Barriers and strengthening strategies on the Korea safety laws for the application of hydrogen and ammonia as power generation fuels based on the expert survey
Da Hee Kim,Hee Kyung Park,Min Chul Lee
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijhydene.2024.05.126
IF: 7.2
2024-05-20
International Journal of Hydrogen Energy
Abstract:Hydrogen and ammonia have emerged as prominent next-generation clean energy sources pivotal for realizing a decarbonized society. However, their adoption has been marred by incidents ranging from leaks to fires, and explosions, underscoring the imperative for heightened safety protocols when utilizing these novel fuels. In light of this, this study scrutinizes Korean laws and regulations to assess the institutional framework governing the safe utilization of hydrogen and ammonia in power plants. Through this examination, four key limitations are identified: hydrogen laws do not comprehensively cover the entire hydrogen business sector, regulations regarding the revised usage of hydrogen and ammonia are either weak or absent, safety assessments in certain laws exclude new fuels, and there is a relaxation in requirements for appointing safety managers. This prompted an expert survey aimed at delineating strategies for improvement. A bespoke questionnaire, tailored to address the shortcomings of current legislation, was administered to 50 experts in the realms of decarbonized fuels or safety. Quantitative analysis of their responses revealed a consensus regarding the elevated risk posed by hydrogen and ammonia compared to conventional fuels, with hydrogen (72) deemed riskier than ammonia (65) and LNG (50). Moreover, a pressing need for bolstering the existing safety legal framework was highlighted. Notably, the survey underscored specific areas requiring attention, ranked in order of priority: the enactment of an Ammonia Act (78), augmentation of qualification requirements for safety managers under the Hydrogen Act (73), reinforcement of regulatory and technical standards, implementation of emergency response drills, classification of ammonia as a Class 4 hazardous material (70), and enhancement of criteria for appointing safety managers (59). Insights gleaned from the expert survey culminated in four improvements geared towards enhancing safety measures. There is a need to enact a stand-alone law specifically for ammonia, to strengthen standards for risk assessment and the appointment of safety managers. Additionally, there is a necessity to expand the scope of safety laws to include prevention and education initiatives, while also attempting to consolidate scattered laws for better coherence and effectiveness. This study advocates for comprehensive safety management systems to be established through extensive research preceding the commercialization of power plants utilizing new fuels.
energy & fuels,electrochemistry,chemistry, physical