Abstract:Purpose This paper fits in a research field dealing with the impact of Corporate Ethics Assessment on Financial Performance. The authors argue how environmental, social and governance (ESG) paradigm, meant to measure corporate social performance by rating issuance, can impact on abnormal returns of Italian firms listed on Financial Times Stock Exchange Milano Indice di Borsa (FTSE MIB) Index, developing a panel data analysis which runs from 2007 to 2015. Design/methodology/approach This study aims at exploring whether socially responsible investors outperform an excess market return on Italian Stock Exchange because of their investment behavior, testing statistically the relationship between the yearly ESG assessment issued by Standard Ethics Agency on FTSE MIB’s companies and their abnormal returns. To verify the impact of an ESG Rating on a company’s abnormal return, the authors developed a panel data analysis through a Fixed Effects Model. They measured abnormal returns via Fama–French approach, running a yearly Jensen’s Performance Index for each company under investigation. Findings The empirical results denote in Italy both a growing interest to corporate social responsibility (CSR) and sustainability by managers over the past decade, as well as an improving quality in ESG assessments because of a reliable corporate disclosure. Thus, despite investors have been applying ESG criteria in their stock – picking operations, the authors found a not positive and statistically significant impact in terms of market premium, when they have been undertaking a socially responsible investment (SRI). Practical implications The findings described above show that ethics is not yet a reliable fundraising tool for Italian-listed companies, despite SRIs having a positive growth rate over past decade. Investors seem to be not pricing CSR on Stock Exchange Market; therefore, listed companies cannot be rewarded with a premium price because of their highly stakeholder oriented behavior. Originality/value This paper explores, for the first time in Italy, when market extra-returns (if any) are related to corporate social performance and how managers leverage ethics to build capital added value.

Is sustainability rating material to the market?

Sustainability Disclosure and IPO Performance: Exploring the Impact of ESG Reporting

Freshen up before going public: Do environmental, social, and governance factors affect firms' appearance during the initial public offering?

ESG Disclosure and Idiosyncratic Risk in Initial Public Offerings

ENVIRONMENTAL, SOCIAL, AND GOVERNANCE (ESG) PRACTICE AND FIRM PERFORMANCE: AN INTERNATIONAL EVIDENCE

Sustainable success: How high ESG ratings affect stock market responses to earnings surprises

Do ESG ratings improve capital market trading activities?

Does ESG matter to investors? ESG scores and the stock price response to new information

Comparing the informativeness of sustainability disclosures versus ESG disclosure ratings

Mandatory ESG Disclosure, Information Asymmetry, and Litigation Risk: Evidence from Initial Public Offerings

The impact of ESG scores on cost of equity and firm’s profitability

Corporate sustainability performance and informativeness of earnings

Embedding sustainability in risk management: The impact of environmental, social, and governance ratings on corporate financial risk

The Influence of Firm Size on the ESG Score: Corporate Sustainability Ratings Under Review

Does a Change in the ESG Ratings Influence Firms’ Market Value? Evidence from an Event Study

The impact of environmental disclosure on initial public offering underpricing: Sustainable development in Singapore

Corporate ESG rating and stock market liquidity: Evidence from China

The IPO corporate social responsibility information disclosure: Does the stock market care?

Towards a more ethical market: the impact of ESG rating on corporate financial performance