The Concurrent and Longitudinal Relations Between Competitive Classroom Climate and Learning Motivation Among Chinese Adolescent Students: The Mediating Roles of Social Comparisons
Zien Ding,Ru-De Liu,Yi Ding,Xiantong Yang,Wei Hong,Huizi Li
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/prbm.s364803
IF: 3.974
2022-05-13
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Zien Ding, 1 Ru-De Liu, 1 Yi Ding, 2 Xiantong Yang, 1 Wei Hong, 1 Huizi Li 3 1 Beijing Key Laboratory of Applied Experimental Psychology, National Demonstration Center for Experimental Psychology Education (Beijing Normal University), Faculty of Psychology, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, 100875, People's Republic of China; 2 Graduate School of Education, Fordham University, New York, NY, 10023, USA; 3 Department of Curriculum and Instruction, Yinchuan Tanglai Hui Middle School, Ningxia, 750000, People's Republic of China Correspondence: Ru-De Liu, Beijing Key Laboratory of Applied Experimental Psychology, National Demonstration Center for Experimental Psychology Education (Beijing Normal University), Faculty of Psychology, Beijing Normal University, Beijing, 100875, People's Republic of China, Email Purpose: Over the past decade, cross-sectional studies have established a link between competitive classroom climate and learning motivation. However, the precise predictive direction has remained unclear, and the potential mechanisms underlying the link have yet to be investigated. According to the social comparison theory, competitive classroom climate is positively associated with learning motivation, and upward and downward comparison may play a role in mediating this process. Patients and Methods: Data were obtained from a three-wave study of 476 Chinese senior high school students (45.4% boys, 54.6% girls) aged 14– 18 years. Structural equation modeling was performed to test different models. Results: Concurrent and longitudinal analyses revealed that higher competitive classroom climate was associated with higher learning motivation. Moreover, upward comparison mediated the relation between competitive classroom climate and learning motivation. However, downward comparison did not mediate these relations. Conclusion: From the perspective of practice, the results provide evidence for how to promote learning motivation by cultivating competitive classroom climate and applying effective social comparison strategies. Keywords: competitive classroom climate, upward comparison, downward comparison, learning motivation The relation between classroom climate and learning motivation has received much public attention in recent years. 1–3 Past research revealed that a cooperative classroom climate has positive effects on students' learning motivation. 4,5 However, as students move from junior to senior high school, the culture of the classroom often changes, with increased emphasis placed on competition at the senior high level. 6 Although there is empirical evidence that intergroup competition has a positive effect on motivation in the working environment, 7 the nature of the effect of competitive climate on learning motivation in the classroom remains unclear. Furthermore, few research studies have explored the underlying mechanisms behind this relation. According to the social comparison theory (SCT), social comparison is an important feature of the classroom environment 8,9 and plays a pivotal role in linking classroom climate and motivation. 10 It is plausible that social comparison mediates the association between competitive classroom climate and learning motivation. The present study aimed to examine the effect of competitive classroom climate on high school students' learning motivation and the mediating role of social comparison in the association between classroom climate and learning motivation by a three-wave longitudinal investigation. Competitive classroom climate refers to the degree to which students perceive the competitive nature of their classroom environment. 11 The classroom is the main environment not only for the implementation of a school's educational functions but also for adolescents' knowledge acquisition, moral education, socialization, and self-education. 12,13 Climate substantially affects the quality of interactions among the students and the interactions between the students and the teachers. 14 It also reflects the norms, values, and goals that represent the broader educational missions of the classroom. 15 However, classroom structure is different between the East and the West. American students move from classroom to classroom based on the subject that they are learning, while in most East Asian public schools, teachers are the ones who move in and out of classrooms. Students stay put, in fixed seats with fixed classmates over multiple years. In China, when adolescent students take an exam, one of the direct consequences is the calculation of class rank. Previous research found that ranking caused chi -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary