Abstract:Offshore wind farms generate underwater noise during construction, operation and decommissioning. Different foundation designs are in use for offshore wind farms. Steel monopiles, jackets made of four steel pinpiles and gravity-based foundations are applied in the Belgian part of the North Sea. Both monopiles and jacket pinpiles are hammered into the bottom and as such excessive noise is generated during their installation. This paper aims at comparing the emitted underwater noise generated during the piling activities of two wind farms, each using a different type of pile foundation: steel monopiles were used in the Belwind wind farm (Bligh Bank), while jacket pinpiles were chosen for the C-Power project (phases 2 and 3) on the Thorntonbank. Underwater noise was measured from a rigid hull inflatable boat at various distances from the pile driving location during the installation of steel monopiles and pinpiles. Analysis focused on the quantification of the discontinuous impulsive pile driving-generated underwater noise. Zero to peak sound pressure level (Lz-p), unweighted sound exposure level (SEL), cumulative SEL and 1/3 octave spectra were computed in order to quantify and compare the underwater noise. Lz-p and SEL were normalized to 750 m distance from the piling location. Piling of the monopiles generated a Lz-p between 179 and 194 dB re 1μPa. Although piling of the smaller pinpiles was expected to be less noisy, no significant differences with monopiling could be demonstrated (pinpiling Lz-p: 172-189 dB re 1 μPa). Similarly, also SEL, varying between 145 and 168 dB re 1 μPa2s, exerted no statistical difference between monoand pinpiling and furthermore near identical spectra were measured for both types of piling. The rather wide variability within and broad overlap between both types of piling can possibly be attributed to the (small scale) differences in bottom type as well as in the setup used. However, the radius of discomfort in the harbour porpoise Phocoena phocoena was estimated at 30 km and 19 km for monopiles and pinpiles, respectively. Furthermore, the pinpiling (four pinpiles per foundation) took about 2.5 times more time than the monopiling and will as such have a prolonged impact onto the marine fauna. When standardised to megawatt installed (3 MW turbines on the monopiles and 6 MW turbines on the jacket foundations) both types of piling will score about equally.

Measurements and Spatial Distribution Simulation of Impact Pile Driving Underwater Noise Generated During the Construction of Offshore Wind Power Plant Off the Southwest Coast of Korea

A Poroelastic Model for Near-Field Underwater Noise Caused by Offshore Monopile Driving

Pile driving noise impacts behavioral patterns of important East Asian juvenile marine fishes

Characterization of impact pile driving signals during installation of offshore wind turbine foundations

Three-Dimensional Semi-Analytical Model For Predicting Offshore Pile Driving Noise

Comprehensive analysis of the seismic wave fields generated by offshore pile driving: A case study at the BARD Offshore 1 offshore wind farm

A semi-analytical model for predicting underwater noise radiated from offshore pile driving

Underwater Noise Characteristics of Offshore Exploratory Drilling and Its Impact on Marine Mammals

Modeling of Offshore Pile Driving Noise Using A Semi-Analytical Variational Formulation

Validation of a finite element modelling approach for mitigated and unmitigated pile driving noise prognosis

A multi-physics approach for modelling noise mitigation using an air-bubble curtain in impact pile driving

Chapter 10 . Differentiating between underwater construction noise of monopile and jacket foundation wind turbines : A case study from the Belgian part of the North Sea

Closed Form Solutions for Predicting Lateral Response of Tripod Suction Pile for Offshore Wind Turbine Foundation

A numerical study on the effect of asymmetry on underwater noise emission in offshore monopile installation

Theoretical investigation of the effects of the cushion on reducing underwater noise from offshore pile driving.

Recording and Analyzing Underwater Noise During Pile Driving for Bridge Construction

A Study on the Effect of Different Modeling Parameters on the Dynamic Response of a Jacket-Type Offshore Wind Turbine in the Korean Southwest Sea

Model Tests on the Long-Term Dynamic Performance of Offshore Wind Turbines Founded on Monopiles in Sand

Scaling laws for mitigated pile driving: Dependence of underwater noise on strike energy, pile diameter, ram weight, water depth, and mitigation systema)

Characteristics of Breaking Wave Forces on Piles over a Permeable Seabed

Improvement for Marine Environmental Impact Assessment on the Development of Offshore Wind Power