules can improve agri-product safety in China.
Technological Innovation in Agricultural Co-Operatives in China: Implications for Agro-Food Innovation Policies

Jianli Luo,Hongdong Guo,Fu Jia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodpol.2017.09.001

IF: 6.08

2017-01-01

Food Policy

Abstract:Technological innovation has become a major source of farmer co-operatives’ competitive advantage, however empirical research on co-operatives innovation in a developing country context is rare. We adopt an ethnographic case study method collecting data from 32 co-operatives managers of four exemplar co-operative cases and agricultural experts in China and collected much archival data. In addition, a Delphi study was conducted to collect data on the innovation performance. Based on the distinctive characteristics of co-operatives, we found that first knowledge spillovers and technology acquisition modes are two constructs which best capture the dynamic of technological innovation in co-operatives and develop a typology based on them. Second, grassroots and social innovation in a Chinese co-operative context have their own characters and indeed a hybrid of capitalism (e.g., agribusiness) and New Rural Re-structuring principles (i.e., similar to ICA ones). Third and finally, we provide detailed agro-food policy implications for each of the four types of co-op innovation. The results of the research may be learned by co-ops and policy makers in other developing economies who face similar challenges as in China.
Transaction Costs,Farmers' Cognition and Contractual Choice:A Survey from Zhejiang,Jiangxi,Hainan and Guizhou in China

WEI LongBao,ZHANG Fei

2013-01-01

Abstract:This paper studies farmers' contractual choice of marketing channels,based on data of 507 farmers' household in four provinces in China.Farmers' cognition level of cooperatives and contractual market channel is low,and there are significant differences between farmers' actual contract choice and their willingness.Traditional retail market still plays a key role in rural area at present,but farmers' contract choice tends to be sales contracts and cooperatives.By using factor analysis and the multiple Logistic regression model,the paper analyzes farmers' cognition of transaction costs and its effects on their contractual choice.Farmers' cognition of market information and sales channels,capability of negotiation and education,and their party membership have significant effect on farmers' contractual choice.Policy implications are:government should continue to strengthen advocation of modern circulation system of agricultural products,to improve the construction of information services in rural areas,to strengthen their support and supervision on supermarkets and the agriculture leading enterprise which sign contracts with farmers,and to stabilize the profit mechanism between farmers and agricultural product circulation subjects.
Adoption Of Food Safety And Quality Standards By China'S Agricultural Cooperatives

Jiehong Zhou

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.foodcont.2010.06.021

IF: 6

2013-01-01

Food Control

Abstract:The Chinese government is encouraging the adoption of food safety and quality standards by agricultural cooperatives to ensure improved quality of the foods produced. Based on the survey data from 124 vegetable cooperatives in Zhejiang Province, this study is designed to analyze the factors that affect adoption of food safety and quality standards by agricultural cooperatives in China. Our qualitative analysis suggests that cooperative size, perception and attitude toward standards, reputation, expected cost and benefit and the destination market have a positive and statistically significant relationship with the decision of the cooperatives to adopt the standards. We were unable to confirm the positive and significant effects of other factors such as innovativeness, price premium, customer attraction, and availability of support. The policy implications of encouraging the adoption of food safety and quality standards by agricultural cooperatives are also discussed.
SERVICE REALIZATION AND DETERMINANTS IN AGRICULTURAL COOPERATIVES IN CHINA: EVIDENCE FROM ZHEJIANG, SICHUAN AND HEILONGJIANG PROVINCES

Yuling Gao,Zuhui Huang,Qiao Liang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1142/s0217590815501143

2018-01-01

Abstract:In the past decade, China has begun to develop the agricultural cooperatives. The service function is the most important reason for cooperatives' existence. This paper formulates an analytical framework regarding the realization of services in cooperatives from the perspective of agricultural industrialization. Firstly, the definition, measurement and determinants of service realization are analyzed theoretically. Then, the realization of services, as well as influencing the service realization are examined empirically regarding grain, vegetable, fruit, livestock and chicken in the Zhejiang, Sichuan and Heilongjiang provinces. The paper concludes that product characteristics, resources owned by members, entrepreneurship of managers and incentives to managers have significant and positive impacts on the service realization.
Organization And Strategy Of Farmer Specialized Cooperatives In China

Yamei Hu,Zuhui Huang,George Hendrikse,Xuchu Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-7908-1758-4_20

