Abstract:Poor performance of scoring functions is a well-known bottleneck in structure-based virtual screening (VS), which is most frequently manifested in the scoring functions' inability to discriminate between true ligands vs known nonbinders (therefore designated as binding decoys). This deficiency leads to a large number of false positive hits resulting from VS. We have hypothesized that filtering out or penalizing docking poses recognized as non-native (i.e., pose decoys) should improve the performance of VS in terms of improved identification of true binders. Using several concepts from the field of cheminformatics, we have developed a novel approach to identifying pose decoys from an ensemble of poses generated by computational docking procedures. We demonstrate that the use of target-specific pose (scoring) filter in combination with a physical force field-based scoring function (MedusaScore) leads to significant improvement of hit rates in VS studies for 12 of the 13 benchmark sets from the clustered version of the Database of Useful Decoys (DUD). This new hybrid scoring function outperforms several conventional structure-based scoring functions, including XSCORE::HMSCORE, ChemScore, PLP, and Chemgauss3, in 6 out of 13 data sets at early stage of VS (up 1% decoys of the screening database). We compare our hybrid method with several novel VS methods that were recently reported to have good performances on the same DUD data sets. We find that the retrieved ligands using our method are chemically more diverse in comparison with two ligand-based methods (FieldScreen and FLAP::LBX). We also compare our method with FLAP::RBLB, a high-performance VS method that also utilizes both the receptor and the cognate ligand structures. Interestingly, we find that the top ligands retrieved using our method are highly complementary to those retrieved using FLAP::RBLB, hinting effective directions for best VS applications. We suggest that this integrative VS approach combining cheminformatics and molecular mechanics methodologies may be applied to a broad variety of protein targets to improve the outcome of structure-based drug discovery studies.

Structural Protein–Ligand Interaction Fingerprints (SPLIF) for Structure-Based Virtual Screening: Method and Benchmark Study

SPOT-Ligand: Fast and effective structure-based virtual screening by binding homology search according to ligand and receptor similarity.

Protein-Ligand Empirical Interaction Components For Virtual Screening

SPOT-ligand 2: Improving Structure-Based Virtual Screening by Binding-Homology Search on an Expanded Structural Template Library

SMPLIP-Score: predicting ligand binding affinity from simple and interpretable on-the-fly interaction fingerprint pattern descriptors

Bridging Structure- and Ligand-Based Virtual Screening through Fragmented Interaction Fingerprint

Fine tuning for success in structure-based virtual screening

Advancing Ligand Docking through Deep Learning: Challenges and Prospects in Virtual Screening

A molecular representation to identify isofunctional molecules

Computational representations of protein–ligand interfaces for structure-based virtual screening

S4MPLE—Sampler for Multiple Protein-Ligand Entities: Methodology and Rigid-Site Docking Benchmarking

Cheminformatics Meets Molecular Mechanics: a Combined Application of Knowledge-Based Pose Scoring and Physical Force Field-Based Hit Scoring Functions Improves the Accuracy of Structure-Based Virtual Screening.

On Evaluating Molecular-Docking Methods for Pose Prediction and Enrichment Factors

SG‐ML‐PLAP: A structure‐guided machine learning–based scoring function for protein–ligand binding affinity prediction

Comprehensive Assessment of Flexible-Ligand Docking Algorithms: Current Effectiveness and Challenges

Comparison of Ligand-, Target Structure-, and Protein-Ligand Interaction Fingerprint-based Virtual Screening Methods

True Accuracy of Fast Scoring Functions to Predict High-Throughput Screening Data from Docking Poses: The Simpler the Better

FRAGSITE2: A structure and fragment-based approach for virtual ligand screening

Free resources to assist structure-based virtual ligand screening experiments

Using Interaction Fingerprints as a Strategy of Protein-Ligand Interaction Patterns Recognition and Post-Docking Analysis

Virtual Ligand Screening against Escherichia coli Dihydrofolate Reductase: Improving Docking Enrichment Using Physics-Based Methods