When Health Disparities Hit Home: Redlining Practices, Air Pollution, and Asthma

Sonali Bose,Jaime Madrigano,Nadia N. Hansel

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1164/rccm.202206-1063ED

IF: 24.7

2022-10-01

American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine

Abstract:Asthma disproportionately burdens minority and low-income populations, and factors such as poor housing quality, the indoor environment, and ambient pollutants have consistently been linked to worse asthma outcomes (1). Recently, there has been increasing awareness of the role of institutional racial bias in creating and perpetuating respiratory health disparities (2). In this issue of the Journal , Schuyler and Wenzel (pp. 824–837) have focused their lens on the impact of one undeniable incarnation of structural racism: historical redlining (3). Redlining was a real estate practice of ranking non-White neighborhoods as credit unworthy and was designated as part of the federal housing policy from the 1930s to 1960s through the Home Owner's Loan Corporation (HOLC) and Federal Housing Authority. The consequences of redlining are complex and multifaceted. Redlining has not only limited the ability of people of color to build wealth through home ownership but has also been linked to overall substandard, poor-quality urban housing. Redlining designations have also contributed to other environmental disparities and specifically have been demonstrated to be associated with a variety of established environmental risk factors for asthma, including greenspace, tree canopy, and urban-heat exposure (4–7), as well as intraurban pollutant gradients for nitrogen dioxide (NO 2 ) and particulate matter (8). Thus, understanding the impact of redlining on asthma morbidity deserves particular consideration; however, to date, limited studies have investigated these relationships. A single ecological study conducted by Nardone and colleagues (9) explored HOLC risk grades based on location of population-weighted centroids on security maps and asthma exacerbation data obtained using census tract–level rates of emergency department visits across eight California cities. Historically redlined census tracts (i.e., risk grade D) were found to have a 39% higher rate of emergency department visits due to asthma than that of the lowest-risk census tracts in adjusted models, suggesting that this discriminatory practice might have contributed to current racial and ethnic asthma health disparities.

respiratory system,critical care medicine