Abstract:Cities play a central role in the circular economy (CE) as they are important centres of production and consumption, responsible for 80% of global GDP. European cities are particularly important due to their position of power in the global economy as major markets, and places of industrial and social innovation. Yet urban CE policies and discourses remain poorly researched and understood. This paper addresses this research gap by analysing and comparing the CE policies and discourses in different European cities to draw critical insights and recommendations. It does so by first reviewing academic literature on urban CE policies to develop a new conceptual framework to analyse CE discourses and policies. This framework is then used to analyse and compare the CE policies of three European cities: Glasgow, Amsterdam, and Copenhagen. Results show that technocentric approaches to CE are dominant in the three cities. Moreover, they have very limited social justice policies for a fair distribution of the costs and benefits of a CE transition. Key policy recommendations to address these shortcomings are thus proposed. The insights brought about by this paper are valuable for both practitioners and academics seeking to improve urban CE policies. Key policy highlights CE strategies in Amsterdam, Glasgow and Copenhagen focus on economic competitiveness and technological innovation and thus fail to address the full social, political, and ecological implications of a CE transition. To improve social justice outcomes, circular cities should encourage policies that redistribute unused building stock (e.g. through speculation and vacancy taxes) and promote non-profit cooperatives (e.g. through public procurement practices). To improve ecological outcomes, circular cities should establish policies that create compact multi-functional neighbourhoods and reduce the need for motorised transport, as well as policies that conserve and restore biodiversity. To improve political legitimacy and equity, circular cities should democratise decision-making through various mechanisms, such as participatory budgeting processes and deliberative assemblies, that can determine the course of the circularity transition in an inclusive manner.

The socio-spatial effects of Circular Urban Systems

Sustainable circular cities? Analysing urban circular economy policies in Amsterdam, Glasgow, and Copenhagen

Barriers and enablers of circular economy in construction: a multi-system perspective towards the development of a practical framework

Facilitating Circular Economy in Urban Planning

Applying Circular Economy Principles to Urban Housing

Circularity on what grounds? Advancing learning for circular area development at the interface of proximity and precarity

Urban infrastructures, metabolic resource flows and the contradictions of circular economy 'solutions' in Nantes and Gothenburg

Circular Maker Cities: Maker Space Typologies and Circular Urban Design

Realizing the potential for circularity in Glasgow through the socio-spatial dimension of urban systems

Amsterdam’s circular economy at a world-ecological crossroads: postcapitalist degrowth or the next regime of capital accumulation?

‘Let’s brew a new Brussels’: imaginaries of the circular economy

The (missing) social aspect of the circular economy: a review of social scientific articles

The role of place in the development of a circular economy: a critical analysis of potential for social redistribution in Hull, UK

Integrating Temporal Dimensions in Circularity of the Built Environment Analysis of Two Flemish Industrial Parks

The circular economy of waste: recovery, incineration and urban reuse

Conceptualizing Core Aspects on Circular Economy in Cities

Circular Building Design: An Analysis of Barriers and Drivers for a Circular Building Sector

Circular Economy Strategies in Eight Historic Port Cities: Criteria and Indicators Towards a Circular City Assessment Framework

When Circular Economy Meets the Smart City Ecosystem: Defining the Smart and Circular City

Towards circular renovation: a comparative review of circular economy integration in sustainable building rating systems

Innovations in circular economy for sustainable urban development