Vaccine breakthrough hypoxemic COVID-19 pneumonia in patients with auto-Abs neutralizing type I IFNs

Paul Bastard,Sara Vazquez,Jamin Liu,Matthew T. Laurie,Chung Yu Wang,Adrian Gervais,Tom Le Voyer,Lucy Bizien,Colin Zamecnik,Quentin Philippot,Jérémie Rosain,Emilie Catherinot,Andrew Willmore,Anthea M. Mitchell,Rebecca Bair,Pierre Garçon,Heather Kenney,Arnaud Fekkar,Maria Salagianni,Garyphallia Poulakou,Eleni Siouti,Sabina Sahanic,Ivan Tancevski,Günter Weiss,Laurenz Nagl,Jérémy Manry,Sotirija Duvlis,Daniel Arroyo-Sánchez,Estela Paz Artal,Luis Rubio,Cristiano Perani,Michela Bezzi,Alessandra Sottini,Virginia Quaresima,Lucie Roussel,Donald C. Vinh,Luis Felipe Reyes,Margaux Garzaro,Nevin Hatipoglu,David Boutboul,Yacine Tandjaoui-Lambiotte,Alessandro Borghesi,Anna Aliberti,Irene Cassaniti,Fabienne Venet,Guillaume Monneret,Rabih Halwani,Narjes Saheb Sharif-Askari,Jeffrey Danielson,Sonia Burrel,Caroline Morbieu,Yurii Stepanovskyy,Anastasia Bondarenko,Alla Volokha,Oksana Boyarchuk,Alenka Gagro,Mathilde Neuville,Bénédicte Neven,Sevgi Keles,Romain Hernu,Antonin Bal,Antonio Novelli,Giuseppe Novelli,Kahina Saker,Oana Ailioaie,Arnau Antolí,Eric Jeziorski,Gemma Rocamora-Blanch,Carla Teixeira,Clarisse Delaunay,Marine Lhuillier,Paul Le Turnier,Yu Zhang,Matthieu Mahevas,Qiang Pan-Hammarström,Hassan Abolhassani,Thierry Bompoil,Karim Dorgham,Guy Gorochov,Cédric Laouenan,Carlos Rodríguez-Gallego,Lisa F. P. Ng,Laurent Renia,Aurora Pujol,Alexandre Belot,François Raffi,Luis M. Allende,Javier Martinez-Picado,Tayfun Ozcelik,Sevgi Keles,Luisa Imberti,Luigi D. Notarangelo,Jesus Troya,Xavier Solanich,Shen-Ying Zhang,Anne Puel,Michael R Wilson,Sophie Trouillet-Assant,Laurent Abel,Emmanuelle Jouanguy,Chun Jimmie Ye,Aurélie Cobat,Leslie M. Thompson,Evangelos Andreakos,Qian Zhang,Mark S. Anderson,Jean-Laurent Casanova,Joseph L. DeRisi,Laurent Abel,Cristian Achille,Alessandro Aiuti,Saleh Al-Muhsen,Fahd Al-Mulla,Mark S. Anderson,Evangelos Andreakos,Micol Angelini,Andrés A. Arias,Gokhan Aytekin,Fausto Baldanti,Hagit Baris Feldman,Alexandre Belot,Federica Bergami,Catherine M. Biggs,Dusan Bogunovic,Alexandre Bolze,Anastasiia Bondarenko,Ahmed A. Bousfiha,Petter Brodin,Yenan Bryceson,Carlos D. Bustamante,Manish J. Butte,Giorgio Casari,John Christodoulou,Antonio Condino-Neto,Stefan N. Constantinescu,Francesca Conti,Megan A. Cooper,Clifton L. Dalgard,Murkesh Desai,Beth A. Drolet,Jamila El Baghdadi,Recai Ergun,Dilek Ergun,Sara Espinosa-Padilla,Jacques Fellay,Carlos Flores,José Luis Franco,Antoine Froidure,Stefano Ghirardello,Peter K. Gregersen,Bodo Grimbacher,Filomeen Haerynck,David Hagin,Rabih Halwani,Lennart Hammarström,James R. Heath,Sarah E. Henrickson,Elena W.Y. Hsieh,Eystein Husebye,Kohsuke Imai,Yuval Itan,Erich D. Jarvis,Fikret Kanat,Timokratis Karamitros,Kai Kisand,Vasyl Kopcha,Mykhaylo Korda,Cheng-Lung Ku,Yu-Lung Lau,Yun Ling,Carrie L. Lucas,Tom Maniatis,Davood Mansouri,László Maródi,Isabelle Meyts,Joshua D. Milner,Kristina Mironska,Trine H. Mogensen,Francesco Mojoli,Francisco Morandeira,Tomohiro Morio,Lisa F.P. Ng,Luigi D. Notarangelo,Antonio Novelli,Giuseppe Novelli,Cliona O'Farrelly,Satoshi Okada,Keisuke Okamoto,Tayfun Ozcelik,Michele Pagani,Qiang