Abstract:Background For more than twenty years, large and generally stable differences in academic achievement and cognitive ability have been reported within Germany. In such studies, the southern regions lead in the west and east, while city-states lag behind. Expressed in school learning time, the students in Bavaria are 14 months ahead of the students in Bremen. It is striking that there are no or only marginally received studies on causes and consequences. Purpose This study attempts to explore the causes and consequences of the differences within Germany and what can be learned in general about their development. Materials and methods We use data from student assessment and other studies (e.g., PISA, IQB) and apply correlational and path analyses, controlled for various background factors. Results There are no stable correlations with evolution (genes), educational level of society (adult school years) and wealth (GDP per capita). However, there are high correlations, robust across indicators, with "burgher-conservative" education policies, e.g., central exit examinations, early tracking, grades at a young age (around r ≈ .65); with measures of students' quantity of education (hours of instruction, no teacher shortage; r ≈ .40); with measures of tertiary educational quality and appreciation of education (university quality, short duration of studies, professors' salaries; r ≈ .50); with student native/immigrant ratio ( r ≈ .50); with middle-class burgher lifestyle (less private debt, less welfare dependency and less crime; r ≈ .60); and with burgher-conservative-right politics (share of votes for CDU/CSU and non-left parties, non-left state governments; r ≈ .80). Longitudinal analyses over four decades reveal interaction effects, i.e., more burgher policies statistically lead to more cognitively competent students ( β ≈ .45) and more cognitively competent populations vote for burgher parties ( β ≈ .30). Conclusions The results, which support the efficacy a bourgeois-conservative education policy and of lower immigration rates, are delicate for the practice of student achievement research and for the political milieu that dominates the social sciences.

Talent, Effort or Social Background?

Unravelling socioeconomic school composition effects on higher education enrollment: the role of students’ individual and shared feelings of futility and self-efficacy

Grade 12 students' perceptions of educational tracks in Flanders

How teachers form educational expectations for students: A comparative factorial survey experiment in three institutional contexts

School staff's views on causes of early school leaving in regular secondary and adult education: Identifying the role of individual, job‐related and school climate characteristics

The Influence of Social Background on Participation in Adult Education

Socio-economic and Ethnic Inequalities in Social Capital from the Family among Labour Market Entrants

Academic failure and psychological disengagement: can belief in school meritocracy make a difference?

The long-term differential achievement effects of school socioeconomic composition in primary education: A propensity score matching approach

Explaining academic-track boys' underachievement in language grades: Not a lack of aptitude but students' motivational beliefs and parents' perceptions?

Unequal expectations? Testing decisional mechanisms for secondary effects of social origin

Parental SES and family support as predictors of educational level: Testing the buffering effect of effortful control and peer support

Why are there differences across German states in student achievement and cognitive ability?

The culture of futility and its impact on study culture in technical/vocational schools in Belgium

Socioeconomic origin, future expectations, and educational achievement: A longitudinal three-generation study of the persistence of family advantage.

Students’ Occupational Aspirations: Can Family Relationships Account for Differences Between Immigrant and Socioeconomic Groups?

Parental involvement in secondary education in Belgium, France and Luxembourg: Associations with family and school characteristics

Talent or effort? Parents’ explanations of their children’s mathematical performance in relation to mathematical competence

Children’s conversion of cultural capital into educational success: the symbolic and skill-generating functions of cultural capital

Student perceptions of assessment and student self-efficacy in competence-based education

Two Forms of Social Inequality in Students' Socio-Emotional Skills: Do the Levels of Big Five Personality Traits and Their Associations With Academic Achievement Depend on Parental Socioeconomic Status?