2007-01-01

Abstract:How are the new farmer specialized cooperatives in China organized? This question is addressed by presenting data at three levels. First, data are presented regarding the historical development of farmer cooperatives in China. Second, data are presented regarding the membership composition of a sample of 66 farmer cooperatives in the Zhejiang province. Third, data are presented regarding the various attributes (governance, quality control system, and strategy) of a watermelon cooperative in this province. Many cooperatives are being transformed in organizations with a market orientation. The data indicate that cooperatives exhibit substantial heterogeneity, in terms of farmers being member and skewness in the distribution of control rights. Human asset specificity in terms of establishing and maintaining relations and access to markets seems to be more important than physical asset specificity in accounting for governance structure choice in the current institutional setting.
"Institutions in Transition - Challenges for New Modes of Governance"

Qiao Liang,George Hendrikse,Zuhui Huang

2010-01-01

Abstract:Traditional farmer cooperatives, new generation farmer cooperatives, and investor-owned firms (IOFs), are compared regarding their value added and value added rate in terms of product marketing. The results of the analysis regarding the pear supply chain in Zhejiang province in China indicate that IOFs obtain a higher value added or value added rate than farmer cooperatives. New generation cooperatives mitigate the under-investment problem of traditional cooperatives in a certain extent. However, farmer cooperatives have some advantages over investor-owned firms in benefiting farmers.
Supply chain re-engineering: a case study of the Tonghui Agricultural Cooperative in Inner Mongolia

Qianyu Zhu,Cheryl J. Wachenheim,Zhiyao Ma,Cong Zhu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22434/ifamr2016.0095

2018-01-09

International Food and Agribusiness Management Review

Abstract:Benefits of cooperative organization in agriculture come from price advantages in procurement and marketing, cost reductions and efficiency gains from sharing of productive assets and processes, and improved access to and increased efficiency in using credit, logistics, and information. Efficacy of strategic activities designed to capture these advantages is investigated empirically in a case study of the Tonghui Agricultural Cooperative in Inner Mongolia, an autonomous region of China. Information from interviews, on-site visits, evaluation of cooperative, member and partner information, and participation in the advising process are used to evaluate the impact of efforts to re-engineer the supply chain for independent farmers through cooperative organization. Specific examples of marketing channel development and operation for Wallace melons and mutton represent implementation of strategic plans. The case also reviews the cooperative’s credit system, designed increase access to and reduced cost of funds for members, use of alternative market venues, and horizontal expansion through tourism.

agricultural economics & policy
Multiple roles of agricultural cooperatives in improving farm technical efficiency: A case study of rural Gansu, China

Xinyi Li,Junichi Ito

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/agr.21901

2024-01-13

Agribusiness

Abstract:The establishment of agricultural cooperatives is widely viewed as an institutional arrangement to remove constraints that prevent smallholders from accessing profitable business opportunities in agriculture. Agricultural cooperatives in China offer a wide range of services within the framework of contract farming and vertical integration. This study empirically examines the multiple roles of China's cooperatives in improving farm production efficiency and conserving the agricultural environment. Considering that agricultural cooperatives' services can be broadly divided into biological and machinery services, we specify a stochastic frontier production function in a special form, called the separated Cobb–Douglas. The empirical results present clear evidence that Chinese agricultural cooperatives play essential roles in increasing biochemical technical efficiency and protecting the agroecological environment. However, the involvement of cooperatives as vertical integrators is demonstrated to have a detrimental effect on biochemical technical efficiency. The pressing challenge for agricultural cooperative development in China is to accommodate the conflicting consequences that their entry into farming has on biochemical and machinery technical efficiencies. This has strong policy implications, although our study has certain limitations in terms of the narrow focus on a single specific region. [EconLit Citations: C26, Q12, Q13, Q15, Q18].

economics,agricultural economics & policy,food science & technology
The efficiency of agricultural marketing cooperatives in China's Zhejiang province

Zuhui Huang,Yuzhi Fu,Qiao Liang,Yu Song,Xuchu Xu

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/mde.2589

2013-01-01

Managerial and Decision Economics

Abstract:On the basis of the bootstrap-Data Envelopment Analysis (DEA), this paper estimates technical, scale, and pure technical efficiencies for the agricultural marketing cooperatives in China's Zhejiang Province and employs a single truncated bootstrap procedure to identify the key determinants of efficiencies. The empirical results suggest that pure technical inefficiency was the main source of the technical inefficiency. Factors having significantly positive impacts on efficiency of cooperatives are local economic development level, entrepreneurship of managers, and human capital of members. The size of financial leverage and the number of board members have a negative impact on pure technical efficiency. © 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
Collective Action of Small Farmers: A Case Study of Ruoheng Farmer Watermelon Cooperative in China