Pan-Hammarström,Jean W. Pape,Rebeca Perez de Diego,David S. Perlin,Graziano Pesole,Andrea Pession,Antonio Piralla,Anna M. Planas,Carolina Prando,Aurora Pujol,Lluis Quintana-Murci,Sathishkumar Ramaswamy,Laurent Renia,Igor Resnick,Raúl Rigo-Bonnin,Carlos Rodríguez-Gallego,Vanessa Sancho-Shimizu,Anna Sediva,Mikko R.J. Seppänen,Mohammed Shahrooei,Anna Shcherbina,Ondrej Slaby,Andrew L. Snow,Pere Soler-Palacín,András N. Spaan,Ivan Tancevski,Stuart G. Tangye,Ahmad Abou Tayoun,Baykal Tulek,Stuart E. Turvey,K M Furkan Uddin,Mohammed Uddin,Bénédicte Clément,Yumiko Abe-Jones,Saurabh Asthana,Sharvari Bhide,Carolyn S. Calfee,Sidney A. Carrillo,Suzanna Chak,Zachary Collins,David J. Erle,Gabriela K. Fragiadakis,Rajani Ghale,Carolyn M. Hendrickson,Alejandra Jauregui,Kirsten N. Kangelaris,Matthew F. Krummel,Charles R. Langelier,Tasha Lea,Deanna Lee,Aleksandra Leligdowicz,Carolyn Leroux,Raphael Lota,Michael Matthay,Viet Nguyen,Ravi Patel,Logan Pierce,Priya Prasad,Arjun Arkal Rao,Ahmad Rashid,Nicklaus Rodriguez,Bushra Samad,Cole Shaw,Austin Sigman,Kevin Tang,Luz Torres Altamirano,Alyssa Ward,Andrew Willmore,Michael Wilson,Prescott G. Woodruff,Laurent Abel,Clotilde Allavena,Claire Andrejak,François Angoulvant,Cecile Azoulay,Delphine Bachelet,Marie Bartoli,Romain Basmaci,Sylvie Behilill,Marine Beluze,Nicolas Benech,Dehbia Benkerrou,Krishna Bhavsar,Laurent Bitker,Lila Bouadma,Maude Bouscambert,Pauline Caraux Paz,Minerva Cervantes-Gonzalez,Anissa Chair,Catherine Chirouze,Alexandra Coelho,Hugues Cordel,Camille Couffignal,Sandrine Couffin-Cadiergues,Eric d'Ortenzio,Etienne De Montmollin,Alexa Debard,Marie-Pierre Debray,Dominique Deplanque,Diane Descamps,Mathilde Desvallée,Alpha Diallo,Jean-Luc Diehl,Alphonsine Diouf,Céline Dorival,François Dubos,Xavier Duval,Philippine Eloy,Vincent Enouf,Olivier Epaulard,Hélène Esperou,Marina Esposito-Farese,Manuel Etienne,Denis Garot,Nathalie Gault,Alexandre Gaymard,Jade Ghosn,Tristan Gigante,Morgane Gilg,François Goehringer,Jérémie Guedj,Alexandre Hoctin,Isabelle Hoffmann,Ikram Houas,Jean-Sébastien Hulot,Salma Jaafoura,Ouifiya Kafif,Florentia Kaguelidou,Sabrina Kali,Younes Kerroumi,Antoine Khalil,Coralie Khan,Antoine Kimmoun,Fabrice Laine,Cédric Laouénan,Samira Laribi,Minh Le,Cyril Le Bris,Sylvie Le Gac,Quentin Le Hingrat,Soizic Le Mestre,Hervé Le Nagard,Adrien Lemaignen,Véronique Lemee,François-Xavier Lescure,Sophie Letrou,Yves Levy,Bruno Lina,Guillaume Lingas,Jean Christophe Lucet,Moïse Machado,Denis Malvy,Marina Mambert,Aldric Manuel,France Mentré,Amina Meziane,Hugo Mouquet,Jimmy Mullaert,Nadège Neant,Duc Nguyen,Marion Noret,Aurélie Papadopoulos,Christelle Paul,Nathan Peiffer-Smadja,Vincent Peigne,Ventzislava Petrov-Sanchez,Gilles Peytavin,Huong Pham,Olivier Picone,Valentine Piquard,Julien Poissy,Oriane Puéchal,Manuel Rosa-Calatrava,Bénédicte Rossignol,Patrick Rossignol,Carine Roy,Marion Schneider,Richa Su,Coralie Tardivon,Marie-Capucine Tellier,François Téoulé,Olivier Terrier,Jean-François Timsit,Christelle Tual,Sarah Tubiana,Sylvie Van Der Werf,Noémie Vanel,Aurélie Veislinger,Benoit Visseaux,Aurélie Wiedemann,Yazdan Yazdanpanah,COVID HGE consortium,French COVID study group,COMET consortium

