Collaborative information seeking (CIS) behavior of LIS students and undergraduate students: An exploratory case study

Shabnam Shirley Shahvar,Rong Tang

DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/meet.2014.14505101106

2014-01-01

Proceedings of the American Society for Information Science and Technology

Abstract:This study investigates the collaborative information seeking (CIS) behavior among three different user groups: LIS students, undergraduates, and a mixture of LIS and undergraduate students. Each group consisted of a pair of participants. Out of 28 participants, 16 were graduate students of library and information science and 12 were undergraduates from different majors. Results of this case study revealed that undergraduate groups visited library website and library databases more frequently than other groups. They had the highest average frequency in reading an abstract or a full text article compared to two other groups. Undergraduate groups also held the highest success rate. Mixed groups had the highest frequency of verbal dialogue and spent the longest time on tasks. Most of the LIS student groups found search results faster and spent the shortest time on completing tasks and reading the abstract and full texts. Surprisingly, LIS groups had the lowest success rate among the three groups. Participants described the positive aspects of collaborative search as gaining greater search insights, good learning process, positive partnership and being more efficient with task completion. They also pointed out that collaboration drawbacks may include not having equal control/sharing of keyboard or mouse and other obstacles in the collaborative decision‐making process. Participants further provided suggestions on database and search engine design to facilitate the collaborative search process.