Abstract:The building project development approval process is increasingly complex and fraught with conflict due to the rise of the sustainable urban development movement and inclusive decision making. Coupled with this, government decision-making decentralization has resulted in a fragmented and over-regulated compliance system. Problems arising from the process include wasted resources, excessive time delays, increased holding and litigation costs, inadequate planning coordination, high levels of advocacy costs and a divisive politicized approval process. In Australia, despite attempts by government and industry associations, numerous problems are still unresolved. Design managers increasingly assume a liaison role during the approval phase. There is a long tradition of planning theory literature which provides context for understanding the knowledge—power—participation relationship for this paper. This study investigated the policy, process and practice conflicts during the approval stage in achieving sustainable urban developments. Three regional local government areas within one state jurisdiction and observations from detailed structured focus group interviews involving 23 stakeholders, proposers and assessors were analysed to explore this conflictual environment. As a result of regulatory fragmentation and excessive consultation, various persuasion tactics have been developed by all stakeholders of which ‘reciprocity’ and ‘authority’ were identified as the most common. Two challenges for design managers were thus identified: first, the emergence of the role of a by default central informal arbitrator across conflicting planning instruments; and, second, as a navigator through a set of persuasion tactics. An inclusive knowledge-based design management framework for sustainable urban development is proposed considering Habermas' communicative planning theory, Foucaltian governance and discursive powers thesis and Cialdini's persuasion theory, as well as being grounded in the key empirical results from this study, using various types and sources of knowledge as an authoritative persuasion tactic.

Governing through design: the politics of participation in neoliberal cities

Impact of a Fragmented Regulatory Environment on Sustainable Urban Development Design Management

Participatory micro-regeneration: governing urban redevelopment in Qinghe, Beijing

Governance and Governmentality in Community Participation: The Shifting Sands of Power, Responsibility and Risk

Unearthing the political: differences, conflicts and power in participatory urban design

Using a design approach to create collaborative governance

Participatory design for democratic innovation: participation requests and community empowerment in Scotland

Defining the limits of community governance

New Municipalism and the Challenges of Design: Context, Instruments and Implementation

Government-led and Internet-empowered Citizen Participation in China's Policymaking: A Case Study of the Shanghai 2035 Master Plan.

The role of discourses in enacting neoliberal urbanism: Understanding the relationship between ideology and discourse in planning

Designing Web Technologies for Local Governance Reform: Good Management or Good Democracy?

Participatory Design in Emerging Civic Engagement Initiatives in the New Public Sector

Changing Urban Governance in New Zealand: Public Participation and Democratic Legitimacy in Local Authority Planning and Decision-Making 1989–2014

Participative Urban Renewal? Disability, Community, and Partnership in New Labour's Urban Policy

Integrated and Participatory Design of Sustainable Development Strategies on Multiple Governance Levels

Rethinking public participation in the smart city

Co-creating the future: participatory cities and digital governance

AI urbanism: a design framework for governance, program, and platform cognition

Actor Resistance Influences Effectiveness of Ostrom’s Design Principles for Governing Contested Landscapes

Public Values and Public Participation: A Case of Collaborative Governance of a Planning Process