Mismatch between the Optimal Ages for Gross Primary Production and Net Ecosystem Production in Norway Spruce Forests

Junbin Zhao,Holger Lange,Helge Meissner

DOI: https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3993190

2021-01-01

SSRN Electronic Journal

Abstract:The stand age plays a crucial role in controlling the productivity and net carbon dioxide (CO2) sequestration of forests. Forest management usually determines the rotation age based on the timber productivity for the best economic benefit. On the other hand, for climate change mitigation, the optimal age for CO2 sequestration also needs be considered as an important parameter in forest management. Therefore, it is important to determine the optimal ages for the productivity and CO2 sequestration separately and investigate whether they are different. In this study, we focused on Norway spruce forests and used eddy-covariance-based observations of carbon fluxes from eight sites to investigate the responses of ecosystem CO2 fluxes to stand age variations via machine learning models. The net ecosystem production (NEP), as an indication of the net ecosystem CO2 sequestration, peaked at ages of 20-40 yr. This NEP peak did not overlap with the peak of gross primary production (GPP), which appeared later at ages of 60-85 yr. To our knowledge, this is the first study that provides empirical evidence of a mismatch between optimal ages for CO2 sequestration and forest productivity. Considering the climate variability over areas where Norway spruce forests are distributed, we found young stands (30 yr) tend to have a higher NEP than mature (90 yr) and old stands (180 yr) in most areas. Under the “middle-of-the-road” SSP2-4.5 scenario of climate projections, the NEP of Norway spruce forests is likely to increase in most areas of Europe over 2021-2040 and these responses of NEP are generally similar among different age groups. Overall, this study investigated forest CO2 fluxes with respect to the stand age, suggesting both forest productivity and CO2 sequestration should be considered separately in forest management to find pathways towards constrained optimization of these important ecosystem services of forests.