Zuhui Huang,Qiao Liang,George Hendrikse

DOI: https://doi.org/10.22004/ag.econ.52840

2009-01-01

Abstract:Watermelon production investments, incomes and the access to markets between members of a cooperative and individual small farmers are compared. The results of the case study regarding members of a watermelon cooperative and five individual small farmers in Zhejiang province in China indicate that members of the cooperative are prone to produce food of higher quality, have obvious advantage in accessing modern food supply chains over individual small farmers, and subsequently gain a significantly higher return or income than individual small farmers.
Farmer Cooperatives and the Limits of Agricultural Reform in Rural Hubei

Brooke Wilmsen,Sarah Rogers,Yuefang Duan,Ju-Han Zoe Wang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1086/722258

2022-11-20

Abstract:There has been remarkable growth in the number of cooperatives in China in the past decade. This article asks: what role are cooperatives playing in driving China's ambitious agricultural reforms? The scholarly literature describes farmer cooperatives as either an important entity for progressing China's rural modernization agenda, a vehicle of exploitation and dispossession of smallholder farmers, or evidence of broader commitment to grassroots solidarity. Despite the rapid expansion of farmer cooperatives, the role that they play in the livelihoods of smallholder farmers in places where agriculture remains central and out-migration is low is poorly understood. To explore this, in 2019 we conducted a survey of 266 households in the mountains of Hubei Province. To illuminate the politics and dynamics on the ground, we followed up by conducting in-depth interviews with agribusinesses, cooperatives, households, and local government officials. Our findings suggest that although cooperatives are attempting to engage with smallholders, they are neither integrating nor exploiting them. While seemingly innocuous to the livelihoods of smallholder farmers, these entities serve a mostly political function, and it is in these dynamics that we observe the limits of agricultural reform. Where smallholder production is lucrative, land is valuable, and out-migration is minimal, local government appears to be "performing" reform, without forcing it on smallholders and thereby harming the local economy or risking social unrest.

area studies

The role of agricultural cooperatives in serving as a marketing channel: evidence from low-income regions of Sichuan province in China

Farmer cooperatives in China: frontiers in development and research

Cooperation Performance and its Surplus Allocation along Agri-food Supply Chain during "Farmer-Supermarket Direct Purchase"——Evidence from the Mode of "Farmer+Cooperative+Supermarket"

Cooperatives As Competitive Yardstick in the Hog Industry?—evidence from China

The Role of Farmer Cooperatives in Promoting Environmentally Sustainable Agricultural Development in China: A Review

Do Chinese Farmers Need Their Cooperatives:An Empirical Analysis of Farmers' Attitude to These Organizations in Coastal China

Characterizing Cooperatives In China

A Hybrid Form of Agricultural Organization: the Case of the Beizhijiang Vegetable Cooperative in China

Adoption of Food Safety and Quality Standards by China’s Agricultural Cooperatives: A Way out of Monitoring Production Practices of Numerous Small-scale Farmers ?

Understanding Farmer Cooperatives' Self-Inspection Behavior to Guarantee Agri-Product Safety in China

Technological Innovation in Agricultural Co-Operatives in China: Implications for Agro-Food Innovation Policies

Transaction Costs,Farmers' Cognition and Contractual Choice:A Survey from Zhejiang,Jiangxi,Hainan and Guizhou in China

Adoption Of Food Safety And Quality Standards By China'S Agricultural Cooperatives

SERVICE REALIZATION AND DETERMINANTS IN AGRICULTURAL COOPERATIVES IN CHINA: EVIDENCE FROM ZHEJIANG, SICHUAN AND HEILONGJIANG PROVINCES

Organization And Strategy Of Farmer Specialized Cooperatives In China

"Institutions in Transition - Challenges for New Modes of Governance"

Supply chain re-engineering: a case study of the Tonghui Agricultural Cooperative in Inner Mongolia

Multiple roles of agricultural cooperatives in improving farm technical efficiency: A case study of rural Gansu, China

The efficiency of agricultural marketing cooperatives in China's Zhejiang province

Collective Action of Small Farmers: A Case Study of Ruoheng Farmer Watermelon Cooperative in China

Farmer Cooperatives and the Limits of Agricultural Reform in Rural Hubei