Abstract:We ask if there are alternative contest models that minimize error or information loss from misspecification and outperform the Pythagorean model. This article aims to use simulated data to select the optimal expected win percentage model among the choice of relevant alternatives. The choices include the traditional Pythagorean model and the difference-form contest success function (CSF). Method. We simulate 1,000 iterations of the 2014 MLB season for the purpose of estimating and analyzing alternative models of expected win percentage (team quality). We use the open-source, Strategic Baseball Simulator and develop an AutoHotKey script that programmatically executes the SBS application, chooses the correct settings for the 2014 season, enters a unique ID for the simulation data file, and iterates these steps 1,000 times. We estimate expected win percentage using the traditional Pythagorean model, as well as the difference-form CSF model that is used in game theory and public choice economics. Each model is estimated while accounting for fixed (team) effects. We find that the difference-form CSF model outperforms the traditional Pythagorean model in terms of explanatory power and in terms of misspecification-based information loss as estimated by the Akaike Information Criterion. Through parametric estimation, we further confirm that the simulator yields realistic statistical outcomes. The simulation methodology offers the advantage of greatly improved sample size. As the season is held constant, our simulation-based statistical inference also allows for estimation and model comparison without the (time series) issue of non-stationarity. The results suggest that improved win (productivity) estimation can be achieved through alternative CSF specifications.

A stochastic model for NFL games and point spread assessment

Modeling and Predicting the Outcomes of NBA Basketball Games

A new probabilistic model: Theory, simulation and applications to sports and failure times data

Modeling the complexity of basketball games using marked mutually exciting point processes

How often does the best team win? A unified approach to understanding randomness in North American sport

A Bayesian Approach to In-Game Win Probability in Soccer

Stochastic model for football's collective dynamics

Converting College Football Point Spread Differentials to Probabilities

iWinRNFL: A Simple, Interpretable & Well-Calibrated In-Game Win Probability Model for NFL

Stochastic modelling of football matches

Modelling handball outcomes using univariate and bivariate approaches

Exploiting oddsmaker bias to improve the prediction of NFL outcomes

Self-affirmation model for football goal distributions

An Analysis of an Alternative Pythagorean Expected Win Percentage Model: Applications Using Major League Baseball Team Quality Simulations

Big ideas in sports analytics and statistical tools for their investigation

Comparing probabilistic predictive models applied to football

Moving from Machine Learning to Statistics: the case of Expected Points in American football

A new statistical distribution with applications to sports and health sciences

Assessing competitive balance in the English Premier League for over forty seasons using a stochastic block model

Bayesian models for prediction of the set-difference in volleyball

Predicting the NFL using Twitter