Abstract:The inhibition effect of corporate governance and internal control on earnings management is directly related to the effective functioning of resource allocation in the securities market, thereby bearing great research significance.Due to the great differences in accrual earnings management and real earnings management methods and their economic consequences, it has been a core issue concerned by regulatory departments as for how to better the governance mechanism of accrual and real earnings management.Director linkage, as a special information transmission channel between firms, is being widely adopted by firms.However, there has been no empirical evidence to directly indicate whether or not independent director linkage has an inhibition effect on accrual and real earnings management.Besides, since the promulgation of Section 404 of the SOX Act, firms have been hoping to control earnings management with high-quality internal control.Although some literuture suggests internal control can inhibit the accrual earnings management, no consistent conclusion has been reached on real earnings management.Based on the above analyses, this paper tries to make some improvements on these aspects. To examine the impact of external independent director linkage mechanism and internal control mechanism on corporate earnings management, this paper selects the dataset of 2007-2015 A-share listed firms in China and solves the possible endogenous problems using 1:1 pairing and difference-in-difference method.Ultimately, this paper examines the governance effect of independent director linkage and internal control on accrual and real earnings management, and meanwhile explores their interactions.Our results show that both internal control and independent director linkage can significantly inhibit accrual earnings management, and there is a clear substitutional association between the internal and external governance mechanisms.We also find that only internal control can significantly inhibit real earnings management, with independent director linkage failing to do it, and meanwhile there is no significant substitutional relationship found between them. Further analysesshow internal control has a significant inhibition effect on upward and downward accrual management, while the role of independent director linkage is mainly on the upward aspect, with a partially substitutional relationship between independent director linkage and internal control; internal control has a significant inhibition effect on production cost, operational cash flow and discretionary cost manipulation, while independent director linkage, although having no obvious effect on the overall real earnings management, shows certain governance effect on the production cost manipulation.Additionally, compared with internal control, the governance effect of independent director linkage is more susceptible to the influence of enterprise strategy, and internal control has a more comprehensive and stable inhibition effect on earnings management.In short, this paper shows that independent director linkage and internal control have different effects on accrual and real earnings management, and the internal and external governance mechanisms can be mutually substituted to a certain degree. These findings shed new light on the positive role of independent director linkage and internal control in the governance of earnings management, thereby bearing great significance for regulatory authorities and firms.Firstly, in order to respond to the call for the healthy development of the securities market, regulatory authorities should firmly implement the systems related to internal control.Secondly, whether it is for corporate shareholders or regulatory authorities, much attention should be paid to the governance role of independent director linkage.Thirdly, inhibiting earnings management may start from the two aspects of independent director linkage and internal control, but firms need to weigh the governance cost and the effect to be obtained, and be aware that internal control has a more comprehensive and stable inhibition effect on earnings management.

Internal Control Weakness Disclosure and Earnings Management

Individual Investors' Perceptions of Risk Associated with Internal Control Deficiency Information Disclosure:An Experimental Study

Disclosure of internal control evaluation reports of Chinese enterprises: History, problems and strategies

The Governance Effect of Independent Director Linkage and Internal Control on Earnings Management

Internal Control Deficiencies Disclosure,Motivated Selectivity and Economic Consequences

Element Analysis of Management's Internal Control Deficiencies Disclosure Activity——Based on the View of the Motivated Selectivity in the Internal Control Information Disclosure

Internal Control Deficiencies of Listed Companies and Quality of Financial Information

Analysis of the Relationship between Listed Companies’ Earnings Quality and Internal Control Information Disclosure

Internal Control Weakness: A Literature Review

Internal Control Deficiency Type And Real Earnings Management-Based On The Perspective Of Financial Distress

Determinants of the Discovery and Reporting of Internal Control Deficiencies over Financial Reporting

The Impact Of Internal Control Audit On Real Earnings Management Behaviors

Determinants and economic consequences of voluntary disclosure of internal control weaknesses in China

Positive Research on Information Disclosure of Internal Control Defects

Does the Disclosure of Internal Control Deficiency Matter for Accrual Quality? Evidence from China

The Role of Internal Control Disclosure in Financial Reporting Precision and the Quality of Audited Financial Reports

Mandatory internal control and earnings management

How Does the Heterogeneity of Internal Control Weaknesses Affect Financial Reports? Evidence in Chinese Context

Empirical Study Of Corporate Governance'S Impact On Internal Control Deficiency Disclosure

Determinants of Disclosure of Internal Control Deficiencies over Financial Reporting——Empirical Study of the Listed Companies of Shenzhen Stock Exchange

Research on the Relationship between Internal Control Quality and Earnings Management under the Adjustment of Ownership Structure—Empirical Analysis Based on the A-share Listed Companies in Shanghai and Shenzhen