Abstract:Sir: We read with great interest the article entitled “Tissue-Engineered Soft-Tissue Reconstruction Using Noninvasive Mechanical Preconditioning and a Shelf-Ready Allograft Adipose Matrix” by Giatsidis et al.1 The authors showed that the combined use of external volume expansion and an allograft adipose matrix graft for soft-tissue reconstruction led to better tissue preservation compared with adipose tissue grafts, which might transform best practice in the reconstruction of soft-tissue defects. In this communication, we would like to propose our several different perspectives and suggestions, hoping to promote better clinical application of this approach in the future. Initially, the preparation of allograft adipose matrix was not discussed in detail. Did the authors use the same method as in the trial registered at ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02445118?2 We believe that the approach of only 1-propanol (30 minutes) and aqueous sodium deoxycholate (24 hours) to obtain cadaver-derived allograft adipose matrix is too simple to achieve complete decellularization. As shown in Supplemental Digital Content 1, the hydrated acellular matrix was still yellow, which also seemed to confirm incomplete decellularization. What is more, DNA content less than 50 ng/mg of tissue is considered optimal.3 However, the amount of DNA was not measured in this study. Furthermore, as an ionic detergent, aqueous sodium deoxycholate can be very destructive to the structure of the matrix, and its residue can be toxic to cells, causing significant swelling or alteration.4 In recent years, researchers have been seeking a certain balance between complete decellularization and structural preservation. After all, this is very important for the future safety of adipose acellular matrix in clinical applications. So far, Flynn’s nondetergent protocol is considered to be the most effective among all the comprehensive methods.5 In addition, the injection volume of allograft adipose matrix in clinical trials currently ongoing was not large, and most follow-up time was only 4 to 6 months, which did not guarantee that immune rejection after massive injection or chronic rejection would not occur. In terms of analysis of samples, the authors used the cross-sectional area of the graft as a surrogate for graft volume, which would make the final results less scientific and less convincing. Because volume change rate is a key indicator in soft-tissue reconstruction studies, we recommend a quantitative measurement that combines three-dimensional scanning with software to compare volume changes of irregular soft tissues more accurately and conveniently. For the study design, why is the external volume expansion plus fat group not set up? In addition, should the rehydrated allograft adipose matrix be mixed with processed lipoaspirate in equal volume parts rather than the same weight ratio? In the end, we thank the authors specially for the research of combined use of external volume expansion and allograft adipose matrix. DISCLOSURE The authors have no financial disclosure to report in relation to the content of this communication.

Recent Developments in Extracellular Matrix Remodeling for Fat Grafting

Adipose Tissue and Extracellular Matrix Development by Injectable Decellularized Adipose Matrix Loaded with Basic Fibroblast Growth Factor

Preclinical Optimization of a Shelf-Ready, Injectable, Human-Derived, Decellularized Allograft Adipose Matrix.

The Synergetic Roles of Stromal Vascular Fraction (SVF) and Extracellular Matrix (ECM) on Fat Graft Retention in Nude Mice

Adipose-Derived Stem Cells Exosomes Improve Fat Graft Survival by Promoting Prolipogenetic Abilities through Wnt/β-Catenin Pathway

Mechanical force promotes tissue and molecular changes in adipose tissue regeneration post-transplantation

Extracellular matrix grafts: From preparation to application (Review)

Deciphering the Emerging Roles of Adipocytes and Adipose-Derived Stem Cells in Fat Transplantation.

The role of matrix stiffness and viscosity on lipid phenotype and fat lineage potential

Extracellular Matrix Remodeling in Stem Cell Culture: A Potential Target for Regulating Stem Cell Function.

Fat Therapeutics: The Clinical Capacity of Adipose-Derived Stem Cells and Exosomes for Human Disease and Tissue Regeneration

Possible Role of Mechanical Force in Regulating Regeneration of the Vascularized Fat Flap Inside a Tissue Engineering Chamber.

Tissue-Engineered Soft-Tissue Reconstruction Using Noninvasive Mechanical Preconditioning and a Shelf-Ready Allograft Adipose Matrix.

Anti-fibrotic effect of adipose-derived stem cells on fibrotic scars

Advances in Biomaterials for Adipose Tissue Reconstruction in Plastic Surgery

Preparation and characterization of acellular adipose tissue matrix using a combination of physical and chemical treatments

Human Esc-Derived Mscs Enhance Fat Engraftment By Promoting Adipocyte Reaggregation, Secreting Ccl2 And Mobilizing Macrophages

ECM remodeling in stem cell culture: a potential target for regulating stem cell function.

Adipose Tissue Reconstruction Facilitated with Low Immunogenicity Decellularized Adipose Tissue Scaffolds

Letter on "strategies to Improve AFT Volume Retention after Fat Grafting".

Investigating the Adipogenic Effects of Different Tissue-Derived Decellularized Matrices.