Whole slide imaging in pathology: advantages, limitations, and emerging perspectives
Liron Pantanowitz,Navid Farahani,Anil Parwani
DOI: https://doi.org/10.2147/PLMI.S59826
2022-01-20
Pathology and Laboratory Medicine International
Abstract:Navid Farahani, 1 Anil V Parwani, 2 Liron Pantanowitz 2 1 Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA, USA; 2 Department of Pathology, University of Pittsburgh School of Medicine, Pittsburgh, PA, USA Significant technologic gains have led to the adoption of innovative digital imaging solutions in pathology. Whole slide imaging (WSI), which refers to scanning of conventional glass slides in order to produce digital slides, is the most recent imaging modality being employed by pathology departments worldwide. WSI continues to gain traction among pathologists for diagnostic, educational, and research purposes. This article provides a technologic review of WSI platforms and covers clinical and nonclinical pathology applications of these imaging systems. Barriers to adoption of WSI include limiting technology, image quality, problems with scanning all materials (eg, cytology slides), cost, digital slide storage, inability to handle high-throughput routine work, regulatory barriers, ergonomics, and pathologists' reluctance. Emerging issues related to clinical validation, standardization, and forthcoming advances in the field are also addressed. Keywords: digital, imaging, microscopy, pathology, validation, whole slide image, telepathology Introduction The era of digital pathology continues to evolve at a rapid pace, primarily driven by developments in technology. Persistent gains in computer processing power, data transfer speeds, advances in software, and cloud storage solutions have enabled the use of digital images for a wide variety of purposes in pathology. As a result, pathology departments have begun utilizing digital imaging for simple tasks (eg, image archiving) and more complex undertakings (eg, telepathology, image analysis). 1–9 Digital imaging modalities have shifted from using cameras to acquire static images toward whole slide imaging (WSI), which is a relatively novel technology. 10 WSI, also commonly referred to as "virtual microscopy", 5 aims to emulate conventional light microscopy in a computer-generated manner. Practically speaking, WSI consists of two processes. The first process utilizes specialized hardware (scanner) to digitize glass slides, which generates a large representative digital image (so-called "digital slide"). The second process employs specialized software (ie, virtual slide viewer) 5,6 to view and/or analyze these enormous digital files. Figure 1 shows an example of a contemporary WSI scanner and virtual slide viewer. During the last decade, a wide range of commercially available WSI instruments have been developed. A list of common WSI systems and their respective vendors is provided in Table 1. These devices are meant to meet the needs of a diverse user base. A list of differences between selected WSI systems is provided in Table 2. Figure 1 (Top) Omnyx whole slide imaging scanner. (Bottom) Omnyx viewer and integrated digital pathology solution that facilitates pathologist workflow. (Images courtesy of Omnyx). Table 1 Present-day commercially available whole slide imaging (WSI) scanners Notes: *Leica was formerly known and operated as Aperio; **Ventana was formerly known and operated as Bioimagene. Table 2 Selected commercial WSI systems Notes: Every attempt was made to include accurate data in this table at the time of writing this article. However, as products continue to be developed by the manufacturers, there may be slight changes to some of these features. "Slide capacity" refers to the total number of slides that can be loaded at one time for scanning. *Scanning speeds listed are for 15 mm × 15 mm area (bright field); **resolutions listed are in microns/pixel; – information unavailable. Abbreviations: WSI, whole slide imaging; 1D, one dimensional; 2D, two dimensional; DICOM, Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine; LCD, liquid-crystal display. The aim of this article is to review the technology and demonstrate the use of WSI for various clinical and nonclinical uses in pathology. Emerging issues related to clinical validation of these digital imaging systems and recent advances in the field are also addressed. History The first WSI scanners, introduced in the late 1990s, were quite primitive compared with their contemporary counterparts. 7 Prior to the introduction of WSI, digital imaging in anatomic pathology relied largely on microscope-mounted cameras to produce "static" digital images. 2 These static images were of limited clinical utility because they captured only specific regions of a glass slide. Robotic microscopy was accordingly utilized becaus -Abstract Truncated-