Abstract:Purpose Investigation of family firm radical innovation is burgeoning but far less prevalent than studies of family firm innovation in general. Concurrently, studies repeatedly report that family firms exhibit mostly conservative and incremental innovation rather than more radical ones. This is unfortunate because without radical innovation, family firms risk a competency trap in which long-term competitiveness is lost to more innovative rivals. This situation has led to urgent calls among scholars to explicitly acknowledge the heterogeneity of family firm innovation and to understand the conditions for family firm radical innovation. Design/methodology/approach A systematic review of 51 papers categorized into four scholarly conversations build the foundation for a critical discussion of each line of inquiry. Findings The authors analyze 51 leading articles and identify four persistent theoretical positions: (1) RBV and capabilities, (2) agency and stewardship, (3) behavioral agency and socioemotional wealth, and (4) the ability and willingness paradox. The authors identify key research problems and research questions needing urgent scholarly and present a framework that captures their complementary and competing assumptions to enable rigorous future research. Originality/value To galvanize and spearhead future research efforts, this paper provides a critical analysis of our understanding of family firm radical innovation with a specific emphasis on the theoretical assumptions at the core of existing investigations and the eight most important research questions in need of answers.

Family firm innovation strategy: contradictions and tradition

Dispersion of Family Ownership and Innovation Input in Family Firms

Managing the Tradition and Innovation Paradox in Family Firms: A Family Imprinting Perspective

Structural Power Distribution Between Family and Non-Family Executives and Innovation Performance in Family Firms

Employee Incentives and Family Firm Innovation: A Configurational Approach

Product Innovation in Family versus Nonfamily Firms: An Exploratory Analysis

Radical innovation in family firms: a systematic analysis and research agenda

A Configurational Approach to Family Firm Innovation

Faultlines in Family SMEs: The U-Shape Effect of Family Control on Innovativeness and Performance

It’s more complicated than we think: The implications of social capital on innovation

Navigating the politics of innovation in family firms: The role of political capital

Innovation in Family Firms: A Systematic Literature Review and Guidance for Future Research

Corporate Entrepreneurship in Family Firms: the Roles of Family Commitment and Long-Term Orientation

Family involvement, family essence, and family-centered non-economic and economic goals in Chinese family firms: A replication study

The New Lyrics of the Old Folks: the Role of Family Ownership in Corporate Innovation

When is Good News Not Good News? Opening Up the Black Box of Innovation for Family Firms

Innovation Through Tradition: The Role of Past Knowledge for Successful Innovations in Family and Non-family Firms

Innovation underperformance, socioemotional wealth and de-familization in family firms

Inertia In Japanese Organizations: Knowledge Management Routines And Failure To Innovate

Managing Strategic Contradictions: A Top Management Model for Managing Innovation Streams

Innovation through tradition in design-intensive family firms