Abstract:Purpose This paper aims to examine whether social comparison in a prior, nonconsumption circumstance (e.g. in an academic setting) affects consumers' materialism and subsequent spending propensity, and explores the incidental feeling of envy as the underlying mechanism. Design/methodology/approach Four experiments have been conducted to test these hypotheses. Study 1 manipulated social comparison in an academic domain, and measured undergraduate students' materialism after they compared themselves to a superior student or to an inferior student. Study 2 used a recall task to manipulate social comparison and examine the mediating role of envy. Study 3 examined which of the two types of envy (benign or malicious) affected materialism. Study 4 examined the downstream consequences on spending propensity in both public and private consumption contexts. Findings The results suggest that consumers place greater importance on material goods and are more likely to spend money on publicly visible products after making upward social comparisons than after making downward social comparisons or no comparisons. Furthermore, envy acts as the mediator for the observed effect of incidental social comparison on materialism. Originality/value First, this study improves our understanding of the consequences of social comparison and envy by demonstrating that incidental envy (both benign and malicious) experienced in a prior, unrelated social comparison can motivate materialistic pursuits. Second, the present research contributes to the compensatory consumption literature by revealing that, in a social comparison context, envy is the affective underpinning that gives rise to the motivation to engage in compensatory consumer behavior. Third, the findings also enrich materialism research by exploring an important situational antecedent in driving materialistic orientation.

In Pursuit of Happiness: Effects of Mental Subtraction and Alternative Comparison

Impact of material vs. experiential purchase types on happiness: The moderating role of self-discrepancy

Experiential Purchases, Material Purchases, and Happiness: an Introduction

The relative relativity of material and experiential purchases.

Damned if They Do, Damned if They Don't: Material Buyers Are Not Happier from Material or Experiential Consumption

The pursuit of optimal distinctiveness and consumer preferences.

What makes people happy? Decoupling the experiential‐material continuum

Who Can Get More Happiness? Effects of Different Self-Construction and Experiential Purchase Tendency on Happiness

Re-examining the Experiential Advantage in Consumption: A Meta-Analysis and Review

Don't Fall into Exquisite Poverty: the Impact of Mismatch Between Consumers and Luxury Brands on Happiness

Influences of mental accounting on consumption decisions: asymmetric effect of a scarcity mindset

The Spillover Effect of Incidental Social Comparison on Materialistic Pursuits

Negative Emotions Will Be Welcomed: The Effect of Upward Comparison on Counterhedonic Consumption

The effect of material and experiential consumption on goal pursuit

Beyond experiential spending: Consumers report higher well-being from purchases that satisfy intrinsic goals

Benefits Associated with Experiential and Material Purchases May Depend on Culture

Feeling inferior, showing off: The effect of nonmaterial social comparisons on conspicuous consumption

Asserting Your Mind: Interruptions Extremize Consumer Choices

The Influence of Mindset Abstraction on Preference for Mixed Versus Extreme Approaches to Multigoal Pursuits

Imagination Matters when You Shop Online: the Moderating Role of Mental Simulation Between Materialism and Online Impulsive Buying.

Will Materialism Lead to Happiness? A Longitudinal Analysis of the Mediating Role of Psychological Needs Satisfaction