Abstract:After many years of research across disciplines, it remains unclear whether people are more motivated to seek appraisals that accurately match self-views (self-verification) or are as favorable as possible (self-enhancement). Within sociology, mixed findings in identity theory have fueled the debate. A problem here is that a commonly employed statistical approach does not take into account the direction of a discrepancy between how we see ourselves and how we think others see us in terms of a given identity, yet doing so is critical for determining which self-motive is at play. We offer a test of three competing models of identity processes, including a new "mixed motivations" model where self-verification and self-enhancement operate simultaneously. We compare the models using the conventional statistical approach versus response surface analysis. The latter method allows us to determine whether identity discrepancies involving over-evaluation are as distressing as those involving under-evaluation. We use nationally representative data and compare results across four different identities and multiple outcomes. The two statistical approaches lead to the same conclusions more often than not and mostly support identity theory and its assumption that people seek self-verification. However, response surface tests reveal patterns that are mistaken as evidence of self-verification by conventional procedures, especially for the spouse identity. We also find that identity discrepancies have different effects on distress and self-conscious emotions (guilt and shame). Our findings have implications not only for research on self and identity across disciplines, but also for many other areas of research that incorporate these concepts and/or use difference scores as explanatory variables.

The Homeostatic Ego: Self-Enhancement as a Biological Adaptation

A longitudinal-experimental test of the panculturality of self-enhancement: Self-enhancement promotes psychological well-being both in the west and the east

Praise from a self-enhancement perspective: More, I want more?

The Causes and Consequences of a Need for Self-Esteem: A Terror Management Theory

Motivational and emotional aspects of the self

Positive Illusions in the Academic Context

Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being.

An Evolutionary Perspective on Appearance Enhancement Behavior

Do People Embrace Praise Even When They Feel Unworthy? A Review of Critical Tests of Self-Enhancement Versus Self-Verification

Cross-Cultural Insights from Two Global Mental Health Studies: Self-Enhancement and Ingroup Biases

Further Examining the American Dream: Differential Correlates of Intrinsic and Extrinsic Goals

To thine own self be true? Clarifying the effects of identity discrepancies on psychological distress and emotions

Everyday temptations: An experience sampling study of desire, conflict, and self-control.

A four-culture study of self-enhancement and adjustment using the social relations model: Do alternative conceptualizations and indices make a difference?

Human Enhancement: Enhancing Health or Harnessing Happiness?

Cognitive Enhancement: Unanswered Questions About Human Psychology and Social Behavior

Validating the "Two Faces" of Envy: The Effect of Self-Control

The "What" and "Why" of Goal Pursuits: Human Needs and the Self-Determination of Behavior

Self-transcendence through the lens of ontological addiction: correlates of prosociality, competitiveness and pro-nature behavior

Perfectionism, Self-Image Goals and Compassionate Goals in Health and Mental Health: A Longitudinal Analysis

Motivated response styles: The role of cultural values, regulatory focus, and self-consciousness in socially desirable responding.