Abstract:Dr. Coffman et al. examined the association between deployment-related traumatic brain injury (TBI) severity, frequency, and other injury characteristics with headache outcomes in 594 veterans evaluated at a Veterans Administration polytrauma support clinic. They found a dose-dependent relationship between TBI severity and headache outcomes, with a history of multiple mild TBIs and a longer duration of alteration of consciousness and post-traumatic amnesia being important risk factors for poor headache outcomes in the veterans. In addition to highlighting the poor headache outcomes associated with subconcussive exposure, the authors concluded that past TBI characteristics should be considered in the development of headache management guidelines for veterans. In response, Dr. Gupta argues that the TBI phenotypes do not offer insights into salient aspects of migraine pathophysiology and questions the biological plausibility of epidemiologic relationships reported in headache research. He suggests that vasopressin may play a role in advancing the pathophysiologic understanding of headache in TBI. Responding to these comments, the authors disagree and among other things point out that not all headaches reported by patients in their study had migraine-like features. They appropriately point out that specific aspects of migraine pathophysiology were beyond the scope of their study, although they acknowledge that cortical spreading depression is a hallmark of both migraine and acute TBI and may relate to injury severity and outcomes. Nevertheless, they advocate for a cautious approach when extrapolating migraine research to the TBI population, given the differences between migraine and post-traumatic headache patients seen on structural and functional neuroimaging studies. This exchange highlights important similarities and differences in the characteristics of migraine and TBI-related headaches that are worth bearing in mind for both clinical and research pursuits in this area. Dr. Coffman et al. examined the association between deployment-related traumatic brain injury (TBI) severity, frequency, and other injury characteristics with headache outcomes in 594 veterans evaluated at a Veterans Administration polytrauma support clinic. They found a dose-dependent relationship between TBI severity and headache outcomes, with a history of multiple mild TBIs and a longer duration of alteration of consciousness and post-traumatic amnesia being important risk factors for poor headache outcomes in the veterans. In addition to highlighting the poor headache outcomes associated with subconcussive exposure, the authors concluded that past TBI characteristics should be considered in the development of headache management guidelines for veterans. In response, Dr. Gupta argues that the TBI phenotypes do not offer insights into salient aspects of migraine pathophysiology and questions the biological plausibility of epidemiologic relationships reported in headache research. He suggests that vasopressin may play a role in advancing the pathophysiologic understanding of headache in TBI. Responding to these comments, the authors disagree and among other things point out that not all headaches reported by patients in their study had migraine-like features. They appropriately point out that specific aspects of migraine pathophysiology were beyond the scope of their study, although they acknowledge that cortical spreading depression is a hallmark of both migraine and acute TBI and may relate to injury severity and outcomes. Nevertheless, they advocate for a cautious approach when extrapolating migraine research to the TBI population, given the differences between migraine and post-traumatic headache patients seen on structural and functional neuroimaging studies. This exchange highlights important similarities and differences in the characteristics of migraine and TBI-related headaches that are worth bearing in mind for both clinical and research pursuits in this area.

Editors' Note: Relationship Between Headache Characteristics and a Remote History of TBI in Veterans: A 10-Year Retrospective Chart Review