Abstract:Crime and perception of safety are two intertwined concepts affecting the quality of life and the economic development of a society. However, few studies have quantitatively examined the difference between the two due to the lack of granular data documenting public perceptions in a given geographic context. Here, by applying a pre-trained scene understanding algorithm, we infer the perception of safety score of streetscapes for census block groups in the city of Houston using a large number of Google Street View images. Then, using this inferred perception of safety, we create “perception bias” categories for each census block group. These categories capture the level of mismatch between people’s visually perceived safety and the actual crime rates. This measure provides scalable guidance in deciphering the relationship between the built environment and crime. Finally, we construct a series of models to examine the “perception bias” with static and dynamic urban factors, including socioeconomic features (e.g., unemployment rate and ethnic compositions), urban diversity (e.g., number and diversity of Points of Interest), and urban livelihood (i.e., hourly count of visitors). Analytical and numerical results suggest that the association between characteristics of urban space and “perception bias” over crime could be paradoxical. On the one hand, neighborhoods with a higher volume of day-time visitors appear more likely to be safer than it looks (low crime rate and low safety score). On the other hand, those with a higher volume of night-time visitors are likely to be more dangerous than it looks (high crime rate). The findings add further knowledge to the long-recognized relationship between built environment and crime as well as highlight the perception of safety in cities, which in turn enhances our capacity to design urban management strategies that prevent the emergence of extreme “perception bias”.

Bridging the perceptual gap: variations in crime perception of businesses at the neighborhood level

“Perception Bias”: Deciphering a Mismatch Between Urban Crime and Perception of Safety

Fear of crime in Brisbane city: revisiting the importance of ‘context’ in the development of fear of crime

Perceived Unsafety and Fear of Crime: The Role of Violent and Property Crime, Neighborhood Characteristics, and Prior Perceived Unsafety and Fear of Crime

Psychological distance and fear of crime: Towards a new understanding of risk perception formation

Place and Perception: Constructions of Community and Safety across Neighborhoods and Residents

Modelling the fear of crime

Neighborhood crime reduction interventions and perceived livability: A virtual reality study on fear of crime

A Multiscale Assessment of the Impact of Perceived Safety from Street View Imagery on Street Crime

Examining impacts of street characteristics on residents' fear of crime: Evidence from a longitudinal study of crime hot spots

Across the wide prairie: Exploring fear of crime in a small Canadian municipality

Predicting perceptions of crime: Community residents’ recognition and classification of local crime problems

Ecological assessments of community disorder: their relationship to fear of crime and theoretical implications

Social Ties, Collective Efficacy, and Crime-Specific Fear in Seattle Neighborhoods

Burglary Victimization, Perceptions of Crime Risk, and Routine Activities: A Multilevel Analysis Across Seattle Neighborhoods and Census Tracts

Integrating Sketch Maps with GIS to Explore Fear of Crime in the Urban Environment: A Review of the Past and Prospects for the Future

A Social-Psychological Process of “Fear of Crime” for Men and Women: Revisiting Gender Differences from a New Perspective

Perceived neighbourhood affluence, mental health and wellbeing influence judgements of threat and trust on our streets: An urban walking study

Assessing Differences in Safety Perceptions Using GeoAI and Survey Across Neighbourhoods in Stockholm, Sweden

Investigating the Spatiotemporal Links Between Disorder, Crime, and the Fear of Crime

Developing a model of perceptions of security and insecurity in the context of crime