Evidence-Based Treatment in Practice: PCIT Research on Addressing Individual Differences and Diversity Through the Lens of 20 Years of Service
Shawna M Campbell,Tanya Hawes,Kellie Swan,Rae Thomas,Melanie J Zimmer-Gembeck
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PRBM.S360302
IF: 3.974
2023-07-13
Psychology Research and Behavior Management
Abstract:Shawna M Campbell, 1 Tanya Hawes, 1 Kellie Swan, 1 Rae Thomas, 2, 3 Melanie J Zimmer-Gembeck 1, 4 1 School of Applied Psychology, Griffith University, Gold Coast, QLD, Australia; 2 Tropical Australian Academic Health Centre, Townsville, QLD, Australia; 3 College of Medicine and Dentistry, James Cook University, Townsville, QLD, Australia; 4 Griffith Centre for Mental Health, Griffith University, Gold Coast, QLD, Australia Correspondence: Melanie J Zimmer-Gembeck, School of Applied Psychology, Griffith University, Parklands Drive, G40_7.86, Southport, Gold Coast, QLD, 4222, Australia, Tel +61 07 5678 9085, Email Parent–Child Interaction Therapy (PCIT) is an intensive parent support program for caregivers and their children who exhibit difficult-to-manage disruptive behaviors. After more than four decades of research supporting its efficacy for reducing children's disruptive behaviors and improving parent–child relationships, PCIT has become one of the most popular and widely disseminated parenting support programs in the world. The evidence for the efficacy of PCIT can be found in many reviews of randomized clinical trials and other rigorous studies. To add to those reviews, our aim was to provide practical guidance on how PCIT can be part of an evidence-based program for families that depends on practitioner expertise, as well as attention to families' diverse needs. To do this, we describe the evolution of PCIT as practiced in a university-community partnership that has continued for over 20 years, alongside a narrative description of selected and recent findings on PCIT and its use in specific client presentations across four themes. These themes include studies of 1) whether the standard manualized form of PCIT is efficacious across a selection of diverse family situations and child diagnoses, 2) the mechanisms of change that explain why some parents and some children might benefit more or less from PCIT, 3) whether treatment content modifications make PCIT more feasible to implement or acceptable to some families, at the same time as achieving the same or better outcomes, and 4) whether PCIT with structural modifications to the delivery, such as online or intensive delivery, yields similar outcomes as standard PCIT. Finally, we discuss how these directions in research have influenced research and practice, and end with a summary of how the growing attention on parent and child emotion regulation and parents' responses to (and coaching of) their children's emotions has become important to PCIT theory and our practice. Keywords: parent–child interaction therapy, parent support, child externalizing behavior, emotion regulation, autism spectrum disorder, evidence-based practice Externalizing behavior problems during childhood, including aggressive behavior, excessive tantrums, rule-breaking and oppositional defiance, are some of the primary reasons for family distress and requests for professional help. 1,2 Externalizing behaviors (also called disruptive behaviors or problem behaviors) are also troubling because they can result in daycare/school disruptions, academic disengagement and failure, victimization by peers and other relationship or social problems. 3–6 Moreover, children with the most elevated levels of externalizing behavior problems often experience chronic problems without intervention, which has significant detrimental effects on the future health and well-being of the individuals, their families, and their broader communities – especially given increased risk of contact with the criminal justice system. 7,8 To address children's externalizing behavior problems early in life, multiple classic and contemporary theories of child development suggest that working with parents and family relationships is a preferred and effective approach. 9,10 In fact, although there can be multiple causes for externalizing behavior, many children with elevated levels of problems have caregivers who would benefit from learning new or additional skills for parenting. Some of these parents not only need skills because their children are especially challenging, but they can have their own histories of aggression or other behavioral or mental health problems. Thus, we have seen decades of development, implementation, and evaluation of multiple parent training programs that are applicable across of range of child and caregiver problems. Lists guiding practitioners and parents to services identify over 30 manualized evidence-based treatments (EBTs) that aim to reduce child externalizing behavior problems, teach parents skills that can be useful in their caregiving role, and improve parent–child relationships (see the California Evidence-Based Clearinghouse for Chi -Abstract Truncated-
psychology, clinical, multidisciplinary