Abstract:Most empirical studies based on U.S. data suggest that the fiscal multiplier is less than 1 (e.g., Barro and Redlick, 2011). However, Keynes argued that the multiplier would be the largest when markets have failed to the greatest extent in coordinating economic activities (such as during the Great Depression with rampant unemployment and low capacity utilization). As a large developing country with high household saving rates, a large pool of rural labor force, and a wide range of market failures, China offers a unique opportunity to test the Keynesian notion that government expenditures (even as a pure waste of aggregate resources) can have a fiscal multiplier larger than 1 on aggregate income. Perhaps even more exceptional is China’s extensive use of government spending as a major policy tool to stimulate the economy over the past three decades. Based on both aggregate time-series data and panel data from 29 Chinese provinces, we find that the fiscal multiplier in China is larger than 2. We provide a theoretical model with market failures and Monte Carlo analysis to rationalize our empirical findings. Specifically, we build a model that can generate the same multiplier and business cycles observed in China and use the model as a data-generating process to gauge whether structural vector autoregressions can yield consistent estimates of the theoretical multiplier in short samples. Our analysis supports the large multiplier found in China but also suggests that government spending may not necessarily be a free lunch despite the large multiplier.

The Missing Intercept: A Demand Equivalence Approach

Macroeconomic Frameworks: Reconciling Evidence and Model Predictions from Demand Shocks

The aggregate and distributional effects of fiscal stimuli

Can Public Spending Boost Private Consumption?

The consumption multiplier of government spending: the role of substitutability between government spending and leisure

Estimating Fiscal Multipliers by Combining Statistical Identification with Potentially Endogenous Proxies

The Heterogeneous Effects of Government Spending: It’s All About Taxes

Fiscal stimulus with imperfect expectations: Spending vs. tax policy

Aggregate Demand Externalities, Income Distribution, and Wealth Inequality

Fiscal shocks and asymmetric effects: a comparative analysis

Fiscal Policy, International Spillovers, and Endogenous Productivity

Monetary policy, income distribution and semi‐autonomous demand in the US

Functional Forms, Exogenous Shifts, and Economic Surplus Changes

The Euro Area Government Spending Multiplier in Demand‐ and Supply‐Driven Recessions

Private consumption, public consumption and liquidity constraints in developing countries: some empirical evidence

Equivalent-expenditure functions and expenditure-dependent equivalence scales

On the multiplicative effect of government spending (or any other spending for that matter)

Is Government Spending a Free Lunch? -- Evidence from China

Do Different Estimation Methods Lead to Implausible Differences in the Size of the Non-Observed or Shadow Economies? A Preliminary Answer

Desperate times call for desperate measures: government spending multipliers in hard times

SVAR (Mis)Identification and the Real Effects of Monetary Policy Shocks