Chemical speciation and health risk assessment of potentially toxic elements in playground soil of bell metal commercial town of Eastern India
Laha, Tanmay,Gupta, Nitu,Pal, Mousumi,Koley, Apurba,Masto, Reginald Ebin
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10653-024-02240-8
2024-09-26
Environmental Geochemistry and Health
Abstract:Contaminated playground soils can expose players to harmful pollutants, increasing the risk of respiratory, skin, and gastrointestinal issues and potentially impacting long-term health and development. This study investigated the chemical forms and the human health risks associated with potentially toxic elements (PTEs) found in playground soil samples from Khagra, a historic town known for its bell metal industry, located in the Murshidabad district of eastern India. Sequential extraction techniques were employed to analyze the distribution of PTEs such as As, Cd, Co, Cu, Mn, Pb, Ni, Sn, and Zn among different fractions: exchangeable (F1), bound to carbonate phase (F2), bound to iron and manganese oxides (F3), bound to organic matter (F4), and residual (F5). The playground soil showed the highest contamination with Sn, with an I POLL value of 3.14, indicating moderate to heavy contamination, while Cd, Cu, Mn, Pb, and Zn exhibit moderate contamination. The mean concentration of PTEs in all fractions (F1–F5) follows the order: Fe > Zn > Cu > Mn > Pb > Sn > Ni > Co > As > Cd. The maximum affinity of PTEs and their percentages are as follows: Fe (F5, 80.6%), As (F5, 55.31%), Cd (F5, 48.8), Co (F5, 64.9%), Mn (F3, 44%), Ni (F5, 53.2%), Pb (F3, 44.7%), Zn (F3, −43.19%), Sn (F3, 55%), Cu (F5 −42.18). As, Cd, Co, Cu, Fe, and Ni have a high affinity for F5, indicating geogenic source, while Mn, Pb, Sn, and Zn have a high affinity for F3, indicating anthropogenic source. Fe–Mn oxide partition was dominant for nearly all PTEs due to elevated sorption of cations onto Fe–Mn oxides at high pH. The risk assessment code for Cd, Cu, Mn, Ni, Sn, and Zn in playground soil is categorized under moderate risk, below 30%, while other elements showed no risk. Also, mobility factors were calculated for each PTEs, suggesting the degree of mobility that PTEs can easily migrate and be taken up, absorbed, or adsorbed by the human body. The mobility factor in playground soil was higher for Sn (59.89%) followed by Mn (54.24%) > Pb (52.91%) > Zn (52.01%) > Cd (39.49%) > Ni (33.20%) > As (30.39%) > Co (26.56%) > Cu (21.24%) > Fe (11.20%). Risk hazard quotients for children and adults were found to follow the order: Pb (0.263; 0.040), Cu (0.098; 0.015) > As(0.056; 0.008) > Mn (0.045; 0.009) > Zn(0.36; 0.05) > Cd(0.006; 0.001) > Ni (0.004; 0.001) > Co (0.001; 0.0). PTEs detected in the environment result from atmospheric deposition from small-scale metallurgical industries (bell metal and brass), coal and oil combustion, civil works, municipal waste incineration, and fugitive emissions from road dust. The human non-carcinogenic health risk for PTEs from ingestion and dermal contact was higher than that from inhalation. In the context of carcinogenic risk, As shows the highest health risk of 2.51E-05, followed by Cd (1.02E−09) and Co (8.14E−09). This study uniquely assesses the chemical speciation of PTEs in playground soils, revealing their geogenic and anthropogenic sources, and evaluates associated health risks. Policy intervention is vital for monitoring and remediating PTEs in playgrounds to protect children's health.
environmental sciences,engineering, environmental,water resources,public, environmental & occupational health