Varying Performance of Low-Cost Sensors During Seasonal Smog Events in Moravian-Silesian Region
Václav Nevrlý,Michal Dostál,Petr Bitala,Vít Klečka,Jiří Sléžka,Pavel Polách,Katarína Nevrlá,Melánie Barabášová,Růžena Langová,Šárka Bernatíková,Barbora Martiníková,Michal Vašinek,Adam Nevrlý,Milan Lazecký,Jan Suchánek,Hana Chaloupecká,David Kiča,Jan Wild
DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/atmos15111326
IF: 3.11
2024-11-04
Atmosphere
Abstract:[d=(R1), comment= was reformulated according to suggestion of the Reviewer1]Air pollution monitoring in industrial regions like Moravia-Silesia faces challenges due to complex environmental conditions. Low-cost sensors offer a promising, cost-effective alternative for supplementing data from regulatory-grade air quality monitoring stations. This study evaluates the accuracy and reliability of a prototype node containing low-cost sensors for carbon monoxide (CO) and particulate matter (PM), specifically tailored for the local conditions of the Moravian-Silesian Region during winter and spring periods. An analysis of the reference data observed during the winter evaluation period showed a strong positive correlation between PM, CO, and NO2 concentrations, attributable to common pollution sources under low ambient temperature conditions and increased local heating activity. The Sensirion SPS30 sensor exhibited high linearity during the winter period but showed a systematic positive bias in PM10 readings during Polish smog episodes, likely due to fine particles from domestic heating. Conversely, during Saharan dust storm episodes, the sensor showed a negative bias, underestimating PM10 levels due to the prevalence of coarse particles. Calibration adjustments, based on the PM1/PM10 ratio derived from Alphasense OPC-N3 data, were initially explored to reduce these biases. For the first time, this study quantifies the influence of particle size distribution on the SPS30 sensor's response during smog episodes of varying origin, under the given local and seasonal conditions. In addition to sensor evaluation, we analyzed the potential use of data from the Copernicus Atmospheric Monitoring Service (CAMS) as an alternative to increasing sensor complexity. Our findings suggest that, with appropriate calibration, selected low-cost sensors can provide reliable data for monitoring air pollution episodes in the Moravian-Silesian Region and may also be used for future adjustments of CAMS model predictions.This study examines the varying performance of low-cost sensors during seasonal smog events, particularly those resulting from solid fuel combustion linked to residential or industrial heating and other pollution sources. A prototype low-cost sensor node developed within this work was collocated for several months with reference equipment at an air quality monitoring station in the city of Ostrava (the Moravian-Silesian region, Czech Republic). The deterioration of air quality during a pair of smog alert events, namely wintertime "Polish smog" episode and springtime "Saharan dust storm", which occurred through the extended period of co-location, was characterized quantitatively based on particulate matter and carbon monoxide concentrations measured by the low-cost sensors. These datasets were compared with reference data and model predictions provided by the Copernicus Atmospheric Monitoring Service. Selected low-cost sensors demonstrated a linear response during the Polish smog episode with a highly correlated time series of carbon monoxide and particulate matter concentrations. However, when compared to the reference data, the Sensirion SPS30 sensor is found to overestimate coarse particle (PM10) concentrations by the factor of two during the winter evaluation period. On the other hand, oppositely biased PM10 response (underestimation by the factor of five) was determined from the co-location measurement during the Saharan dust storm event. This observation was attributed to combination of the specific detection efficiency of the given low-cost sensor and shifts in particle size distribution due to seasonal change of ambient conditions.
environmental sciences,meteorology & atmospheric sciences