Abstract:According to economic theory, an economically rational market agent searching for permanent housing in a particular stage in his/her life cycle should base his/her tenure considerations also by comparing rent to the user costs of homeownership, and among flats with otherwise identical housing services and security will select the cheaper of two alternative tenures. Economic theory perceives rental and owner-occupied housing as ‘communicating vessels’—a change in conditions in one necessarily entails changes in the other. This is called the ‘substitution effect’ and represents an important balancing mechanism in the housing market. Our hypothesis is that if the substitution between rental and owner-occupied housing in particular culture/society is weak, then the demand for owner-occupied housing becomes more income-elastic than vice versa. Consequently, in the case of a weak substitution effect, changes in house prices will closely mimic changes in household incomes, while in the case of a strong substitution effect this relationship will be much weaker. We confirmed our hypothesis by employing both a theoretical model and an empirical analysis of price data. If we assume poor responsiveness of housing supply, the main implication of our findings is that in societies with weak substitution effect between owning and renting we can expect higher house-price volatility and thus a higher chance of price bubbles appearing.

What Drives the Owner-Occupied and Rental Housing Markets? Evidence from an Estimated DSGE Model

Housing Market Spillovers: Evidence from an Estimated DSGE Model

The Effect Of Expectation In Housing Market

Housing Price, Consumption, and Financial Market: Evidence from Urban Household Data in China

Housing Boom-Bust and Price-Rent Dynamics Over the Business Cycle

A Theory of Housing Demand Shocks

The driving forces of China's business cycles: Evidence from an estimated DSGE model with housing and banking

Housing wealth appreciation and heterogeneous household consumption: Evidence from China

House Price, Interest Rate And Macroeconomic Fluctuation: Evidence From Shanghai Real Estate Market

Explaining Inter-Metropolitan Variation in Housing Rents in China

Dynamic Equilibrium of the Housing Market

Expectations, Intermediaries, and the Term Structure of Rental Housing Supply

Does Tourism Contribute to Real Estate Boom? A DSGE Modeling in Small Open Economy

How Does Housing Price Affect Consumption in China: Wealth Effect or Substitution Effect?

How Do Housing Price and Sentiment Affect Consumption Distribution in China?

Impact of weak substitution between owning and renting a dwelling on housing market

Permanent and Transitory Shocks in Owner-Occupied Housing: A Common Trend Model of Price Dynamics

Price-rent dynamics , and business cycles

Housing Price, Housing Rent, and Rent-Price Ratio: Evidence from 30 Cities in China

SERIES House Prices , Expectations , and Time-Varying Fundamentals

Separating the consumption and investment demands for housing: Evidence from urban China