Resident Attitudes Toward Geriatric Psychiatry Subspecialty and Needs Assessment for a Geriatric Psychiatry Curriculum: A Qualitative Study
Wayles Haynes,Heidi Rishel Brakey,Christopher Abbott,Alexandra Roesch,Julie Salvador
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jagp.2024.01.144
IF: 7.996
2024-02-22
American Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry
Abstract:Introduction The Institute of Medicine estimates that by 2030, up to 14.4 million Americans aged 65 years or older will have mental health or substance use disorders. Despite increasing demand for mental health services for older adults, there are not enough geriatric psychiatrists to serve their needs. Nationally the number of geriatric psychiatry fellows has declined from 106 during 2002-2003 to 48 during 2020-2021. Scholarship investigating the decline of geriatric psychiatry fellowships in the last 20 years indicates formative educational experiences play a key role in subspecialty recruitment. Understanding general psychiatry residents' needs and attitudes could positively influence the strength and sustainability of geriatric psychiatry. Identifying resident attitudes and needs for learning about geriatric psychiatry could guide the design of curriculum that may impact attitudes and decrease barriers to fellowship. Methods In January 2023, we recruited residents to participate in two focus groups, one each with the PGY-1 and PGY-2 general psychiatry residents at UNM (n=10). Study investigators trained in qualitative research techniques and conversant with the field of geriatric psychiatry facilitated the groups. Questions asked for residents' general impressions of geriatric psychiatry, perceived challenges and benefits relating to caring for these patients, and what kinds of information they believe is needed to competently treat this population. Qualitative researchers analyzed transcriptions using an iterative, thematic, team-based approach. Results Residents shared attitudes about the benefits and challenges related to the subspecialty. Negative attitudes toward the subspecialty included beliefs that geriatric psychiatry was too demanding, too complex, and lacked personal value or meaning. Challenges with patients include moral injury, lack of connection to patients, perceived deficits of knowledge, low confidence in management, and futility of care. Challenges with the system include inadequate resources, stigma, and discrimination towards patients. Positive attitudes towards and benefits of geriatric psychiatry subspecialty, patients and the system were of rewarding and meaningful interactions with patients in an engaging and impactful field. The targeted needs assessment for a geriatric psychiatry curriculum found learners value teaching on managing complex pharmacology, medical comorbidities, late-life physiology and developmental theory. Additionally, they requested more in-depth teaching on cognitive testing, palliative care, end of life conversations and legal/ethical concerns. Conclusions Psychiatric subspecialty choice is heavily impacted by clinical and didactic experiences during residency. Results from these focus groups provide insight into perceptions and experiences of some general psychiatry residents in the PGY-1 and PGY-2 years of training at UNM. Negative attitudes expressed by residents portrays burnt-out geriatric psychiatrists performing an intellectually and emotionally demanding job in a resource-poor and overburdened system. Positive attitudes and perceived benefits picture a stimulating and rewarding work life that provides meaningful connections to patients and families while performing a valuable and highly needed service. These perspectives have the power to influence the training and practice decisions of trainees. To better serve the geriatric psychiatry population, negative attitudes and challenges must be addressed. The results of these focus groups have been used to modify the PGY-1 and PGY-2 geriatric psychiatry curriculum at the University of New Mexico using the affective context learning theory. Future research will investigate if the geriatric psychiatry curriculum modified to address attitudes and interests of the student population can impact attitudes toward the subspeciality and increase participation in the field of geriatric psychiatry.
psychiatry,geriatrics & gerontology,gerontology