Abstract:Objective: Responding to the concern about racial/ethnic disparities (R/ED) in the use of risk assessment instruments (RAIs) in justice systems, previous research has overwhelmingly tested the extent to which RAI scores consistently predict recidivism across race and ethnicity (predictive bias). However, little is known about R/ED in the association between RAI measures and court dispositions (disparate application) for justice-involved youths. This study investigated predictive bias and disparate application of three risk measures—criminal history, social history, and the overall risk level—produced by the Positive Achievement Change Tool (PACT) for White, Black, and Hispanic justice-involved youths. Hypotheses: Given the mixed evidence in existing research for predictive bias and lack of evidence for disparate application, we did not make any specific hypothesis but conducted exploratory analyses. From a clinical perspective, however, we anticipated little or no evidence to support predictive bias and disparate application of the PACT among White, Black, and Hispanic youths in the jurisdiction we examined. Method: The sample consisted of 5,578 youths (11.4% White, 43.9% Black, and 44.7% Hispanic) who completed the PACT while in the Harris County Juvenile Probation Department, Texas. The outcome variables included recidivism (general and violent reoffending) and court dispositions (deferred adjudication, probation without placement, and probation with placement). We ran a series of moderating binary logistic regression models and moderating ordinal logistic regression models to evaluate predictive bias and disparate application. Results: Race and ethnicity influenced how the criminal history score related to violent recidivism: This compromised the validity of the score as a predictor of recidivism. Moreover, evidence showed that the overall risk of reoffending was associated with harsher sanctioning decisions for Black and Hispanic youths than for White youths. Conclusion: Ensuring that RAI results are consistently interpreted and used in informing decisions is as important as ensuring that RAI scores function equally well in predicting recidivism regardless of race and ethnicity. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2023 APA, all rights reserved)

Cross Racial Identity Scale (CRIS) scores and profiles in African American adolescents involved with the juvenile justice system.

Reliability and Structural Validity of Cross Racial Identity Scale Scores in a Sample of African American Adults

A Study on the Psychometric Properties of Conners Comprehensive Behavior Rating Scales-Self Report Scores in African Americans with Juvenile Court Contact

(Re)Examining Racial Identity Attitude Differences Across Gender, Community Type, and Socioeconomic Status Among African American College Students

Cross's Nigrescence Model: From Theory to Scale to Theory

MACI Scores of African American Males in a Forensic Setting: Are We Measuring What We Think We Are Measuring?

Evaluating Measures of Externalizing Personality Pathology Traits in Black and White American Adolescents in a Program for at-Risk Youths

ADHD symptom frequency and ADHD symptom count clustering in African-American adolescents with juvenile court contact

State-level structural racism and adolescent mental health in the United States

Development of CRIS: measure of community reintegration of injured service members

Measurement invariance of the Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL) across race/ethnicity and sex in the Adolescent Brain and Cognitive Development (ABCD) study.

Perceived parental security profiles in African American adolescents involved in the juvenile justice system.

Reliability, Validity, and Predictive Utility of the 25-item Criminogenic Cognitions Scale (CCS)

Contextual risks and psychosocial outcomes among rural African American emerging adults: A latent profile analysis

IRT Analysis of the Grit-S Scale: Evaluation With Racially/Ethnically Diverse Adolescents in the US

Cultural Trauma Scale: Psychometric evaluation of Black men's beliefs, emotions, and coping.

Cross-Cultural Validity of Sexual Recidivism Risk Assessments Using Static-99R, STABLE-2007, and the VRS-SO

Evaluating the Clinical Utility of the MAYSI-2 Among African American Male Juvenile Offenders

Psychosocial Maturation, Race, and Desistance from Crime

A factor analytic approach to understanding health risk behaviors and resilience among multi-racial/ethnic adolescents in New Mexico

Racial/ethnic disparities of the pact in predicting recidivism and court dispositions for justice-involved youth.