Experimental Study on Patient Preferences Regarding the Shape and Size of Medical Tablets and Capsules Using Three-Dimensionally Printed Plastic Model Formulations

Kenji Kabeya,Hiroki Satoh,Satoko Hori,Yasufumi Sawada
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PPA.S306582
2021-04-29
Patient Preference and Adherence
Abstract:Kenji Kabeya, 1 Hiroki Satoh, 2, 3 Satoko Hori, 4 Yasufumi Sawada 2 1 Faculty of Pharmaceutical Sciences, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, 113-0033, Japan; 2 Laboratory of Drug Lifetime Management, Graduate School of Pharmaceutical Sciences, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, 113-0033, Japan; 3 Interfaculty Initiative in Information Studies, The University of Tokyo, Tokyo, 113-0033, Japan; 4 Laboratory of Drug Informatics, Keio University Faculty of Pharmacy, Tokyo, 105-8512, Japan Correspondence: Yasufumi Sawada Tel +81 3 5841 1096 Fax +81 3 5841 1097 Email Background: Tablets and capsules are the most common dosage forms. However, ease of use and/or swallowing influences patients' compliance. Objective: To identify patients' preferences regarding the three-dimensional size of medical tablets/capsules. Methods: Eighteen cylindrical-, oblong-, and oval-shaped model formulations having different sizes were prepared by three-dimensional printing using polylactic acid. Participants (40 patients visiting a pharmacy in Japan) evaluated the difficulty of picking up and swallowing these model formulations by touching/observing them, and completed a questionnaire. The visual analogue scale (VAS) was used to evaluate each sample, and the relationship of VAS scores to the major axis, thickness, I 2 (the sum of major/minor axes) and I 3 (the sum of major/minor axes and thickness) of the model formulations was evaluated by ANOVA followed by Tukey's test. Results: Female participants showed lower VAS scores (less difficult) for picking difficulty compared with male participants, and those taking many drugs showed higher VAS scores (more difficult) for swallowing difficulty compared with those taking fewer drugs. Otherwise, age, gender, disease status, number of drugs usually taken, and ingestion problems did not greatly influence the evaluation. Overall, larger model formulations showed less picking difficulty, but greater swallowing difficulty. Model formulations 2 mm thick or less were harder to pick up, whereas those 6 mm thick or more were harder to swallow. I 3 values greater than 20– 22 mm were associated with a negative evaluation by participants. Conclusion: Participants in this study preferred model formulations with an I 3 value below 22 mm and a thickness of 2– 6 mm. Keywords: tablet, capsule, size, shape, patient preference Medical tablets and capsules are the most common dosage forms in Japan because of their convenience. However, large tablets/capsules are more difficult to ingest, and may reduce patients' compliance. 1 , 2 Therefore, it is important to understand patients' preferences regarding the size and shape of medical tablets and capsules. Several studies have investigated this issue, 3–13 but have had various limitations: (i) most only investigated the diameter of round tablets and did not consider the three-dimensional shape of tablets, and (ii) most only compared patient preferences for different tablet/capsule sizes, and did not focus on the preferred size range or threshold size for acceptability, although this information would be useful for drug formulation design and development. We previously analyzed patients' preferences regarding the shapes and sizes of medical tablets and capsules using data collected from medical professionals such as doctors and pharmacists by marketing specialists (MSs) of a medical wholesaler. Our results indicated that the parameter "major axis + minor axis + thickness" is effective to evaluate patients' preference regarding size. In that study, we found that drugs with a major axis + minor axis + thickness of 21 mm or above were considered too large by patients. 14 However, that study was a retrospective study of previously collected post-marketing information, and we considered that the results should be validated in a prospective study. For this purpose, we designed a clinical study of patients visiting a pharmacy. Thus, the aims of this study were (i) to validate our previous findings by experimentally establishing participants' preferences regarding the three-dimensional size of medical tablets/capsules, and (ii) to prospectively test the hypothesis that there is a threshold value of "major axis + minor axis + thickness" that would be associated with negative evaluation of medical tablets/capsules by participants. For this experimental study, we prepared a series of 18 cylindrical-, oblong-, and oval-shaped pol -Abstract Truncated-
medicine, general & internal
What problem does this paper attempt to address?