Narratology and narrative theory
Sue-Ann Harding
DOI: https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315640129-5
2021-08-23
Abstract:From its origins in the structuralist study of folktales and literary fiction to the broad and thriving ensemble of narratologies it has become today, narrative has developed into a critical concept adopted and embraced by an array of disciplines. This chapter provides a brief overview of how narrative theory has been used as an analytic tool in translation studies, where it is relatively new, and in history, where for decades it has been a driving force in debates over how we know, study, communicate, and make sense of the past. Hayden White (1928–-2018) was among the most influential scholars in these debates, arguing that historiography could be interrogated using the same narrative tropes used to study literature. Whether this is because narrative is the cognitive tool we use to make sense of our lives, or whether it is because we seek to impose narrative order on chaos lies at the heart of these debates. In both translation studies and history, narrative foregrounds the constructed nature of the narratives we tell to explain and justify actions and events, and the chapter concludes by commenting on the minimal overlap between the two fields, a surprising state of affairs given the shared interest in narrative and yet indicative perhaps of scholars’ struggle to navigate genuine interdisciplinarity. Nevertheless, the theoretical resonances to be found at the points where narrative, history, and translation studies intersect are strong, and the chapter ends by advocating for increased and intense dialogue and collaborations between all three fields. This chapter provides a brief overview of how narrative theory has been used as an analytic tool in translation studies, where it is relatively new, and in history, where for decades it has been a driving force in debates over how we know, study, communicate, and make sense of the past. The movement of narratology to the United States was marked by the significant influence on narrative theory of other disciplines and the adoption of ideas from other ‘diverse theoretical trends’, including psychoanalysis, feminist approaches, critical discourse, rhetoric, cultural studies, comparative literature, post-structuralism, post-modernism, ideological, and ethical approaches. Like translation studies, narratology is marked by its interdisciplinarity, both through its appropriation of, and adoption into, other fields. Translations both have histories and mediate history. The resonances of concerns, interests, and theoretical concepts between all three fields—history, narrative, and translation—surely mean that each field can simultaneously and mutually inform, and be informed by, the other two fields.