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1126/sciimmunol.abp8966

IF: 30.63

2022-06-15

Science Immunology

Abstract:Life-threatening 'breakthrough' cases of critical COVID-19 are attributed to poor or waning antibody response to the SARS-CoV-2 vaccine in individuals already at risk. Pre-existing autoantibodies (auto-Abs) neutralizing type I IFNs underlie at least 15% of critical COVID-19 pneumonia cases in unvaccinated individuals; however, their contribution to hypoxemic breakthrough cases in vaccinated people remains unknown. Here, we studied a cohort of 48 individuals (age 20-86 years) who received 2 doses of an mRNA vaccine and developed a breakthrough infection with hypoxemic COVID-19 pneumonia 2 weeks to 4 months later. Antibody levels to the vaccine, neutralization of the virus, and auto-Abs to type I IFNs were measured in the plasma. Forty-two individuals had no known deficiency of B cell immunity and a normal antibody response to the vaccine. Among them, ten (24%) had auto-Abs neutralizing type I IFNs (aged 43-86 years). Eight of these ten patients had auto-Abs neutralizing both IFN-α2 and IFN-ω, while two neutralized IFN-ω only. No patient neutralized IFN-β. Seven neutralized 10 ng/mL of type I IFNs, and three 100 pg/mL only. Seven patients neutralized SARS-CoV-2 D614G and the Delta variant (B.1.617.2) efficiently, while one patient neutralized Delta slightly less efficiently. Two of the three patients neutralizing only 100 pg/mL of type I IFNs neutralized both D61G and Delta less efficiently. Despite two mRNA vaccine inoculations and the presence of circulating antibodies capable of neutralizing SARS-CoV-2, auto-Abs neutralizing type I IFNs may underlie a significant proportion of hypoxemic COVID-19 pneumonia cases, highlighting the importance of this particularly vulnerable population.

immunology