Abstract:This study investigated the comparative efficacy of two instructional approaches—didactic teaching and self-instructional training—in teaching average and poor readers a comprehension question-answering strategy. Forty-five average students and 45 poor readers from Grades 5 and 6 participated. These 38 girls and 52 boys were equally and randomly assigned to one of three treatment conditions: didactic teaching of the strategy, self-instruction, or control (no training). Students in the first two treatment conditions learned a mnemonic strategy (“Here,” “Hidden,” and “in my Head”) to indicate question-answer relationships that are text explicit, text implicit, or script implicit, respectively. Essentially, the 3H mnemonic cued students to use appropriate text and/or knowledge-base information in answering comprehension test questions. In addition, students in the self-instruction group learned three self-questions to guide their use of the 3H strategy. Specifically, the self-questions focused students' attention on the task, provided a basis for decision making concerning the categorization of comprehension test questions, and reminded students to check their answers. The results indicated that both didactic teaching and self-instructional training of the strategy effected significant improvements in students' reading comprehension performance. However, self-instructional training was more effective in enhancing and maintaining students' reading comprehension performance than didactic teaching. Moreover, results from the oral questionnaire indicated that the 3H strategy training increased students' general metacognitive knowledge. Lastly, of the 60 trained students, 52 wrote that they would encourage other children to leant the 3H strategy. Thus, the response to strategy learning was clearly positive.

Teaching High School Students to Identify Main Ideas in Expository Text

Identification of main ideas in expository texts: selection versus deletion

Children's ability to comprehend main ideas in content textbooks

Strategy Instruction to Support Struggling Readers in Comprehending Expository Main Ideas

A Review of Summarizing and Main Idea Interventions for Struggling Readers in Grades 3 Through 12: 1978–2016

Teaching Secondary English Learners to Understand, Analyze, and Write Interpretive Essays About Theme

The Frequency and Placement of Main Ideas in Children's Social Studies Textbooks: A Modified Replication of Braddock's Research on Topic Sentences

Comparing Two Modes of Teaching a Question-Answering Strategy for Enhancing Reading Comprehension

Effects of Historical Reasoning Instruction and Writing Strategy Mastery in Culturally and Academically Diverse Middle School Classrooms.

A Systematic Analysis of Studies on Main Idea Teaching in Turkey

Teaching Students With Intellectual Disability to Use a Self-Questioning Strategy to Comprehend Social Studies Text for an Inclusive Setting

Leveling the Playing Field: The Efficacy of Thinking Maps on English Language Learner Students’ Writing

Think-Aloud: Effect on Adolescent Deaf Students' Use of Reading Comprehension Strategies

Writing expository essays from social studies texts: a self-regulated strategy development study

Effect of Story-Continuation Writing Task on High School Students’ Writing

Analysis of Students' Difficulties in Determining the Main Idea in Reading Texts in Class V

Reading to Learn: Effects of Combined Strategy Instruction on High School Students

Integrating STAD and flipped learning in expository writing skills: Impacts on students’ achievement and perceptions

Vocabulary and Main Idea Reading Intervention Using Text Choice to Improve Content Knowledge and Reading Comprehension of Adolescents With Autism Spectrum Disorder

Structure Strategy Interventions: Increasing Reading Comprehension of Expository Text.

Teaching Students with Learning Disabilities to Mindfully Plan When Writing