Abstract:BackgroundRigorous, informative meta-analyses rely on availability of appropriate summary statistics or individual participant data. For continuous outcomes, especially those with naturally skewed distributions, summary information on the mean or variability often goes unreported. While full reporting of original trial data is the ideal, we sought to identify methods for handling unreported mean or variability summary statistics in meta-analysis.MethodsWe undertook two systematic literature reviews to identify methodological approaches used to deal with missing mean or variability summary statistics. Five electronic databases were searched, in addition to the Cochrane Colloquium abstract books and the Cochrane Statistics Methods Group mailing list archive. We also conducted cited reference searching and emailed topic experts to identify recent methodological developments. Details recorded included the description of the method, the information required to implement the method, any underlying assumptions and whether the method could be readily applied in standard statistical software. We provided a summary description of the methods identified, illustrating selected methods in example meta-analysis scenarios.ResultsFor missing standard deviations (SDs), following screening of 503 articles, fifteen methods were identified in addition to those reported in a previous review. These included Bayesian hierarchical modelling at the meta-analysis level; summary statistic level imputation based on observed SD values from other trials in the meta-analysis; a practical approximation based on the range; and algebraic estimation of the SD based on other summary statistics. Following screening of 1124 articles for methods estimating the mean, one approximate Bayesian computation approach and three papers based on alternative summary statistics were identified. Illustrative meta-analyses showed that when replacing a missing SD the approximation using the range minimised loss of precision and generally performed better than omitting trials. When estimating missing means, a formula using the median, lower quartile and upper quartile performed best in preserving the precision of the meta-analysis findings, although in some scenarios, omitting trials gave superior results.ConclusionsMethods based on summary statistics (minimum, maximum, lower quartile, upper quartile, median) reported in the literature facilitate more comprehensive inclusion of randomised controlled trials with missing mean or variability summary statistics within meta-analyses.

Unified approach to optimal estimation of mean and standard deviation from sample summaries

Enhanced Estimation of Population Mean in the Presence of Auxiliary Information

Optimally estimating the sample standard deviation from the five‐number summary

How to estimate the sample mean and standard deviation from the five number summary?

Optimized estimation for population mean using conventional and non-conventional measures under the joint influence of measurement error and non-response

Improved Ratio Type Estimators of Population Mean Based on Median of a Study Variable and an Auxiliary Variable

Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from the sample size, median, range and/or interquartile range

Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from commonly reported quantiles in meta-analysis

Estimating Mean and Standard Deviation from the Sample Size, Three Quartiles, Minimum, and Maximum

Estimating the sample mean and standard deviation from order statistics and sample size in meta-analysis

On Estimating the Selected Treatment Mean under a Two-Stage Adaptive Design

Applications of Sequentially Estimating the Mean in a Normal Distribution Having Equal Mean and Variance

Shrinkage Testimator for the Common Mean of Several Univariate Normal Populations

Dealing with missing standard deviation and mean values in meta-analysis of continuous outcomes: a systematic review

Optimal Subsampling Approaches for Large Sample Linear Regression

Subsampled Optimization: Statistical Guarantees, Mean Squared Error Approximation, and Sampling Method

Bias Reduction in Sample-Based Optimization

Adjusted Variance Estimators Based on Minimizing Mean Squared Error for Stratified Random Samples

Ten circumstances and solutions for finding the sample mean and standard deviation for meta-analysis

Optimality in Mean Estimation: Beyond Worst-Case, Beyond Sub-Gaussian, and Beyond $1+α$ Moments

Double Exponential Ratio Estimator of a Finite Population Variance under Extreme Values in Simple Random Sampling