Abstract:The propensity of a surface to nucleate ice or bind to ice is governed by its ice-philicity — its relative preference for ice over liquid water. However, the relationship between the features of a surface and its ice-philicity is not well understood, and for surfaces with chemical or topographical heterogeneity, such as proteins, their ice-philicity is not even well-defined. In the analogous problem of surface hydrophobicity, it has been shown that hydrophobic surfaces display enhanced low water-density (vapor-like) fluctuations in their vicinity. To interrogate whether enhanced ice-like fluctuations are similarly observed near ice-philic surfaces, here we use molecular simulations and enhanced sampling techniques. Using a family of model surfaces for which the wetting coefficient, k, has previously been characterized, we show that the free energy of observing rare interfacial ice-density fluctuations decreases monotonically with increasing k. By utilizing this connection, we investigate a set of fcc systems and find that the (110) surface is more ice-philic than the (111) or (100) surfaces. By additionally analyzing the structure of interfacial ice, we find that all surfaces prefer to bind to the basal plane of ice, and the topographical complementarity of the (110) surface to the basal plane explains its higher ice-philicity. Using enhanced interfacial ice-like fluctuations as a measure of surface ice-philicity, we then characterize the ice-philicity of chemically heterogeneous and topologically complex systems. In particular, we study the spruce budworm anti-freeze protein (sbwAFP), which binds to ice using a known ice-binding site (IBS) and resists engulfment using non-binding sites of the protein (NBSs). We find that the IBS displays enhanced interfacial ice-density fluctuations and is therefore more ice-philic than the two NBSs studied. We also find the two NBSs are similarly ice-phobic. By establishing a connection between interfacial ice-like fluctuations and surface ice-philicity, our findings thus provide a way to characterize the ice-philicity of heterogeneous surfaces.

Can solid surface energy be a predictor of ice nucleation ability?

Ice repellency investigation and proposed free energy approach for nucleation inhibition

The Many Faces of Heterogeneous Ice Nucleation: Interplay Between Surface Morphology and Hydrophobicity

Supercooled Water Droplet Impact on Superhydrophobic Surfaces with Various Roughness and Temperature

Impact of Surface Nanostructure on Ice Nucleation.

Molecular Insights into Surface Wettability for Heterogeneous Ice Nucleation of Seawater on Solid Surfaces

Interfacial Ice Density Fluctuations Inform Surface Ice-philicity

Identification of a common ice nucleus on hydrophilic and hydrophobic close-packed metal surfaces.

Icephobicity of Functionalized Graphene Surfaces

Intrinsic dependence of ice adhesion strength on surface roughness

The variation of surface propensity of halides with droplet size and temperature; The planar interface limit

Icephobic/anti-icing properties of superhydrophobic surfaces

Ice nucleation on silicone rubber surfaces differing in roughness parameters and wettability: Experimental investigation and machine learning–based predictions

Icing and Adhesion Behaviors on Surfaces with Varied Lattice Constants

Icing of Water on Polyethylene Surfaces

Nucleation enhancement by energy dissipation with the collision of a supercooled water droplet

Distinct Ice Patterns On Solid Surfaces With Various Wettabilities

Nanoscale Correlations of Ice Adhesion Strength and Water Contact Angle

Role of proton ordering in adsorption preference of polar molecule on ice surface

In situ investigation of ice formation on surfaces with representative wettability

Alkali metal ion-mediated ice nucleation