Abstract:The path towards establishing and advancing human rights’ protection within the EU legal system seemed straightforward a decade ago. With the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty in 2009, the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the EU became part of primary law, together with a commitment of accession to the European Convention on Human Rights. In 2010, Protocol 14 to the ECHR entered into force, allowing the EU to accede to the ECHR. A draft agreement on accession was finalized thereafter. In 2014, however, the Court of Justice of the European Union issued a negative opinion on the draft accession treaty, citing perceived threats to autonomy of EU law, competence of the EU and powers of the Court. A year earlier, in February 2013, the CJEU rendered judgments in cases Fransson and Melloni whereby it provided crucial rules for interpretation of clauses 51(1) and 53, respectively, of the Charter. The field of application of the Charter was equated with the scope of EU law. Primacy, effectiveness and unity of EU law, both primary and secondary, were prioritized over human rights and fundamental freedoms recognized by international agreements, including the ECHR, as well as by the Member States’ constitutions. The realm of fundamental individual rights remains to this day the decisive grounds for asserting the core principle of EU constitutionality: the autonomy of EU law. Accession to the ECHR remains to this day a proclaimed goal of EU governing bodies, but little palpable progress is being made. Protection of fundamental rights at EU level has remained a point of contention among academics. Some question the very need for its existence, in view of constitutional guarantees by Member States and the ECHR. Others, however, claim that the CJEU sacrificed protection of individuals’ rights for the interest of promoting constitutionality of the EU. These critiques seem unwarranted. Article 2 TEU necessitates existence of an efficient mechanism for protection of fundamental freedoms at EU level. Historical examples of political communities built on multi-ethnic, civic model all show necessity of integrating human rights protection at the constitutional level. Constitutionality of the EU has been developing for six decades, for the most part under the guise of autonomy of EU law. It requires that primacy of fundamental rights, as guaranteed by EU law, be affirmed both vis-a-vis Member States and international treaties. However, one may not expect that fundamental rights and freedoms within the EU be protected in a uniform and efficient manner unless a system for enforcing such rights and freedoms is not put in place first.

The impact of ECtHR case-law on the CJEU's interpreting of the EU's return acquis: More than it first seems?

A Bird’s Eye View on ECJ Judgments on Immigration, Asylum and Border Control Cases

ECJ Judges read the morning papers. Explaining the turnaround of European citizenship jurisprudence

Between facts and norms: Testing compliance with Article 8 ECHR in immigration cases

The implementation of the CJEU’s Joined Cases Aranyosi and Caldararu by the UK and Irish Courts – A real impact on the protection of fundamental rights in surrender proceedings?

Spelling It Out−Convergence and Divergence in the Judicial Dialogue between cjeu and ECtHR

The European Court of Justice as a Constitutional Court. Legal Reasoning in a Comparative Perspective

Prison Conditions and Judicial Cooperation in the EU – What Future for the European Arrest Warrant?

The Narrowing of the European Court of Human Rights? Legal Diplomacy, Situational Self-Restraint, and the New Vision for the Court

Evaluation of Member State Provisions Addressing Land Policy and Restitution by the European Commission

ECHR Preamble vs. the European Arrest Warrant: balancing Human Rights protection and the principle of mutual trust in EU Criminal Law?

Is there an EU Copyright Jurisprudence? An Empirical Analysis of the Workings of the European Court of Justice

Beyond EU Borders, Beyond EU Responsibility: The Protection of Asylum-Seekers’ Rights In and Outside the EU. Reflections on the X. & X. and Al Chodor Cases

The Role of the European Court of Justice in the Protection of Human Rights and Freedoms

Impact of ECJ Case Law on the Harmonization of Inheritance and Gift Taxation in the European Union

The Slovenian Constitutional Court and EU Law: Some Aspects and Future Challenges

Quasi-constitutional court of human rights for Europe? Comments on Geir Ulfstein

The Long Walk to Strasbourg: About the Insufficient Judicial Protection in Some Areas of the Common Foreign and Security Policy before the European Union’s Accession to the ECHR

Of Legislative Waves and Case law: Effective Judicial Protection, Right to an Effective Remedy and Proceduralisation in the EU Asylum Policy

A DECADE OF BALANCING WITH EU HUMAN RIGHTS PROTECTION: BETWEEN NATIONAL AND INTERNATIONAL COMPETENCES AND SOURCES OF LAW , INDIVIDUAL AND SYSTEMIC INTERESTS

Effective Judicial Protection and the Regulation Implementing Enhanced Cooperation on the Establishment of the European Public Prosecutor's Office