Abstract:We compare the performance of predicting the effect of climate on demographic rates using three very complex ("antecedent models"), and two simple (linear regression and "null" models without climate predictors) statistical models. None of the models including climate consistently improves predictive ability. However, in the few, selected cases where antecedent effect models improve predictive ability, they can be a formidable exploratory data analysis tool. Understanding mechanisms and predicting natural population responses to climate is a key goal of Ecology. However, studies explicitly linking climate to population dynamics remain limited. Antecedent effect models are a set of statistical tools that capitalize on the evidence provided by climate and population data to select time windows correlated with a response (e.g., survival, reproduction). Thus, these models can serve as both a predictive and exploratory tool. We compare the predictive performance of antecedent effect models against simpler models and showcase their exploratory analysis potential by selecting a case study with high predictive power. We fit three antecedent effect models: (1) weighted mean models (WMM), which weigh the importance of monthly anomalies based on a Gaussian curve, (2) stochastic antecedent models (SAM), which weigh the importance of monthly anomalies using a Dirichlet process, and (3) regularized regressions using the Finnish horseshoe model (FHM), which estimate a separate effect size for each monthly anomaly. We compare these approaches to a linear model using a yearly climatic predictor and a null model with no predictors. We use demographic data from 77 natural populations of 34 plant species ranging between seven and 36 years in length. We then fit models to the asymptotic population growth rate (λ) and its underlying vital rates: survival, development, and reproduction. We find that models including climate do not consistently outperform null models. We hypothesize that the effect of yearly climate is too complex, weak, and confounded by other factors to be easily predicted using monthly precipitation and temperature data. On the other hand, in our case study, antecedent effect models show biologically sensible correlations between two precipitation anomalies and multiple vital rates. We conclude that, in temporal datasets with limited sample sizes, antecedent effect models are better suited as exploratory tools for hypothesis generation.

Disappointing Survival Forecast for a Local Population of Androsace albana in a Random Environment

Local population of Eritrichium caucasicum as an object of mathematical modelling. I. Life cycle graph and a nonautonomous matrix model

Extinction probabilities of small structured populations: adequate short-term model predictions in Folsomia candida

Population responses to environmental stochasticity are primarily driven by survival-reproduction trade-offs and mediated by aridity

Understanding the effects of weather parameters on the population dynamics of an endangered geophyte supports monitoring efficiency

Balancing: A solution to our distorted indices of transient dynamics

A modeling approach to forecast local demographic trends in metapopulations

The accuracy of predicting maladaptation to new environments with genomic data

Differences in Adult Survival Drive Divergent Demographic Responses to a Decade of Field Warming on the Tibetan Plateau

Trade-off dynamics in a rare cactus: What are the demographic consequences of temporal variation in fitness?

Uncertainty in predicting range dynamics of endemic alpine plants under climate warming

Underprediction of extirpation and colonisation following climate and land‐use change using species distribution models

Antecedent Effect Models as an Exploratory Tool to Link Climate Drivers to Herbaceous Perennial Population Dynamics Data

The limits of predicting maladaptation to future environments with genomic data

Generalized Single Index Models and Jensen Effects on Reproduction and Survival

Conditions for growth and extinction in matrix models with environmental stochasticity

Effects of growth rate, size, and light availability on tree survival across life stages: a demographic analysis accounting for missing values and small sample sizes

Discrete-Time Model of an Exploited Population with Age and Sex Structures: Instability and the Hydra Effect

Survival Forests under Test: Impact of the Proportional Hazards Assumption on Prognostic and Predictive Forests for ALS Survival

Extending Grime's CSR model to predict plant demographic responses across resource availability gradients: evidence from the patagonian steppes

METHODS Skewed distributions of lifetime reproductive success: beyond mean and variance